Skip to content
The Browns Board
  1. Home
  2. The Browns Board
  3. Quarterback Merry Go Round

Quarterback Merry Go Round

The Browns Board
206 24 6.3k 1
  • The GipperT The Gipper

    @sdbacker80 said:

    Co-Sign this post too.  But Mayfield showed us something last season I’m saying he’s there. 

    The alternative is Dalton with a guy like Trey Lance waiting in the wings.  But Dalton apparently to some on here can give you something on par with what Dak gives you...ignorant thought if you watched Cowboy games last season.

    Dalton HAS given you on par with what Dak has performed in his career.  But, OK, I would take Dak over Dalton as my permanent starter, now.  But Dalton's role would be only as the "bridge" QB....and that is all I am saying. 

    @the-gipper said:

    Dalton HAS given you on par with what Dak has performed in his career.  But, OK, I would take Dak over Dalton as my permanent starter, now.  But Dalton's role would be only as the "bridge" QB....and that is all I am saying. 

    And as I mentioned before do you think Good Ole Jerry Jones is gonna just throw away a year.  He brought in McCarthy he’s got Zeke in his prime and Jerry is getting old.  He pressed the go button last year, the year before last and so forth.

    Get in Jerry’s head for one second his QB options are Trevor Lawrence or Dak. One isn’t realistic and the other is expensive.

  • S SdBacker80

    @the-gipper said:

    Dalton HAS given you on par with what Dak has performed in his career.  But, OK, I would take Dak over Dalton as my permanent starter, now.  But Dalton's role would be only as the "bridge" QB....and that is all I am saying. 

    And as I mentioned before do you think Good Ole Jerry Jones is gonna just throw away a year.  He brought in McCarthy he’s got Zeke in his prime and Jerry is getting old.  He pressed the go button last year, the year before last and so forth.

    Get in Jerry’s head for one second his QB options are Trevor Lawrence or Dak. One isn’t realistic and the other is expensive.

    @sdbacker80 said:

    And as I mentioned before do you think Good Ole Jerry Jones is gonna just throw away a year.  He brought in McCarthy he’s got Zeke in his prime and Jerry is getting old.  He pressed the go button last year, the year before last and so forth.

    Get in Jerry’s head for one second his QB options are Trevor Lawrence or Dak. One isn’t realistic and the other is expensive.

    LOL.  Yea.  Certainly discussing any sort of strategy that involves trying to think what Jerry Jones would do is a different exercise from trying to think what what a competent owner/gm would do. 

  • OK, here you go for another round of " What should Yada yada do in the best interests of their team".

    Let's look at the Jets.    They seem to have a number of options,  and it seems to me they are probably in serious debate mode over these.  (Note:   Jets now have a new GM and a new HC..and perhaps, maybe they have someone competent trying to make these decisions...unlike before)

    Options:

    A.   Keep Darnold as their QB.  Use their  #2 and #23 picks  on non QBs  who can hopefully help the team.

    B. Keep Darnold as their QB.  Use their #2 pick as trade bait for some other team to take a QB in exchange for  more high draft picks.  Either a couple of more  1st and second rounders this year, or more first rounders next year....and maybe some current players that could help.

    C. Try to package Darnold, and their #2 pick in an attempt to trade with Houston for DeShaun Watson.

    D. Punt on Darnold.  Try to get the best you can from him in a trade.  Use #2 pick on a new QB. 

    E. Keep Darnold,  but still take a QB with the #2 pick to eventually replace him.    That move, naturally would have Darnold demanding a trade anyway. 

    F.   Some  other options I have not thought of?

    Give your pros and cons on any of these  Options.  

  • S SdBacker80

    @the-gipper said:

    Dak is moving up your list I see 15-20 now 10-15...your opinion looks a little better now.


    Regarding tiers...

    I like Justin Fields.  But Fields and Trey Lance they will need some time.  They are projects.  That’s probably what’s left at their spot.   But Maybe we give credit to the Cowboys scouting department Dak was selected late and was ROY.  

    @sdbacker80 said:

    I like Justin Fields.  But Fields and Trey Lance they will need some time.  They are projects.  That’s probably what’s left at their spot.   But Maybe we give credit to the Cowboys scouting department Dak was selected late and was ROY.  

    You are forgetting Kellen Mond... the Dak of 2021.

    Not joking... I see a lot of similarities. 'Boys can resign Dalton and groom Mond most of the season.

    The 'Boys have put themselves in cap hell and resigning Dak to a big deal simply perpetuates that condition. Add in the uncertainty of Dak's horrendous injury and it just doesn't make sense for Jerrah & Co. to sign Dak...

    Of course that only increases the likelihood that is exactly what Jonsey will do... 😉

    "When you have a shared vision it is a lot easier to make unpopular decisions." - Paul DePodesta "When you win, say nothing. When you lose, say less." - Paul Brown Complete 2017 Browns Board Mock: http://thebrownsboard.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=46196

  • My feelings:   

    1.  While it would be good to acquire Watson.....it is not certain that Houston will even attempt to trade him   "Watson strategy"  could/should be another thread, but as far as the Jets are concerned,  is getting Watson at the cost of say  Darnold, the #2 pick their #23 pick, plus more  really worth it?   That team is already emasculated in most areas besides QB.  Would they really improve by getting Watson and giving all their other assets that could improve the team in so many other areas?  I say no.   It would be unaffordable for the present and future of one of the worst current teams on the league.

