Anderson looking like the starter tonight

Flugel

@lumbergh said:
Anderson throws for 120 yards, including 5 20+ yard plays, in the first quarter. The browns are up by 20 points.

ALMOST as good as what Quinn did to them as a rookie after holding out until a few days before the Detroit game. And guess WHICH poster reminded everyone it was only Detroilet? That would come from 1 Loverboy Lane.

God bless ya!

- Tom F.

Lumbergh

@jadbf said:
NO DA LED ONE DRIVE for 7 points.

Actually DA had 3 for 13 points.

Quinn was 2 for zero points.

In case you're scoring at home.

BrownIndian

@jadbf said:
and did you notice they didn't trust DA to throw in the redzone so they had Jamal run for the TD?

That is a lame reason. If we take that reason as a case point, then the fact that they did not bring Quinn to play means they dont trust him @ all ?

We score a touch down after 7 games and what do we do ? argue if DA is better or BQ ! cos the rest of the team is playoff material right ?

RestinPeace

@brownindian said:
That is a lame reason. If we take that reason as a case point, then the fact that they did not bring Quinn to play means they dont trust him @ all ?
We score a touch down after 7 games and what do we do ? argue if DA is better or BQ ! cos the rest of the team is playoff material right ?

It is preseason guy. Who cares if they score a TD, cause it doesn't count. Listen, considering how scripted everything is in the preseason, don't you think a little effort by the Lions to eh..actually play defense may have led to a different endpoint? Ditto on the Browns last week against the Packers.

That is the point of the so called "QB" battle. If Mangini doesn't know who he wants at QB right now, then he will never make it as coach.

Geech

@chumpchange said:
Hey, just providing the numbers, guys.
QB rating is what they evaluate every other quarterback by, so it's relevant in our case, too.

Really? They don't evaluate QBs based on Wins and Losses?

Speaking of which, Quinn looks so damn good as a QB yet he hasn't racked up a single W. He looked so good at that scrimmage a few weeks back, right? Yet, who got the W? Right! He looked superb against GB last week, right? Yet who got the W and who got goose-egged?

Let's go back to that scrimmage. Who in their right mind would rather have Quinn "looking good" while racking up the L instead of DA looking like crap yet racking up the W?

It's all relative. The only reason Quinn looks like such a fantastic QB is because everyone is comparing him to Anderception. Set your standards a little higher.

Wins and losses, grasshoppers...Wins and Losses!

-Al

P.S. So...

Dawson - 9

JLew - 6

Davis - 6

Cribbs - 6

Anderception - 13 (By proxy)

Quinn - 0 (Two weeks and counting)

BrownIndian

I doubt it thought. Cos if he has picked his QB, then it is absolutely quintessential that the first team QB gets the most reps. Else the preseason games goes to waste.

Besides, looking at the way Brett FAvre played last night, I feel that we do have a realistic chance of pulling of an upset if we still face Vikings with Favre @ the helm.

Flugel

@jadbf said:
NO DA LED ONE DRIVE for 7 points. Cribbs scored on a punt return, and the second "Drive" was a result of an int DEEP in detroit teritory
Da played well enough to stay in the discussion of who should start.

DOn't over do it though.

Thanks JADBF!

This is typical! DA always got all the credit for Josh Cribbs giving us the conference best field position. Today, he's getting credit for Cribbs' return as usual. Basically, DA led 1 TD drive against a team that was 0-16. Now Loverboy is spinning that like a DJ puttin the needle on the record.

Then we play real teams - Loverboy has a tendency to blame Hurricane Ike, Mother Nature, Jack Frost and now the concussion. Wasn't someone insinuating Quinn shouldn't have started if he was too injured to play with a fractured index finger? Isn't it funny how that criteria changes for the concussion/walking coma or whatever the freak it was?

I'm at the point where I've seen 27 DA starts where I actually INLCUDE the last 9. We're a 3-6 type of team with him on a normal schedule. If the football gods will ever be kind enough to give us 10 opponents that averaged 4-5 wins again - we could go 8-8 with DA. No thanks!

