Skip to content

Bold idea that would change the landscape of sports in Cleveland

The Browns Board
355 22 6.5k
  • mjp28M mjp28 wrote on last edited by
    #2

    And how are they (whomever) going to do the financing for all of this ?   

    I do believe in looking ahead and creative thinking but are the CBS and Progressive beyond their useful lives ?

  • And how are they (whomever) going to do the financing for all of this ?   

    I do believe in looking ahead and creative thinking but are the CBS and Progressive beyond their useful lives ?

    Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by
    #3

    @mjp28 said:

    And how are they (whomever) going to do the financing for all of this ?   

    I do believe in looking ahead and creative thinking but are the CBS and Progressive beyond their useful lives ?

    The tax payers, of course! 

    I would have asked Ruiter why the Browns new stadium couldn't have been built where the Wolstein Center is, eliminating the need for a new ballpark for the Indians. 

  • Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by
    #4

    Sounds dumb to me...

    I noticed that Gilbert commented on every franchise's home other than his.

    I love the Jake...

    I like that Browns Stadium was built on the site of old Muni...

  • Sounds dumb to me...

    I noticed that Gilbert commented on every franchise's home other than his.

    I love the Jake...

    I like that Browns Stadium was built on the site of old Muni...

    Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by Dutch Oven
    #5

    @tour2ma said:

    Sounds dumb to me...

    I noticed that Gilbert commented on every franchise's home other than his.

    I love the Jake...

    I like that Browns Stadium was built on the site of old Muni...

    I agree with you on Progressive Field, but not on First Energy. There is no bigger waste of money and space than an open-air football stadium, especially in the North. Then you add the fact that being on the lakefront makes it very expensive to maintain, and that prime real estate is wasted for 10 dates a year, plus the occasional concert. Having a retractable dome would open up the ability for Cleveland to host huge events like the Super Bowl, NCAA Final Four, etc... All that means more to me that this mediocre stadium sitting on the site of old Cleveland Stadium, IMO.... 

    I would imagine the reason Gilbert didn't comment on the home of the Cavs is because the home of the Cavs just underwent an enormous facelift. 

  • @tour2ma said:

    Sounds dumb to me...

    I noticed that Gilbert commented on every franchise's home other than his.

    I love the Jake...

    I like that Browns Stadium was built on the site of old Muni...

    I agree with you on Progressive Field, but not on First Energy. There is no bigger waste of money and space than an open-air football stadium, especially in the North. Then you add the fact that being on the lakefront makes it very expensive to maintain, and that prime real estate is wasted for 10 dates a year, plus the occasional concert. Having a retractable dome would open up the ability for Cleveland to host huge events like the Super Bowl, NCAA Final Four, etc... All that means more to me that this mediocre stadium sitting on the site of old Cleveland Stadium, IMO.... 

    I would imagine the reason Gilbert didn't comment on the home of the Cavs is because the home of the Cavs just underwent an enormous facelift. 

    mjp28M mjp28 wrote on last edited by
    #6

    @dutch-oven said:

    I agree with you on Progressive Field, but not on First Energy. There is no bigger waste of money and space than an open-air football stadium, especially in the North. Then you add the fact that being on the lakefront makes it very expensive to maintain, and that prime real estate is wasted for 10 dates a year, plus the occasional concert. Having a retractable dome would open up the ability for Cleveland to host huge events like the Super Bowl, NCAA Final Four, etc... All that means more to me that this mediocre stadium sitting on the site of old Cleveland Stadium, IMO.... 

    I would imagine the reason Gilbert didn't comment on the home of the Cavs is because the home of the Cavs just underwent an enormous facelift. 

    And the Cavs are a pitiful team without LBJ.

    THE BROWNS blew it not going with a retractable stadium when they replaced the Ol' Muni.....an expensive Mulligan now to build another stadium.

  • Browns149B Browns149 wrote on last edited by
    #7

    Gilbert has the money. 

