Skip to content

Most Overrated "Star" In Football

The Browns Board
61 26 1.9k
  • Thanks to a quick misread of One Post's "Stat" thread, a new thread is born...

  • With Romo retired....lets see.....not Revis anymore really.......Im going to say Alshon Jeffery.

  • Think I'll go OL... Greg Robinson. Came into the league "hot" in some eyes, but I never "got" this athletic specimen. His technique was poor to non-existent.

    Two years later his only hope for his exclusion is how low expectations of him have dropped... but I remember.

    One apparently trending his way to consideration for this title, one I hope never gains it, is Andrew Luck. Word now is the kid tried to rehab his way through a labrum issue in his shoulder. Been there... tried that... without throwing a football at all. Now that he's had repairs done, and has what looks to be at least a little better team placed around him, we'll see.

  • Think I'll go OL... Greg Robinson. Came into the league "hot" in some eyes, but I never "got" this athletic specimen. His technique was poor to non-existent.

    Two years later his only hope for his exclusion is how low expectations of him have dropped... but I remember.

    One apparently trending his way to consideration for this title, one I hope never gains it, is Andrew Luck. Word now is the kid tried to rehab his way through a labrum issue in his shoulder. Been there... tried that... without throwing a football at all. Now that he's had repairs done, and has what looks to be at least a little better team placed around him, we'll see.

    @tour2ma said:

    Think I'll go OL... Greg Robinson. Came into the league "hot" in some eyes, but I never "got" this athletic specimen. His technique was poor to non-existent.

    Two years later his only hope for his exclusion is how low expectations of him have dropped... but I remember.

    One apparently trending his way to consideration for this title, one I hope never gains it, is Andrew Luck. Word now is the kid tried to rehab his way through a labrum issue in his shoulder. Been there... tried that... without throwing a football at all. Now that he's had repairs done, and has what looks to be at least a little better team placed around him, we'll see.

    I think you have to be a STAR first before being overrated. I don't think Greg Robinson was ever in any way a star.

    Here are a few names:

    Sam Bradford.

    Kelvin Benjamin

    Ryan Tannehill.

  • Andrew Luck.

    The perennial go to guy for the argument that so and so is no andrew luck.

    WSS

  • Cam Newton (cue Cartman post).

    All New England receivers.

  • Todd Gurley...They got in his head..He's a track star just like Chris Johnson from NC..

  • Good topic.

    I would say Dick Sherman cb Seattle Seafaggots. He's a system cb in a defense that works for him yes but he doesn't blanket anyone and everyone knows Seattle always gets lucky in the penalty dept. not only do I despise Dick Sherman but his intellect as he tries to use big words is exhausting to hear. He's a dumb jock from Stanford; not some genious from Stanford.

  • Gee whiz man when I read this title I saw that I spelled overrated wrong in my thread. Cha Ching ....I'm actually a good speller maybe sometimes I recon yep.

  • Andrew Luck.

    The perennial go to guy for the argument that so and so is no andrew luck.

    WSS

    @westside-steve said:

    Andrew Luck.

    The perennial go to guy for the argument that so and so is no andrew luck.

    WSS

    He ain't no Kody Kessler guaranteed.
  • Zeke

  • Bill Belichick πŸ˜›

  • Tom Brady and Josh Norman

  • Bill Belichick πŸ˜›

    @nickers said:

    Bill Belichick πŸ˜›

    The Croation master.

  • Gee whiz man when I read this title I saw that I spelled overrated wrong in my thread. Cha Ching ....I'm actually a good speller maybe sometimes I recon yep.

    @one-post said:

    I'm actually a good speller maybe sometimes I recon yep.

    I too RECKON you sometimes spell good.

  • Prediction...Dak Prescott.

    RG III was also fabulous his rookie year, let's see if Dak can maintain his star status next season.

    Maybe even Zeke.

  • Zeke

    @mld-woody said:

    Zeke

    Really? I love how you always get indignant about people here being osu homers when you are the biggest homo homer of all always stumping for OSU's bitch. I like peppers now because he's a Cleveland brown but you are guilty as hell of lovingly licking the nutsack of total crap players like denard robinson. Gtfo of here. Denard robinson is out of the league. Zeke led the league in rushing in his rookie year.

  • Hahaha.

    Man I just wanted to see how someone would react to that, and you succeeded.

    Denard isn't out of the league

    Zeke is a beast. He's just also behind the best OL in the game. I dont think he's the "most overrated star".

    FYI, I'm definitely NOT the biggest Homer to their college team. You're an OSU fan tho, so it probably masks the homerism of other OSU fans.

  • Face it boys professional sports across-the-board is, and should be, directly related to Homer ism.

    WSS

  • Unless you're talking about QB's, an "overrated star" is not easy to come up with..."Overrated star" kinda sounds oxymoronic.