I'm going to trust Mangini will understand why the last brass got fired and that 31 other teams consider DA a backup. Doesn't mean Quinn has proven a THING as it's been said. It just means DA has proven he's not the right guy. Since we drafted Quinn in round 1 - it would be nice to start him when the ENTIRE team is interested in the season. If we throw him out there again after the shit inevitably hits the fan with Dumb Ass - I'll guarantee a guy like Shaun Rogers tells us he's done with the Detroit mindset he thought he left already.

- Tom F.

Geech

@jadbf said:
Oh come on AL, set YOUR standards higher! Wins and Losse? Teams can win DESPITE their QBS. Don't settle for a QB that is "barely good enough".
Quinn may not be the answer...but DA isn't either.

And again. Giving DA credit for 3 points on a field goal when they started with field position in field goal range seems strange to me...give credit for those 3 to Wright.

Fair enough. I have to wait until tomorrow to watch the game on NFL Network. I'm just going by what youz guyz is sayin'.

I know that DA is definitely not the answer. He's streakier than Craig Ehlo and Gerald Wilkins's secret love child...but we have to hold Quinn to a higher standard. We can't say, "Oh Quinn's 23 QBR is better than DA's 19." That's ridiculous.

Utterly ridiculous.

-Al

P.S. I've come to learn that in NFL Terminology, "good enough" most often means "not good enough."

Geech

@jadbf said:
That's mostly why I'd prefer to see Quinn start at least half this year. End the debate. If Quinn sucks...then we're screwed.

Right! 'Cause we already know that DA sucks. Let's see what the Quinner can do.

-Al

Tobalaz

@jadbf said:
yeah when you count the fact that his offense GOT THE BALL already in field goal range and kicked a field goal. WAY TO GO DA!! WOOO HOOOO

that happened a lot when DA supposedly led us to 10-6.

PlaygroundLegend

Thats complete BS, DA in the first quarter was facing a cover 1 the whole time, I was there. As soon as they switched to the cover 2 during his 2-minute drill DA couldn't do shit, he makes a high throw and it goes for a pick, classic Anderception

If it wasn't for Mr.St. Clair tonight Quinn would've had himself 2 mighty fine drives down field, but mr. St. Clair decided to cause 2 penalties and mess our shit up, I was pretty pissed. St. Clair better be running hella laps on monday

Quinn played good, but diddnt get enough snaps nor pass plays called, he was at 3rd and 5 TWICE and Daboll calls a run to Davis TWICE. It almost looked as if they were doing that to Quinn on purpose.

DA threw a pick tonight, classic, it was a very high, short pass that was rocketed out of the cockpit. He also severely underthrew Braylon on a would be TD pass. To be honest DA diddnt really show me anything, Lewis scored that TD, not DA, and DA fizzled out in the red zone like 3-4 times tonight

Sorry guys but if you look at the whole picture including last week, Quinn still has this one in the bag

dawgpound3

@playgroundlegend said:
Thats complete BS, DA in the first quarter was facing a cover 1 the whole time, I was there. As soon as they switched to the cover 2 during his 2-minute drill DA couldn't do shit, he makes a high throw and it goes for a pick, classic Anderception
If it wasn't for Mr.St. Clair tonight Quinn would've had himself 2 mighty fine drives down field, but mr. St. Clair decided to cause 2 penalties and mess our shit up, I was pretty pissed. St. Clair better be running hella laps on monday

Quinn played good, but diddnt get enough snaps nor pass plays called, he was at 3rd and 5 TWICE and Daboll calls a run to Davis TWICE. It almost looked as if they were doing that to Quinn on purpose.

DA threw a pick tonight, classic, it was a very high, short pass that was rocketed out of the cockpit. He also severely underthrew Braylon on a would be TD pass. To be honest DA diddnt really show me anything, Lewis scored that TD, not DA, and DA fizzled out in the red zone like 3-4 times tonight

Sorry guys but if you look at the whole picture including last week, Quinn still has this one in the bag

I agree, Quinn did good. I think Quinn is the man. But, but the competition is still not dead.

