Skip to content

Todd McShay's Mock Draft 2017

The Browns Board
48 22 2.3k
  • T Taco918 wrote on last edited by
    #7

    I guess everyone missed that first paragraph or two.

  • Mitch2Pryor said:

    https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/5iatls/todd_mcshays_2017_nfl_mock_draft_10/?client=safari

    Have us taking Allen #1 and Takkarist McKinley(never heard of him, is he any good?) a LB from UCLA.

    Above is a link to the whole draft

    Interesting is first QB off the board is Trubisky to the Chiefs.

    All the more reason "Mock McShay". If he thinks no QB is going until the 20s, he has not been paying much attention to NFL drafts recently. I say 2 will go in the Top Ten...

    MLD WoodyM MLD Woody wrote on last edited by
    #8

    @the-gipper said:

    All the more reason "Mock McShay". If he thinks no QB is going until the 20s, he has not been paying much attention to NFL drafts recently. I say 2 will go in the Top Ten...

    Yep. Todd McShay hasn't been paying attention to the NFL draft. You got him

  • Don't overthink it. If you're taking a pure LB take Foster.

    Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by
    #9

    @wargograw said:

    Don't overthink it. If you're taking a pure LB take Foster.

    Agree... I've seen McKinley a couple times this year and he is a damn good prospect, but he is not a tone setter.

    Got me thinking about the comment someone made the other day that Garrett lacks "the nasty" many DL exhibit. An Allen/Foster 1st round certainly brings that in abundance. I like it. A few more Crimson types and we can nickname our D "BAMA North"...

    And Kizer is still there at #33...

    Overall McShay must really think highly of the 2017 DB class... 7 in total... 4 of the top 8 depending how you count Peppers.

  • Canton DawgC Canton Dawg wrote on last edited by
    #10

    The first QB off the board at #30??

    McShay has lost his mind.

  • @wargograw said:

    Don't overthink it. If you're taking a pure LB take Foster.

    Agree... I've seen McKinley a couple times this year and he is a damn good prospect, but he is not a tone setter.

    Got me thinking about the comment someone made the other day that Garrett lacks "the nasty" many DL exhibit. An Allen/Foster 1st round certainly brings that in abundance. I like it. A few more Crimson types and we can nickname our D "BAMA North"...

    And Kizer is still there at #33...

    Overall McShay must really think highly of the 2017 DB class... 7 in total... 4 of the top 8 depending how you count Peppers.

    hoortaH hoorta wrote on last edited by
    #11

    @tour2ma said:

    Agree... I've seen McKinley a couple times this year and he is a damn good prospect, but he is not a tone setter.

    Got me thinking about the comment someone made the other day that Garrett lacks "the nasty" many DL exhibit. An Allen/Foster 1st round certainly brings that in abundance. I like it. A few more Crimson types and we can nickname our D "BAMA North"...

    And Kizer is still there at #33...

    Overall McShay must really think highly of the 2017 DB class... 7 in total... 4 of the top 8 depending how you count Peppers.

    Did you read the comments Tour? That mock is 80% garbage.

    "How in the fuck does he have the Chiefs being the first team to take a QB. I don't see how the Browns pass on Trubisky if he's there at the Eagles pick."

  • T TexasAg1969 wrote on last edited by
    #12

    X's 3 on Foster. I got to watch them both and UCLA's guy is just not in the same league with Foster. I'd be elated if he is still there for our 2nd pick. Same applies for Tim Williams if Foster is gone.

  • stillmotionS stillmotion wrote on last edited by
    #13

    he has us taking allen over garrett? lolz

  • he has us taking allen over garrett? lolz

    tiamat63T tiamat63 wrote on last edited by
    #14

    @stillmotion said:

    he has us taking allen over garrett? lolz

    Is it that funny?

  • @tour2ma said:

    Agree... I've seen McKinley a couple times this year and he is a damn good prospect, but he is not a tone setter.

    Got me thinking about the comment someone made the other day that Garrett lacks "the nasty" many DL exhibit. An Allen/Foster 1st round certainly brings that in abundance. I like it. A few more Crimson types and we can nickname our D "BAMA North"...

