Skip to content

Most underrated Browns in modern era

The Browns Board
90 20 2.5k 1
  • D darubes wrote on last edited by
    #37

    Milt Morin TE

    Cody Reisen OT

  • ATOMA ATOM wrote on last edited by
    #38

    Greg Pruitt the king of the tear away jersey

  • RichiswhereR Richiswhere wrote on last edited by
    #39

    Big Daddy Carl Hairston  came over in his 30's and gave us many good years still

  • Was Sipe very good? I'm a little young to know. 

    Bob806B Bob806 wrote on last edited by
    #40

    @icecube said:

    Was Sipe very good? I'm a little young to know. 

    Sipe was very good, real "cerebral" with his game. Rightfully won the MVP in 1980. The Kardiac Kids were his team, great nerve-racking games (Browns defense was basically bad in 79-80).

  • mjp28M mjp28 wrote on last edited by mjp28
    #41

    Just to finish out the list the 13 BROWNS quarterbacks below Mayfield to 10 games started is listed below. The BROWNS also had an incredible 33 quarterbacks who had from 8 to 1 starts many in the 1999 plus era, explains a lot. There were 6 with 8 starts and 8 with only 1 start.

    Paul McDonald 21 8 13 0 .381
    Colt McCoy 21 6 15 0 .286
    Brandon Weeden 20 5 15 0 .250
    Charlie Frye 19 6 13 0 .316
    Brian Hoyer 16 10 6 0 .625
    DeShone Kizer 15 0 15 0 .000
    Tommy O'Connell 14 10 3 1 .750
    Kelly Holcomb 12 4 8 0 .333
    Brady Quinn 12 3 9 0 .250
    Jim Ninowski 11 5 6 0 .455
    Trent Dilfer 11 4 7 0 .364
    Josh McCown 11 1 10 0 .091
    Jeff Garcia 10 3 7 0 .300
  • This is a great topic Icecube.

    Good mentions so far. Let me add a few:

    Defense-Felix Wright, Walter Johnson (played with Jerry Sherk), Mike Johnson, Thom Darden , & Clarence Scott

    Offense- Vinny Testaverde, Calvin Hill (both were "short timers" but made a impact), Kevin Johnson, Mike Baab

    Special Teams- Matt Bahr, Gerald McNeil. I'm assuming Dawson, Cribbs, & Metcalf aren't under rated. 

    OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by Orion
    #42

    @bob806 said:

    Kevin Johnson

    That's the receiver we drafted with Couch, right?    He sucked.  IMO  - Jerry Rice wanted Kevin to work out with him and said he'd give him advice and pointers....and Johnson declined saying he didn't need his pointers.  - One time, on 3rd down, he went down and caught a low pass for 1st down yardage, and then proceeded to roll backwards so as to avoid a hit...by the time he got tagged down he had lost the 1st down, we had to punt, and Butch Davis took him out of the game and he never played again.  I'll never forget that play.  He musta' rolled backwards 2 or 3 yards.  I was like, "You fucin' coward!"  

    Sorry to pick on that one Bob806.   I like your other choices though.

  • OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by
    #43

    Mike Johnson was a really good LBer.  Tom Cousineau was good too.  And Eddie Johnson.

    Chris Berman use to call him Kevin MMMMMMMMMack!  A really powerful runner who could catch.  

    Webster Slaughter was supposed to block the guy that stripped the ball from Byner on The Fumble.   Instead, he stood there like a statue and WATCHED the play like he had a front row seat.  

    Greg Pruitt was great....but Mike Pruitt was quite good...and a powerful runner.  I really liked him.

    Steve Heiden was a pretty good TE.   Michael He-He Jackson was a pretty good receiver.  Michael Dean Perry was a good DLineman.  He got some credit, but maybe he deserved more.

  • Mike Johnson was a really good LBer.  Tom Cousineau was good too.  And Eddie Johnson.

    Chris Berman use to call him Kevin MMMMMMMMMack!  A really powerful runner who could catch.  

    Webster Slaughter was supposed to block the guy that stripped the ball from Byner on The Fumble.   Instead, he stood there like a statue and WATCHED the play like he had a front row seat.  

