Rock N Roll HOF Class of 2017

[The Gipper]

@westside-steve said:

What, Chubby Checker isn't in there already?

I'm a little bit iffy on Elo and golden earring but...

WSS

Chubby is not in, no I do not believe so. Nope, I have checked. Not in.

[Westside Steve]

I remember there was a controversy he was at the center of when they opened up the hall. He was demanding they place a statue of him outside.

WSS

[The Gipper]

@westside-steve said:

I remember there was a controversy he was at the center of when they opened up the hall. He was demanding they place a statue of him outside.

WSS

Chubby Checker? Don't remember that. If he really pulled a stunt like that then no wonder he has not been put in the the 25 years or so it has been open.

[Axe]

The RRHOF is a fucking joke.

[The Gipper]

@axe said:

The RRHOF is a fucking joke.

[nickers]

@axe said:

The RRHOF is a fucking joke.

It's actually the "Jan Wenner HOF"

[Axe]

Yeah, Uncle Ted has no chance in hell of being inducted

[One Post]

Slayer

Motley Crüe

Bon Jovi

Megadeth

Rage against the machine

Journey

Tool

Twisted Sister

Satch

PANTERA

[FairHooker11]

prog bands like Kansas or Dream Theater are my adds

always liked Frank Zappa too.

[Bob806]

@the-gipper said:

I am going to list a whole pile of musical acts that will be eligible for the RRHOF this next year.

From this vast list, choose like your Top 10 that you would want to see make it, plus alternates:

R. Kelley

Dr. Dre

Tupac

Hootie and the Blowfish

Radiohead

Stone Temple Pilots

Tool

The Verve

Ace of Base

The Replacements

King Crimson

Roxy Music

Faith No More

Yes

Iron Maiden

The Cars

Journey...but I hope I never hear "Don't Stop Believing" ever again

The Doobie Brothers

Motley Crue

Bad Company

Ronnie Dio

Mott the Hoople

Bon Jovi

Slayer

The Melvins

The Moody Blues

The Cure

Guess Who

ELP

ELO

Def Leppard

Megadeath

Jethro Tull

Sammy Hagar

Judas Priest

Dire Straits

The Pixies

Pantera

The Smiths

Ted Nugent

Nine Inch Nails

Soundgarden

Big Star

Motorhead

Pearl Jam

Common

Beck

Rage against the Machine

Janet Jackson

Smashing Pumpkins

Sonic Youth

New York Dolls

Link Wray

Kraftwerk

Chic

Gram Parsons

Joan Baez

Warren Zevon

Little Feat

The Monkees

The B-52s

Tori Amos

Rick Astley

No Doubt

Insane Clown Posse

Dixie Chicks

Wallflower

Alannis Morrisette

The Cranberries

Boyz 2 Men

Alice in Chains

The Black Crows

Celine Dion

Kid Rock

Wilson Phillips

Moby

Mariah Carey

Bare Naked Ladies

Cherry Poppin Daddies

Lenny Kravitz

Queen Latifah

Sarah McLachlan

Toad the Wet Sprocket

Melissa Etheridge

Morrisey

Phish

Paula Abdul

Tracy Chapman

Boy George and Culture Club

Gloria Estafan

Janes Addiction

MC Hammer

Sinead O'Connor

Wendy and Lisa

[The Gipper]

@axe said:

Yeah, Uncle Ted has no chance in hell of being inducted

Uncle Ted? As in Ted Nugent? That is probably true. He just wasn't all that compared to many others.

[The Gipper]

@fairhooker11 said:

prog bands like Kansas or Dream Theater are my adds

always liked Frank Zappa too.

Why am I of the opinion that Frank Zappa is already in? No? If not...yes, certainly.

[Tour2ma]

Man... whole lotta non-rockers in those lists... Barbara? Really?
Also one hit wonders... or one LP wonders (Alannis M.)... longevity has to account for something.

But still plenty to choose from... actually hard to draw a line at 10...