    And Kizer is still there at #33...

    Overall McShay must really think highly of the 2017 DB class... 7 in total... 4 of the top 8 depending how you count Peppers.

    Did you read the comments Tour? That mock is 80% garbage.

    "How in the fuck does he have the Chiefs being the first team to take a QB. I don't see how the Browns pass on Trubisky if he's there at the Eagles pick."

    T Taco918 wrote on last edited by
    #15

    @hoorta said:

    Did you read the comments Tour? That mock is 80% garbage.

    "How in the fuck does he have the Chiefs being the first team to take a QB. I don't see how the Browns pass on Trubisky if he's there at the Eagles pick."

    Well if a commenter on Reddit said it, it must obviously be true.

    I guess that's a slight step ahead of asking a homeless guy.

    Progress fellas, progress.

  • @wargograw said:

    Don't overthink it. If you're taking a pure LB take Foster.

    Agree... I've seen McKinley a couple times this year and he is a damn good prospect, but he is not a tone setter.

    Got me thinking about the comment someone made the other day that Garrett lacks "the nasty" many DL exhibit. An Allen/Foster 1st round certainly brings that in abundance. I like it. A few more Crimson types and we can nickname our D "BAMA North"...

    And Kizer is still there at #33...

    Overall McShay must really think highly of the 2017 DB class... 7 in total... 4 of the top 8 depending how you count Peppers.

    W wargograw wrote on last edited by
    #16

    @tour2ma said:

    Agree... I've seen McKinley a couple times this year and he is a damn good prospect, but he is not a tone setter.

    Got me thinking about the comment someone made the other day that Garrett lacks "the nasty" many DL exhibit. An Allen/Foster 1st round certainly brings that in abundance. I like it. A few more Crimson types and we can nickname our D "BAMA North"...

    And Kizer is still there at #33...

    Overall McShay must really think highly of the 2017 DB class... 7 in total... 4 of the top 8 depending how you count Peppers.

    That was me. We have a few BAs on our defense attitude-wise. Garrett is not one. Look up Justin Evans.

  • he has us taking allen over garrett? lolz

    LogicIsForSquaresL LogicIsForSquares wrote on last edited by
    #17

    @stillmotion said:

    he has us taking allen over garrett? lolz

    Not really that funny. Allen is a monster.

  • gumby73G gumby73 wrote on last edited by
    #18

    looks more like a Todd straight "talent big board" with no position concerns..Not a NFL ready QB imo. but it's your 1st rounder to screw it up...

  • @wargograw said:

    Don't overthink it. If you're taking a pure LB take Foster.

    Agree... I've seen McKinley a couple times this year and he is a damn good prospect, but he is not a tone setter.

    Got me thinking about the comment someone made the other day that Garrett lacks "the nasty" many DL exhibit. An Allen/Foster 1st round certainly brings that in abundance. I like it. A few more Crimson types and we can nickname our D "BAMA North"...

    And Kizer is still there at #33...

    Overall McShay must really think highly of the 2017 DB class... 7 in total... 4 of the top 8 depending how you count Peppers.

    gumby73G gumby73 wrote on last edited by
    #19

    @tour2ma said:

    Overall McShay must really think highly of the 2017 DB class... 7 in total... 4 of the top 8 depending how you count Peppers.

    A Passing league has caused a DB draft. some good ones. but as good as last season? Dunno

  • @tour2ma said:

    Overall McShay must really think highly of the 2017 DB class... 7 in total... 4 of the top 8 depending how you count Peppers.

    A Passing league has caused a DB draft. some good ones. but as good as last season? Dunno

    gftChrisG gftChris wrote on last edited by
    #20

    @gumby73 said:

    A Passing league has caused a DB draft. some good ones. but as good as last season? Dunno

    I don't know about that. A DB heavy draft class has produced a DB heavy draft. Maybe you could say that college is producing better QBs since the college game is more pass happy than a smoke circle.