    Greg Pruitt was great....but Mike Pruitt was quite good...and a powerful runner.  I really liked him.

    Steve Heiden was a pretty good TE.   Michael He-He Jackson was a pretty good receiver.  Michael Dean Perry was a good DLineman.  He got some credit, but maybe he deserved more.

    I Icecube wrote on last edited by
    #44

    @orion said:

    Mike Johnson was a really good LBer.  Tom Cousineau was good too.  And Eddie Johnson.

    Chris Berman use to call him Kevin MMMMMMMMMack!  A really powerful runner who could catch.  

    Webster Slaughter was supposed to block the guy that stripped the ball from Byner on The Fumble.   Instead, he stood there like a statue and WATCHED the play like he had a front row seat.  

    Greg Pruitt was great....but Mike Pruitt was quite good...and a powerful runner.  I really liked him.

    Steve Heiden was a pretty good TE.   Michael He-He Jackson was a pretty good receiver.  Michael Dean Perry was a good DLineman.  He got some credit, but maybe he deserved more.

    Mike Jackson was pretty damn good. 6-4 and fast. 

    https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/J/JackMi00.htm

  • Dutch OvenD Dutch Oven wrote on last edited by
    #45

    I thought Tom Cousineau was a bust?

  • I thought Tom Cousineau was a bust?

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #46

    @dutch-oven said:

    I thought Tom Cousineau was a bust?

    Pretty much, yes. 

    Or, maybe he was OK....but just not up to #1 overall status.

  • I thought Tom Cousineau was a bust?

    mjp28M mjp28 wrote on last edited by
    #47

    @dutch-oven said:

    I thought Tom Cousineau was a bust?

    Right up there with Joe Charbenau.  But neat last names.

  • @dutch-oven said:

    I thought Tom Cousineau was a bust?

    Right up there with Joe Charbenau.  But neat last names.

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by The Gipper
    #48

    @mjp28 said:

    Right up there with Joe Charbeneau.  But neat last names.

    Neau they're not.    😆  Nor is Burreau...or is that Burreaux.

  • Greg Pruitt the king of the tear away jersey

    Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by
    #49

    So the "modern era" started in the 30's???

    @atom said:

    Greg Pruitt the king of the tear away jersey

    That would be Earl Campbell. Bonus in video below is the Isaiah Robertson collision.

    http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-videos/0ap2000000149543/Earl-Campbell-s-jersey-ripped-off

  • Just to finish out the list the 13 BROWNS quarterbacks below Mayfield to 10 games started is listed below. The BROWNS also had an incredible 33 quarterbacks who had from 8 to 1 starts many in the 1999 plus era, explains a lot. There were 6 with 8 starts and 8 with only 1 start.

    Paul McDonald 21 8 13 0 .381
    Colt McCoy 21 6 15 0 .286
    Brandon Weeden 20 5 15 0 .250
    Charlie Frye 19 6 13 0 .316
    Brian Hoyer 16 10 6 0 .625
    DeShone Kizer 15 0 15 0 .000
    Tommy O'Connell 14 10 3 1 .750
    Kelly Holcomb 12 4 8 0 .333
    Brady Quinn 12 3 9 0 .250
    Jim Ninowski 11 5 6 0 .455
    Trent Dilfer 11 4 7 0 .364
    Josh McCown 11 1 10 0 .091
    Jeff Garcia 10 3 7 0 .300
    I Icecube wrote on last edited by
    #50

    @mjp28 said:

    Just to finish out the list the 13 BROWNS quarterbacks below Mayfield to 10 games started is listed below. The BROWNS also had an incredible 33 quarterbacks who had from 8 to 1 starts many in the 1999 plus era, explains a lot. There were 6 with 8 starts and 8 with only 1 start.