  • Browns149B Browns149 wrote on last edited by
    #8

    So does Jimma

  • OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by
    #9

    I like the idea of domed stadiums in the north (or retractable).  

    I'm not going to games anymore.  Not interested in sweltering, freezing or getting soaked.....when I can watch it from my couch.

  • tiamat63T tiamat63 wrote on last edited by tiamat63
    #10

    EWBpE0.gif

  • MLD WoodyM MLD Woody wrote on last edited by
    #11

    Less for baseball and more for football? 

    Hell yeah let's do it.

    Jump in front of the inevitable decline in baseball and move it towards more football. Become a venue for cold weather games (bowls, XFL, etc)

  • Less for baseball and more for football? 

    Hell yeah let's do it.

    Jump in front of the inevitable decline in baseball and move it towards more football. Become a venue for cold weather games (bowls, XFL, etc)

    DieHardBrownsFanD DieHardBrownsFan wrote on last edited by
    #12

    @mld-woody said:

    Less for baseball and more for football? 

    Hell yeah let's do it.

    Jump in front of the inevitable decline in baseball and move it towards more football. Become a venue for cold weather games (bowls, XFL, etc)

    Shut up soccer fag.

  • Apparently Dan Gilbert was on 92.3 this morning, I had just missed his interview when I turned it on at 7:25am... From the interview, which Gilbert talked about the state of downtown Cleveland in relation to it's sports teams, Daryl Ruiter came up with a bold plan... What do you think of it?

    1. Tear down CSU's Wolstein Center on the near east side of downtown. It has become somewhat of a white elephant.

    2. Build a smaller, more intimate ballpark for the Indians. Think a 32,000-34,000 seat PNC Field. Upper deck that hugs the playing field, unlike Progressive Field. Half the amount of luxury boxes.

    3. Tear down Progressive Field, build a new retractable dome for the Browns in its spot. Go after the Super Bowl, NCAA Final Four, Big Ten Championship, etc... 

    4. Tear down First Energy Stadium, develop (finally) the lakefront. Haslam has made a point a few times about how much money is poured into the stadium there because the damage it takes from being on the lakefront. This is a great piece of real estate, Cleveland needs to finally take advantage of its lakefront. 

    What say you? 

    S SdBacker80 wrote on last edited by SdBacker80
    #13

    @dutch-oven said:

    Apparently Dan Gilbert was on 92.3 this morning, I had just missed his interview when I turned it on at 7:25am... From the interview, which Gilbert talked about the state of downtown Cleveland in relation to it's sports teams, Daryl Ruiter came up with a bold plan... What do you think of it?

    1. Tear down CSU's Wolstein Center on the near east side of downtown. It has become somewhat of a white elephant.

    2. Build a smaller, more intimate ballpark for the Indians. Think a 32,000-34,000 seat PNC Field. Upper deck that hugs the playing field, unlike Progressive Field. Half the amount of luxury boxes.

    3. Tear down Progressive Field, build a new retractable dome for the Browns in its spot. Go after the Super Bowl, NCAA Final Four, Big Ten Championship, etc... 

    4. Tear down First Energy Stadium, develop (finally) the lakefront. Haslam has made a point a few times about how much money is poured into the stadium there because the damage it takes from being on the lakefront. This is a great piece of real estate, Cleveland needs to finally take advantage of its lakefront. 

    What say you? 

    How many packs of smokes and bottles are you gonna tax?

    tear downs $$

    new builds $$$$$$

    and you just put a ton of money in First energy and not too long ago the Prog the new scoreboard etc 

    before they built first energy I was screaming for a dome for the very reasons brought up.  Super Bowl, NCAA other big events.  We doubled down and remodeled it now too.  
    too late 

  • @dutch-oven said:

    Apparently Dan Gilbert was on 92.3 this morning, I had just missed his interview when I turned it on at 7:25am... From the interview, which Gilbert talked about the state of downtown Cleveland in relation to it's sports teams, Daryl Ruiter came up with a bold plan... What do you think of it?

