So....who gets cut??

ballpeen

That is a good point Jad...all players need some tutoring from vets. Mack would benefit from a guy like Fraley....line calls and such...though it isn't unheard of for a guard to call it to his center, who then calls it out to the other side of the line.

Steinbach could fill that role for a while if need be.

it will be a close call for Fraley and Hadnot.

Fooleeze

Ok, I've updated the roster list:

http://thebrownsboard.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=3456

The 'active' roster (by my records) shows 72 players. So, let's say we need to get down to the 53 man roster. Which 19 players do you think will be cut?

I don't think it's possible that Fraley gets cut. You can't bring in a new C and expect him to start right away without someone there to mentor him & back him up. I just don't see that happening.

Riceloft

Here's my 19. I think we'll end up keeping one or two guys from this list and end up cutting one or two more DB's, but I'm not sure who.

QB - Bartel, Richard
RB - Thomas, Marcus - FA Signing from Detroit

RB - Patrick, Allen

WR - Ellis, Devale

WR - Hubbard, Paul (Practice Squad)

WR - Leggett, Lance

WR - Stallworth, Donte

TE - Walker, Aaron - FA Signing from St. Louis (Practice Squad)

OL - Sowells, Isaac

OL - Fry, Dustin

OL - Quarterman, Kurt (we'll have an OL on the practice squad I think)

DL - Purcell, Melila

DL - Smith, Shaun

DL - Thomas, Santonio

LB - Williams, Leon

LB - Holloway, David

LB - Brown, Titus

DB - Abdullah, Hamza

DB - Lawson, Gerard

Fooleeze

@riceloft said:
Here's my 19. I think we'll end up keeping one or two guys from this list and end up cutting one or two more DB's, but I'm not sure who.

That's a good list. . . Might be right-on with what I would put together. For some reason I don't think they'll cut Shaun Smith this year, but otherwise I would agree.

ballpeen

@riceloft said:
Here's my 19. I think we'll end up keeping one or two guys from this list and end up cutting one or two more DB's, but I'm not sure who.

That's a good stab. No sense reinventing the wheel. I can go with that.

Mr. T

Its safe to say DA will be gone. nobody would trade for him, that show his value.

daddybull1

Lewis rushed for 1000 yards the past 2 seasons and was slow to the hole last year because there were no holes... I see Lewis having a great season in 2009...Keep in mind, he was hurt in preseason and played the year at about 85%... Lewis was the 1st Browns back to have back to back 1000 yard seasons since???????

T.Dawg

BrownsKidd

@daddybull1 said:
Lewis rushed for 1000 yards the past 2 seasons and was slow to the hole last year because there were no holes... I see Lewis having a great season in 2009...Keep in mind, he was hurt in preseason and played the year at about 85%... Lewis was the 1st Browns back to have back to back 1000 yard seasons since???????
T.Dawg

Why not use Lewis as FB - He seems big enough. Just not sure how well he can block. Would be a better short yardage guy than Harrison. Harrison had to many big runs last year to just let this guy sit like he did under RAC.

pl4tinum

@jadbf said:
Kokinis is on record as saying he thinks Lewis still has gas in his tank.

Hopefully enough to make it to the unemployment office

samoth

QB Richard Bartel

RB Marcus Thomas

RB Patrick Allen

WR Ellis Devale

WR Donte Stallworth

WR Steve Sanders

OL Kurt Quarterman

DL Melila Purcell

LB Titus Brown

LB David Holloway

LB Leon Williams

DB Hazma Abdullah

Take your pick.

Bronx Cheer

I think the 19 above is a good start, but have a few comments.

Regarding Fraley, couldn't Steinbach and Hadnot be the backups at C while still being starting Gs? I know Steinbach is thought of as a backup at T, but am I right in thinking that he would be a backup C as well? If Mack starts day 1, then that would enable you to cut Fraley - Steinbach would be able to handle the mentoring thing as well assist in line calls. I can't imagine a new coach who is trying to turn over his roster keeping a backup o-lineman (and a tired old vet to boot) that can play only one position.

Also, if steptoe is cut, then who is the backup kick returner?

? mz.

@sisky-fringo said:
Beau Bell
Lawrence Vickers

Kamerian Wimbley

Holy shit was this post stupid...

Lumbergh

@inspecta said:
We gave lewis a 6 million roster bonus in march, he's not going anywhere this year.

Looks like you put your thinking cap on and figured out how that kind of thing works. Nice job inspecta.

? mz.

Also, I think we should cut Shaun Rogers...he's no Srinivasa Ramanujan!

Thaak

@sisky-fringo said:
the less intelligent ones:
Beau Bell

Lawrence Vickers

Kamerian Wimbley

What?! Vickers was a pro bowl alternate and they have nobody to really replace Wimbley yet.

Thaak

Other than the stupid guy, the only major cut I disagree with is Shaun Smith.

While I think the guy is an ass, and I don't really want him on our team, he's a serviceable NT. Who's going to back up Shaun Rogers if Shaun Smith is not on the team?

Andy

ballpeen

@samoth said:
QB Richard Bartel
RB Marcus Thomas

RB Patrick Allen

WR Ellis Devale

WR Donte Stallworth

WR Steve Sanders

OL Kurt Quarterman

DL Melila Purcell

LB Titus Brown

LB David Holloway

LB Leon Williams

DB Hazma Abdullah

Take your pick.

Not just to pick you out, but were all of these guys active last year??

I don't think we can cut off practice squad players and expect to arrive at the number.

Just thinking out loud here.

ballpeen

@shepwrite said:
Lewis is in another contract year. I expect him to come in buff and hungry, looking to squeeze out one last deal. A lot of his fall off last year can be blamed on Fraley, who got bitched all year long. Mack and hopefully Tucker make this a power running team again.
The more I think about it, the more this situation is perfect for Quinn. He's going to have a nice set of receivers, a terrific line, and a hungry Jamal Lewis.

It does add up for Quinn....I will assume he is the guy.

I think as much that went wrong last season might go our way this season.

We might be much better than people think...and face it, Mangini has to be a better game coach...that will have to add something towards possibly pulling out a extra game or two.

ballpeen

@inspecta said:
Ahhh even the most cynical of us are now optimistic. I just hope the national media stays cynical when it comes to us. We seem to do our best when everybody has counted us out.

Kind of like opening day in baseball......you are tied for first.

sisky fringo

@timugen said:
Quinn for sure.
The guy's a douche and has yet to figure out how to win the Lombardi from the practice field.

Plus if he starts this year then we have to pay him some money. Can you imagine that? Paying your starting QB money? Who would be stupid enough to do that?

Quinn's a goner, so get ready to see DA continue to "dissect" the defenses of the league.

couldn't you have replied with that in the right thread? he was on a tear at 9am, you'd probably be sitting on a big rubber ring right now. he actually showed you a little respect in the reply too. pretty weak i must say but whatever, not my battle.