    Paul McDonald 21 8 13 0 .381
    Colt McCoy 21 6 15 0 .286
    Brandon Weeden 20 5 15 0 .250
    Charlie Frye 19 6 13 0 .316
    Brian Hoyer 16 10 6 0 .625
    DeShone Kizer 15 0 15 0 .000
    Tommy O'Connell 14 10 3 1 .750
    Kelly Holcomb 12 4 8 0 .333
    Brady Quinn 12 3 9 0 .250
    Jim Ninowski 11 5 6 0 .455
    Trent Dilfer 11 4 7 0 .364
    Josh McCown 11 1 10 0 .091
    Jeff Garcia 10 3 7 0 .300

    That is one painful list to look at. 

  • @mjp28 said:

    Just to finish out the list the 13 BROWNS quarterbacks below Mayfield to 10 games started is listed below. The BROWNS also had an incredible 33 quarterbacks who had from 8 to 1 starts many in the 1999 plus era, explains a lot. There were 6 with 8 starts and 8 with only 1 start.

    Paul McDonald 21 8 13 0 .381
    Colt McCoy 21 6 15 0 .286
    Brandon Weeden 20 5 15 0 .250
    Charlie Frye 19 6 13 0 .316
    Brian Hoyer 16 10 6 0 .625
    DeShone Kizer 15 0 15 0 .000
    Tommy O'Connell 14 10 3 1 .750
    Kelly Holcomb 12 4 8 0 .333
    Brady Quinn 12 3 9 0 .250
    Jim Ninowski 11 5 6 0 .455
    Trent Dilfer 11 4 7 0 .364
    Josh McCown 11 1 10 0 .091
    Jeff Garcia 10 3 7 0 .300

    That is one painful list to look at. 

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #51

    @icecube said:

    That is one painful list to look at. 

    And it don't get any better after that.   Cody Kessler, not on that list:   0-8.   And others. 

  • So the "modern era" started in the 30's???

    @atom said:

    Greg Pruitt the king of the tear away jersey

    That would be Earl Campbell. Bonus in video below is the Isaiah Robertson collision.

    http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-videos/0ap2000000149543/Earl-Campbell-s-jersey-ripped-off

    ATOMA ATOM wrote on last edited by
    #52

    @tour2ma said:

    So the "modern era" started in the 30's???

    That would be Earl Campbell. Bonus in video below is the Isaiah Robertson collision.

    http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-videos/0ap2000000149543/Earl-Campbell-s-jersey-ripped-off

    thanks for the earl video i still will never forget that MNF game vs miami 

    But Greg was first with the tear away

  • I Icecube wrote on last edited by
    #53

    Derrick Alexander only here for 2 seasons, but he was underrated overall, in my opinion. 

  • ATOMA ATOM wrote on last edited by
    #54

  • Mike Johnson was a really good LBer.  Tom Cousineau was good too.  And Eddie Johnson.

    Chris Berman use to call him Kevin MMMMMMMMMack!  A really powerful runner who could catch.  

    Webster Slaughter was supposed to block the guy that stripped the ball from Byner on The Fumble.   Instead, he stood there like a statue and WATCHED the play like he had a front row seat.  

    Greg Pruitt was great....but Mike Pruitt was quite good...and a powerful runner.  I really liked him.

    Steve Heiden was a pretty good TE.   Michael He-He Jackson was a pretty good receiver.  Michael Dean Perry was a good DLineman.  He got some credit, but maybe he deserved more.

    S SdBacker80 wrote on last edited by
    #55

    @orion said:

    Mike Johnson was a really good LBer.  Tom Cousineau was good too.  And Eddie Johnson.

    Chris Berman use to call him Kevin MMMMMMMMMack!  A really powerful runner who could catch.  

    Webster Slaughter was supposed to block the guy that stripped the ball from Byner on The Fumble.   Instead, he stood there like a statue and WATCHED the play like he had a front row seat.  

    Greg Pruitt was great....but Mike Pruitt was quite good...and a powerful runner.  I really liked him.

    Steve Heiden was a pretty good TE.   Michael He-He Jackson was a pretty good receiver.  Michael Dean Perry was a good DLineman.  He got some credit, but maybe he deserved more.

    Michael Dean Perry good one.  He had career with us  making it difficult on teams to run on us.

  • S SdBacker80 wrote on last edited by
    #56

    Leroy Hoard.  Didn’t really standout in anything just steady and reliable