    1. Tear down CSU's Wolstein Center on the near east side of downtown. It has become somewhat of a white elephant.

    2. Build a smaller, more intimate ballpark for the Indians. Think a 32,000-34,000 seat PNC Field. Upper deck that hugs the playing field, unlike Progressive Field. Half the amount of luxury boxes.

    3. Tear down Progressive Field, build a new retractable dome for the Browns in its spot. Go after the Super Bowl, NCAA Final Four, Big Ten Championship, etc... 

    4. Tear down First Energy Stadium, develop (finally) the lakefront. Haslam has made a point a few times about how much money is poured into the stadium there because the damage it takes from being on the lakefront. This is a great piece of real estate, Cleveland needs to finally take advantage of its lakefront. 

    What say you? 

    How many packs of smokes and bottles are you gonna tax?

    tear downs $$

    new builds $$$$$$

    and you just put a ton of money in First energy and not too long ago the Prog the new scoreboard etc 

    before they built first energy I was screaming for a dome for the very reasons brought up.  Super Bowl, NCAA other big events.  We doubled down and remodeled it now too.  
    too late 

    Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by
    #14

    @sdbacker80 said:

    How many packs of smokes and bottles are you gonna tax?

    tear downs $$

    new builds $$$$$$

    and you just put a ton of money in First energy and not too long ago the Prog the new scoreboard etc 

    before they built first energy I was screaming for a dome for the very reasons brought up.  Super Bowl, NCAA other big events.  We doubled down and remodeled it now too.  
    too late 

    I think it's a pipe dream too...

    Someday the Browns will be playing in a retractable dome. I have a feeling if the Haslams are around for the long term, they'll demand an upgrade.

    I still think the next ballpark the Indians play in won't be in Cleveland. 

  • @sdbacker80 said:

    How many packs of smokes and bottles are you gonna tax?

    tear downs $$

    new builds $$$$$$

    and you just put a ton of money in First energy and not too long ago the Prog the new scoreboard etc 

    before they built first energy I was screaming for a dome for the very reasons brought up.  Super Bowl, NCAA other big events.  We doubled down and remodeled it now too.  
    too late 

    I think it's a pipe dream too...

    Someday the Browns will be playing in a retractable dome. I have a feeling if the Haslams are around for the long term, they'll demand an upgrade.

    I still think the next ballpark the Indians play in won't be in Cleveland. 

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #15

    @dutch-oven said:

    I think it's a pipe dream too...

    Someday the Browns will be playing in a retractable dome. I have a feeling if the Haslams are around for the long term, they'll demand an upgrade.

    I still think the next ballpark the Indians play in won't be in Cleveland. 

    The tribes ballpark can last for another 50 or more years 

  • @tour2ma said:

    Sounds dumb to me...

    I noticed that Gilbert commented on every franchise's home other than his.

    I love the Jake...

    I like that Browns Stadium was built on the site of old Muni...

    I agree with you on Progressive Field, but not on First Energy. There is no bigger waste of money and space than an open-air football stadium, especially in the North. Then you add the fact that being on the lakefront makes it very expensive to maintain, and that prime real estate is wasted for 10 dates a year, plus the occasional concert. Having a retractable dome would open up the ability for Cleveland to host huge events like the Super Bowl, NCAA Final Four, etc... All that means more to me that this mediocre stadium sitting on the site of old Cleveland Stadium, IMO.... 

    I would imagine the reason Gilbert didn't comment on the home of the Cavs is because the home of the Cavs just underwent an enormous facelift. 

    D BoneD D Bone wrote on last edited by
    #16

    @dutch-oven said:

    I agree with you on Progressive Field, but not on First Energy. There is no bigger waste of money and space than an open-air football stadium, especially in the North.

    Put a lid on that sucker and you guys will finally be able to see the greatest sport ever.....

    Supercross baby. 

  • @mld-woody said:

    Less for baseball and more for football? 

    Hell yeah let's do it.

    Jump in front of the inevitable decline in baseball and move it towards more football. Become a venue for cold weather games (bowls, XFL, etc)

    Shut up soccer fag.

    Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by
    #17

    @diehardbrownsfan said:

    Shut up soccer supercross fag.

  • @diehardbrownsfan said:

    Shut up soccer supercross fag.

    D BoneD D Bone wrote on last edited by D Bone
    #18

    @tour2ma said:

    Shut up soccer supercross fag.

    ............ and you guys think going across the middle is for tough guys. We think that's cute.

    OMG!4-min.jpg

  • And how are they (whomever) going to do the financing for all of this ?   

    I do believe in looking ahead and creative thinking but are the CBS and Progressive beyond their useful lives ?

    hoortaH hoorta wrote on last edited by
    #19

    @mjp28 said:

    And how are they (whomever) going to do the financing for all of this ?   

    I do believe in looking ahead and creative thinking but are the CBS and Progressive beyond their useful lives ?

    Put a winning  team on the  field, and scew  the dome. Cold weather? New England,  Green Bay, Pittsburgh,  and Kansas  City. Any of  those cities  screaming  for a dome? Don't  think  so. Only  the wimps. It's  bullshit,  you can sit out in 10 degree weather  for hours and  be totally  comfortable- if you know  how to  dress  for it. 

    FWIW, I've been  to several  domed venues.  If that's the  ambiance  you want,  I  suggest you stay home,  save your money,  and watch the game on the tube. Because that's what you  get. 

    Domed stadium  for the Browns?  Just let Dan and Jimmy  toss in a billion each, and no problem.  That's the only way  it's  happening in Cleveland.  

    @the-gipper said:

    The tribes ballpark can last for another 50 or more years 

    Yeah Gip, they  should  tear down those Fenway  and Wrigley mausoleums too. 😁

  • Canton MikeC Canton Mike wrote on last edited by
    #20

    I'll not argue that a retractable dome may bring Super Bowls & other events to Cleveland but, as a 73 year old Browns' Fan & Season Ticket Member, I prefer football played "in the elements". I really can't imagine sitting "inside" at a football game. It just doesn't seem natural to me.

    Bottom line is that, no matter what, I'm all in as a Browns' Fan for the rest of my life.

    Mike 

  • I'll not argue that a retractable dome may bring Super Bowls & other events to Cleveland but, as a 73 year old Browns' Fan & Season Ticket Member, I prefer football played "in the elements". I really can't imagine sitting "inside" at a football game. It just doesn't seem natural to me.

    Bottom line is that, no matter what, I'm all in as a Browns' Fan for the rest of my life.

    Mike 

    Bob806B Bob806 wrote on last edited by
    #21

    @canton-mike said:

    I'll not argue that a retractable dome may bring Super Bowls & other events to Cleveland but, as a 73 year old Browns' Fan & Season Ticket Member, I prefer football played "in the elements". I really can't imagine sitting "inside" at a football game. It just doesn't seem natural to me.

    Bottom line is that, no matter what, I'm all in as a Browns' Fan for the rest of my life.

    Mike 

    Agree 100%. Dress for the tailgate and weather. Yeah, those windy days can be tough, but if we are still here after all the years of crap, we aren't going anywhere.

    In 2007 I took my (at the time) 12 year old son to St. Louis to watch the Browns/Rams game. It was boring sitting in a dome.Felt like a movie theater.

    Went to Jerry's Palace in 2012, Browns/Cowboys. While it's not a true "dome," it is pretty darn close. Honestly, I wasn't impressed with that stadium at all. I found myself looking at the giant TV too much (and bitching about Brandon Weeden lol...who throws a ball into the bleachers on 4th and goal from the 3?). 

    Went to Phoenix this year, Browns/Cardinals. Funny, I completely agree they need a dome, it's way to hot down there, but once again, just an odd atmosphere. 

    Our problem in Cleveland is simply our sports teams owners are all mixed up. Dolan needs to own an NBA or NFL team with a salary cap. Gilbert or Haslam should own the Tribe, they'd ante up for Lindor.