ATENEARS

Tjis Anderson guy is good ... well, maybe not good ... but holding off Brady Quinn

Take it for what it is worth

daddybull1

The one thing that tonights game showed me is that some of the posters on this board know diddley squat about football...

Some of you should put aside your personal biases and just watch the game, your critque of what I saw tonight is really off the wall and in no way accurate...

Peace

T.Dawg

osusev

jadbf DA threw for over 100 yds in one quarter PERIOD. He did well tonight, that pick off the tips of our guy was the same as Quinns tip of a their linebackers one just got caught by the wrong guy.... It happens neither was a terrible read or forced play.

DA threw for 61% and WE SCORED.... that BS about coach/offensive coordinator confidence is so laughably stupid about the playcalling for Jamal to run in it on a short field after all passes getting us there is so dumb and biased based on your pure conjecture its not even logical.

This is PRESEASON and we need to see ALL of starters in specific performance situations....

Shut up about the 2 minute drill... WE WERE UP BY 20 points and it was about 1:00 when we actually got the ball.... good god.

I thought BQ got screwed by some funky offensive calling like DA did last week not to mention St clair blowing up BQ's drive by himself.

We looked much better against another terrible team lets see what happens next week against Tennessee, I think we will have our starter after next week.

? mz.

I mean, we are acting as if we didn't have TWO quarterbacks play reasonably well tonight.

When's the last time we could say that without laughing?

Vegasdogg

The pass at the end of the 1st half never should have been thrown. Watch how he moves into the pressure, than chucks it into the air. At these precise moments good teams wait for the other team to choke. Had that been regular season, the 2nd half pressure on DA would have caused him to fold after halftime.

Seriously he just chucked it up and prayed. That is what I can't stand him as a starter.

Remember folks. Mangini stated he is testing these guys under pressure. Throwing for 130 yards and leading the team to 13 points is outstanding for 1 quarter of work.

But how did you finish under pressure?

? TheJokersWILD

Steeler SChuck said:
Too bad the stains don't play the hapless Lions every week. Yinz might hit .500 this year.
Regards

..... an'at

.

What are the odds that you post a comment during a Browns game You are always on this site talking shit, you post during a Browns game, what you secretly a Browns fans??? It's ok if you are We all know how infectious it is to root for a great franchise like the Browns

beefjerky

I'm so sick of this 'BQ Fags' and 'DA Fags' thing, and I can't believe there's people in this thread trying to say DA had a bad game.

just give us a winner at the QB position and I don't give a damn who it is, however I am a bit concerned about DA's consistency so if he can do what he did against detroit next week against tennessee I'll be convinced, Quinn looks more consistent though.

Vegasdogg

Zombo said:

I'm glad Quinn showed us how to follow up a dropped pass in the end zone last week.

"Derek Anderson started and went 6-of-9 for 119 yards in the first quarter including completions of 39 yards to Braylon Edwards, 24 yards to Mohamed Massaquoi and 20 to Cribbs. He finished 8-of-13 for 130 yards and was intercepted by William James in the closing seconds of the first half on a pass that went off Davis' hands and led to the field goal that provided the Lions' first points."

Give me a break. Dude we have seen this from DA before. I admitted he did some nice things tonight. But look man, he did it against the NYG, and then crapped the bed against WASH. So tell me dude, which QB is he? Which one will show up against BAL and PIT?

Don't give me this shit about DA playing well. I've seen it before, I know he has good games in him. I also know he has not done this when we needed it, nor has he done it against the good teams in the AFC, not has he been consistent enough to play well week in and week out. The team has not played well, but if he had played well we'd never be having this conversation.

So when you complain about DA not getting a fair shake, it is because we don't know who the f*ck the real DA is. Is it the guy vs NYG, or WAS? Don't act like we all are down on DA because we like BQ. Some of us are down on DA because of DA and his Sybil-like performances.

You say you've been a fan for 40 years. Well, do you think DA can play like this for 16 games? 10? 5? What does the past tell you? Hell I have seen DA have games like Stafford had.