Camp Cook
-
And everybody else is wrong....but you and the one guy out there that you found that thought Buckner was better.
By "one guy" do you mean the official NFL draft board?
Hey, I guess if I had to pick "one guy", I could do worse than the NFL.
Then again, I'm arguing with a guy who thinks there's no difference between the 3-4 and the 4-3...
By "one guy" do you mean the official NFL draft board?
Hey, I guess if I had to pick "one guy", I could do worse than the NFL.
Then again, I'm arguing with a guy who thinks there's no difference between the 3-4 and the 4-3...
There is NO official NFL draft board. There are 32 official NFL draft boards.....those kept by the teams. Everything else is unofficial.
NFL.com produces articles by writers. Their rankings are no more official than Kiper's.
And like I said, you found one source.
List 10 others and see what they say.
-
-
By "one guy" do you mean the official NFL draft board?
Hey, I guess if I had to pick "one guy", I could do worse than the NFL.
Then again, I'm arguing with a guy who thinks there's no difference between the 3-4 and the 4-3...
There is NO official NFL draft board. There are 32 official NFL draft boards.....those kept by the teams. Everything else is unofficial.
NFL.com produces articles by writers. Their rankings are no more official than Kiper's.
And like I said, you found one source.
List 10 others and see what they say.
There is NO official NFL draft board. There are 32 official NFL draft boards.....those kept by the teams. Everything else is unofficial.
NFL.com produces articles by writers. Their rankings are no more official than Kiper's.
And like I said, you found one source.
List 10 others and see what they say.
So if none of these are official, I'll just choose to believe the NFL endorsed opinion rather than any cut rate third party opinion out there.
Good to know we're in agreement.
-
There is NO official NFL draft board. There are 32 official NFL draft boards.....those kept by the teams. Everything else is unofficial.
NFL.com produces articles by writers. Their rankings are no more official than Kiper's.
And like I said, you found one source.
List 10 others and see what they say.
So if none of these are official, I'll just choose to believe the NFL endorsed opinion rather than any cut rate third party opinion out there.
Good to know we're in agreement.
So if none of these are official, I'll just choose to believe the NFL endorsed opinion rather than any cut rate third party opinion out there.
Good to know we're in agreement.
So....if the Browns have the #2 pick....and Bosa and Buckner are both available....who would you take?
-
So if none of these are official, I'll just choose to believe the NFL endorsed opinion rather than any cut rate third party opinion out there.
Good to know we're in agreement.
So....if the Browns have the #2 pick....and Bosa and Buckner are both available....who would you take?
So....if the Browns have the #2 pick....and Bosa and Buckner are both available....who would you take?
Myles Jack...
-
guess I've gotta break my own rule and argue with Gip.... Jesus.
its hilarious that you ask for multiple sources from people when your "source" was "there was a guy who said something once in the not so recent past, and I blindly agree without doing any independent player evaluation."
I've gotta respect your dogged, Skip Bayless style approach, but here's the thing, Gip. Your personal worth isn't directly tied to being 100% correct on your first take. You don't have to be Skip Bayless and make paper thin arguments and excuses which back up your initial claim. You're a human being, you are valuable, no one will think less of you for abandoning a shaky, out-dated, borderline re-tarded argument... Of course you never will. You will reply to this post and interject your snarky little responses in a contrasting color and continue to tell the world that Tim Tebow, Brandon Weeden and Johnny Manziel are destined for greatness and that Lebron James isn't Very good. Cheers.
-
So if none of these are official, I'll just choose to believe the NFL endorsed opinion rather than any cut rate third party opinion out there.
Good to know we're in agreement.
So....if the Browns have the #2 pick....and Bosa and Buckner are both available....who would you take?
So....if the Browns have the #2 pick....and Bosa and Buckner are both available....who would you take?
Carson Wentz.
-
So....if the Browns have the #2 pick....and Bosa and Buckner are both available....who would you take?
Myles Jack...
Myles Jack...
If he plays anything like Von Miller, you may be onto something there.
Does he have 4.4 speed? -
Guten Morgan...
I agree... you are incapable of discerning a difference.
Not with this group of QBs. No. I don't think there are vast differences in the talent among the first group and the latter group.
Actually you are arguing "closest", but let's set that aside.
Fine....Bosa is the closest thing to a sure thing.....not a closer thing. Happy now?
How do you compare Bosa's chances in a 3-4 vs. a 4-3?
I don't think it matters. He is a football player. He will tackle people and rush the passer from whichever system he plays in. I said he reminds me of Howie Long, who played DE in the 3-4. He was considered the ultimate 3-4 DE. Ray Horton runs the 3-4 I believe. Bosa may have played in the 4-3 in college....but he moved all over the place.
He would do fine in whatever.
How do you compare Bosa's chances in a 3-4 vs. a 4-3?
I don't think it matters. He is a football player. He will tackle people and rush the passer from whichever system he plays in. I said he reminds me of Howie Long, who played DE in the 3-4. He was considered the ultimate 3-4 DE. Ray Horton runs the 3-4 I believe. Bosa may have played in the 4-3 in college....but he moved all over the place.