1. Yes - HTF are they not already in? Prolific, inventive, AOR pioneers...
2. ELP - Ditto... the original power trio... filled stadiums... when stadium rock was new.
3. Joe Cocker - HTF? Plus can throw in The Grease Band for good measure who put out a fine, Cockerless solo LP
4. The Doobie Brothers - HTF?
5. Jethro Tull - HTF?
6. Little Feat- HTF?
7. Supertramp - inventive, unusual, composers of rock... C'mon...
8. Todd Rundgren - the man's a rock genius whether solo or with Utopia
9. Humble Pie - studio work is good, but Rockin' the Philmore is great
10. Iggy Pop - my punk nod... I bought Skull Ring on a lark... and to my surprise loved it...
11. The Moody Blues - created a whole rock genre FFS...
12. Mott the Hoople - even if on Bowie's coattails...
13. Huey Lewis and the News - sounded like no other when they hit it big...
14. Def Leppard - adapted to a one-armed drummer... and got better...
15. Cyndi Lauper - for my daughter...

Worthy, but no room..

1. Boston
2. Robert Palmer
3. The James Gang
4. Loggins and Messina
5. Peter Frampton
6. War
7. The J. Geils Band
8. Nine Inch Nails
9. Steppenwolf
10. Johnny Rivers

Maybe someday...

• King Crimson - not prolific enough
• Roxy Music - love these guys, but an acquired taste...
• The Cars - prolific, but not impactful
• Journey - not really a fan
• Bon Jovi - popularity nod... points off for "Dead or Alive"
• Guess Who - not quite...
• Dire Straits - but not if Knofler is already in...

[The Gipper]

@tour2ma said:

Man... whole lotta non-rockers in those lists... Barbara? Really?

Also one hit wonders... or one LP wonders (Alannis M.)... longevity has to account for something.

But still plenty to choose from... actually hard to draw a line at 10...

1. Yes - HTF are they not already in? Prolific, inventive, AOR pioneers...
2. What does HTF mean? Hard to Fathom?
3. ELP - Ditto... the original power trio... filled stadiums... when stadium rock was new.
4. I think Cream would be the original Power Trio.
5. Joe Cocker - HTF? Plus can throw in The Grease Band for good measure who put out a fine, Cockerless solo LP
6. The Doobie Brothers - HTF?
7. Jethro Tull - HTF?
8. Little Feat- HTF?
9. Supertramp - inventive, unusual, composers of rock... C'mon...
10. Todd Rundgren - the man's a rock genius whether solo or with Utopia
11. Humble Pie - studio work is good, but Rockin' the Philmore is great
12. Iggy Pop - my punk nod... I bought Skull Ring on a lark... and to my surprise loved it...
13. The Moody Blues - created a whole rock genre FFS...
14. Mott the Hoople - even if on Bowie's coattails...
15. Huey Lewis and the News - sounded like no other when they hit it big...
16. Def Leppard - adapted to a one-armed drummer... and got better...
17. Cyndi Lauper - for my daughter...

Worthy, but no room..

1. Boston
2. Robert Palmer
3. The James Gang
4. Loggins and Messina
5. Peter Frampton
6. War
7. The J. Geils Band
8. Nine Inch Nails
9. Steppenwolf
10. Johnny Rivers

Maybe someday...

• King Crimson - not prolific enough
• More for their influence than anything else.
• Roxy Music - love these guys, but an acquired taste...
• I acquired the taste early on.
• The Cars - prolific, but not impactful
• Journey - not really a fan
• Bon Jovi - popularity nod... points off for "Dead or Alive"
• Guess Who - not quite...
• Dire Straits - but not if Knofler is already in...

[Tour2ma]

HTF = How the Fuck...

Arguably right about Cream, but I think first "supergroup" more than power trio in their case.

ELP's use of synth over lead guitar raised the bar in my mind. Plus percussionist, Carl Palmer (he hated being called a drummer) brought more to the kit than Ginger... at least the Cream version of Ginger. Blind Faith? Closer call...

King Crimsom's Fripp popped up on projects all over including Bowie's Scary Monsters... another acquired taste. Other than him ELP's Greg Lake is the only other member I know of that emerged... but then he's the only other member I can name.

Side story: In the Court of's legendary gatefold artwork was faithfully reproduced freshman year at Case on the long interior walls of his suite by a guy named Chris something. End to end and floor to ceiling... one side on one wall, the other on the other... on the order of 8.5' by 14'. Even straight they were awesome...

Roxy was so cool. Brian Ferry's solo work... not so much, but had moments.