    You've also got a lot of pass rushers in this draft - it's just a D heavy draft.

  • W Westside Steve wrote on last edited by
    #21

    I wouldn't be surprised if all three quarterbacks went in the first round.

    Most quarterbacks taken in the first round are disappointments but they do seem irresistible. Like taking a hit on a 20. Hey there are four aces in the deck right?

    WSS

  • jiggins7919J jiggins7919 wrote on last edited by
    #22

    I've seen multiple drafts having us taking Allen over Garrett, and I'd be fine with hit. Allen probably fits what we do and need better than Garrett...at least out of the box. Garrett would have to be fit into our scheme, whereas Allen comes in and immediately does what he did in college. He penetrates like a porn star, is stout against the run, and basically causes trouble all of the time. Putting him next to Shelton would probably be a handful. But the thing with Garrett is he could compliment Ogbah very well. Ogbah has lost out on multiple sacks when the opposing QB just drifts away from him in the pocket and fires the ball down field, but if there is opposing pressure...the QB can't really go anywhere.

    I think many fans are fine with either Garrett or Allen, but the one thing that virtually EVERY person I've talked is...DO NOT TRADE DOWN. That's the consensus I keep hearing from almost everyone.

  • Canton MikeC Canton Mike wrote on last edited by
    #23

    McShay is to evaluation as Lombardi is to acquisition........translation: He's a DUMBASS!!

    Mike

  • I've seen multiple drafts having us taking Allen over Garrett, and I'd be fine with hit. Allen probably fits what we do and need better than Garrett...at least out of the box. Garrett would have to be fit into our scheme, whereas Allen comes in and immediately does what he did in college. He penetrates like a porn star, is stout against the run, and basically causes trouble all of the time. Putting him next to Shelton would probably be a handful. But the thing with Garrett is he could compliment Ogbah very well. Ogbah has lost out on multiple sacks when the opposing QB just drifts away from him in the pocket and fires the ball down field, but if there is opposing pressure...the QB can't really go anywhere.

    I think many fans are fine with either Garrett or Allen, but the one thing that virtually EVERY person I've talked is...DO NOT TRADE DOWN. That's the consensus I keep hearing from almost everyone.

    gftChrisG gftChris wrote on last edited by
    #24

    @jiggins7919 said:

    I've seen multiple drafts having us taking Allen over Garrett, and I'd be fine with hit. Allen probably fits what we do and need better than Garrett...at least out of the box. Garrett would have to be fit into our scheme, whereas Allen comes in and immediately does what he did in college. He penetrates like a porn star, is stout against the run, and basically causes trouble all of the time. Putting him next to Shelton would probably be a handful. But the thing with Garrett is he could compliment Ogbah very well. Ogbah has lost out on multiple sacks when the opposing QB just drifts away from him in the pocket and fires the ball down field, but if there is opposing pressure...the QB can't really go anywhere.

    I think many fans are fine with either Garrett or Allen, but the one thing that virtually EVERY person I've talked is...DO NOT TRADE DOWN. That's the consensus I keep hearing from almost everyone.

    If everyone's fine with either Garrett or Allen, would everyone object to moving down one spot, picking up SF's second or third round pick, for example?

  • jiggins7919J jiggins7919 wrote on last edited by
    #25

    I think that would be the lone trade many people would be happy with. Like, if San Fran is absolutely in love with a guy and wants to MAKE SURE they get him, I could see us doing that. Crazy things tend to happen on draft day, and the one thing I DON'T want to see happen is us give in to temptation. There's probably going to be some insane offers for Garrett, Allen, or a QB. From a value standpoint, it might be difficult to say "no" to a team offering up first round picks and other things. But I think the time is now to really add that blue chip prospect, and not trade down past two.

  • he has us taking allen over garrett? lolz

    C Clevfan4life wrote on last edited by
    #26

    @stillmotion said:

    he has us taking allen over garrett? lolz

    Prob cause allen is ready to tangle with nfl ol right now. Garret will need work and,well, you know the browns dont have any history of properly developing drafted defensive front seven talent right?