He would do fine in whatever.
Sure...
guess I've gotta break my own rule and argue with Gip.... Jesus.
lol... thanks for playing our game...
-
So if none of these are official, I'll just choose to believe the NFL endorsed opinion rather than any cut rate third party opinion out there.
Good to know we're in agreement.
So....if the Browns have the #2 pick....and Bosa and Buckner are both available....who would you take?
So....if the Browns have the #2 pick....and Bosa and Buckner are both available....who would you take?
I went to Jared...
"When you have a shared vision it is a lot easier to make unpopular decisions." - Paul DePodesta "When you win, say nothing. When you lose, say less." - Paul Brown Complete 2017 Browns Board Mock: http://thebrownsboard.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=46196 -
-
If he plays anything like Von Miller, you may be onto something there.
Does he have 4.4 speed?Im not sure what his 40 time is, but I can say that he's fast enough......Im bailing on the combine BS this year and paying attention to production only...
He can play everywhere and did play running back(quite well) and also safety. so as a LB the speed is plenty good enough....and has a real nose for the ball and is a sure tackler, which is all I need.....
Here's afreshman game tape....you decide....
and another...
-
How about Braxton Miller, I mean he went to Ohio State
-
His own teammates decided that he wasn't worthy of being a Captain. That says volumes.
His own teammates decided that he wasn't worthy of being a Captain. That says volumes.
He's Bo Callahan.
-
How about Braxton Miller, I mean he went to Ohio State
How about Braxton Miller, I mean he went to Ohio State
he's a WR.
-
-
If he plays anything like Von Miller, you may be onto something there.
Does he have 4.4 speed?Im not sure what his 40 time is, but I can say that he's fast enough......Im bailing on the combine BS this year and paying attention to production only...
He can play everywhere and did play running back(quite well) and also safety. so as a LB the speed is plenty good enough....and has a real nose for the ball and is a sure tackler, which is all I need.....
Here's afreshman game tape....you decide....
and another...
Im not sure what his 40 time is, but I can say that he's fast enough......Im bailing on the combine BS this year and paying attention to production only...
He can play everywhere and did play running back(quite well) and also safety. so as a LB the speed is plenty good enough....and has a real nose for the ball and is a sure tackler, which is all I need.....
Here's afreshman game tape....you decide....
and another...
His speed approaches Millers but I would not be surprised if he is used as a SS. Not sure he is quite big enough to take on NFL OT's, but he's fast and is a sure tackler in the open field. Has good cover skills too. Why do I think a bigger version of "Jack Tatum" when I watch those highlights?
-
-
Cook is an interesting choice, and I love the fact that we'd be able to spend the second pick on another impact player. Perhaps Bosa, Ramsey, or even trade down (a LITTLE). There are no perfect candidates this year, and anybody can pick apart one of these QB's if given an opportunity. I like the offense that Cook ran in college, and I believe he has potential. I'd be interested in knowing how our scout and talent gurus have the QB's evaluated when the draft comes. Obviously we'll never get that information, but it'd sure be cool.
I think there will be lots of information on these guys. But, again, here is my basic point: you can get a good QB in rounds 2 and 3.....in some years the better QBs came out of those rounds:
2012...Wilson, Foles, Cousins......better than all others except Luck
2011....Dalton, Kaepernick....but than others except Cam.
There is no Luck/Newton in this draft.
I think there will be lots of information on these guys. But, again, here is my basic point: you can get a good QB in rounds 2 and 3.....in some years the better QBs came out of those rounds:
2012...Wilson, Foles, Cousins......better than all others except Luck
2011....Dalton, Kaepernick....but than others except Cam.
There is no Luck/Newton in this draft.
But there could be a Kosar.
Gipper read a fortune cookie Last 4th of July that said there would be no first round QBs this year. He then decided that since QB isn't a very important position that the Browns might as well take the 5th QB prospect on the board. if there's anything that every QB the Browns drafted after Couch has taught us it's that the bargain bin is the best place to find a franchise signal caller.
Yup, since Frye and McCoy worked out so well
Again, yes they will be drafted in the first round.....or should I say overdrafted.
All I am saying is that with our #2 pick.....we would be reaching mightily to take a QB there. If we had the #10-15 pick, it may not be so bad.
But we need #2 talent with our #2 pick.
We don't need the QB equivalent of Trent Richardson.
So you're already calling Goff, Wentz and Lynch busts.
I'm looking at the rankings on NFL.com that clearly have DeForest Buckner rated as a better DE prospect than Bosa. Further, Bosa is far from the #1 overall prospect - he's more like the 7th. I happen to trust the NFL official board moreso than the CBS - considering as these guys are getting drafted to play in the NFL and not CBS.
I may be an OSU homer, but I'm not in love with Bosa. Let me refresh Gips memory about another OSU DL that had the "can't miss superstar" tag. Big Daddy Dan Wilkinson.
Myles Jack...
Yup, rated higher than Bosa- and at a position of dire need.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login