    2.  Getting rid of Darnold, nor keeping him and using the #2 pick on another QB  do not seem prudent to me.  Darnold was the #3 pick.  What is to say the #2 pick QB this will be any better than him...particularly if you do not give him any help beside a disgruntled young QB to compete against.  Further, who knows what kind of value you can get for Darnold.  I don't think he is that bad.  He is young and learning and growing,  but he needs help. 

    3. Ergo, I say  do either A or B above.  If someone will give you a buttload for the #2 pick, go for it....and hope you have a new GM who can really capable of making the best of the picks.  They need weapons on offense,  protection for the QB,  and help in the DL and DB .    As bad as that team,  they can't do everything they need even with 2 first round picks.  If they could drop down,  get a 1 this year,  a 1 next year,  and another 2d and a 3rd...and maybe more, it would be best for them IMO. 

  • So, this represents a consensus between myself,  Unsympathetic and Tour. 

    And, in the other corner are?  : 

    But, for the sake of hoping the Cowboys mire themselves in suckage for a long time,  I hope the other corner's position prevails.  

    S 1 Reply

  • As promised,  here is a thread on what the Texans Strategy, vis a vis Deshaun Watson, should be.

    Note...this is not titled  'Watson's strategy".    Watson has claimed he wants out, and I believe him.  If the DATs  accommodate him, he just has to decide where he would approve a move to.  There is no issue of money involved.  He has a long term deal in place.  If he goes somewhere they have to either accept it, or try to renegotiate  (and why would Watson do that?)

    No, the issue is:  What action should the Texans take:

    A. Play hardball.  Continue to insist he is not going to be traded, and follow through on that,  even if it means he sits out a year.  Of course, continue to try to  woo and cajole him and try to convince him staying put is his best option.

    B. Concede and  try to trade him.   But, to where and for what?    

    .....1. To Jets for Darnold and their two first round picks..plus extra

    .....2. To Dolphins for Tua and their two first round picks...and extra.

    ....3. Say to Watson....We will trade you, but only for an acceptable package...and ONLY to an NFC team.  Say to him, if you insist on leaving, we don't want to see your ass except once every 4 years. 

    ...4. Or just say...we will trade you to the team that gives us the best offer in return regardless of division or conference, as long as we get a ton of picks/young veteran players.  In other words, go Sonny Weaver on them:  "You want Bo Callahan, we want  3 first round picks and a punt returner".  Or something like that.   (except, unlike with Bo...you know you won't be getting a potential bust". 

    C.  Something else I have not thought of? 

  • Trade demand ripple effect

    As to what Texans accept in a trade? Easterby is a shitposter in human form, so I can't see his "logic" for anything.  If you guess correctly, go immediately to Vegas..

    The more labels you have for yourself, the dumber they make you. "When you win, say nothing. When you lose, say less." Paul Brown
  • U Unsympathetic

    Trade demand ripple effect

    As to what Texans accept in a trade? Easterby is a shitposter in human form, so I can't see his "logic" for anything.  If you guess correctly, go immediately to Vegas..

    @unsympathetic said:

    It almost doesn't matter what we "think" will happen.. Texans have no chance of winning until they fire Easterby.

    Trade demand ripple effect

    As to what they'll accept? Easterby is a shitposter in human form, so "logic" can't be included.

    While all that may be true,  (it really NEVER matters what sports fans think)..... we can still talk about it  as if, perhaps there were someone with logic running the show for these teams. 

    And, to quote someone:  "We just stand back and let it all be". 

  • I don't think anyone has that kind of space.. although he had a 70% completion rate last season with that roster and that dysfunction.. Watson is unreal.

    The more labels you have for yourself, the dumber they make you. "When you win, say nothing. When you lose, say less." Paul Brown
  • The GipperT The Gipper

    So, this represents a consensus between myself,  Unsympathetic and Tour. 

    And, in the other corner are?  : 

    But, for the sake of hoping the Cowboys mire themselves in suckage for a long time,  I hope the other corner's position prevails.  

    @the-gipper said:

    So, this represents a consensus between myself,  Unsympathetic and Tour. 

    And, in the other corner are?  : 

    But, for the sake of hoping the Cowboys mire themselves in suckage for a long time,  I hope the other corner's position prevails.  

    I’m with you assuming we know the Cowboys find another draftee that will have a 42-27 record and win rookie of the year.

  • S SdBacker80

    @the-gipper said:

    So, this represents a consensus between myself,  Unsympathetic and Tour. 

    And, in the other corner are?  : 

    But, for the sake of hoping the Cowboys mire themselves in suckage for a long time,  I hope the other corner's position prevails.  

    I’m with you assuming we know the Cowboys find another draftee that will have a 42-27 record and win rookie of the year.

    @sdbacker80 said:

    I’m with you assuming we know the Cowboys find another draftee that will have a 42-27 record and win rookie of the year.

    Most accomplished during first season.... on a rookie deal with a great OL and defense.  

    Now they are shite.....and now  he wants to be paid  20% of his team's salary cap.

    Notes, just for reference:  On a 53 man roster with a  185 million salary cap,  the average salary...i.e if each and every player got 1/53 of the team's salary cap, that would be 3.5 million per player.   But if one guy gets  37 million, that means that  means the other  52 players must share 148 million....or  2.84 million.    Zeke Elliot has a 13.7 million cap hit.   So those 2 players alone could take up  50.7 million of the 185 mill cap hit.  Amari Cooper's cap hit is 22 million.  So, their "triplets"   would take up  72.7  million of their cap number...or  39.3%  of their total salary.  That leaves  112.3 million to be divided between  50 players...or  an average of 2.246 mill per player.  

    I don't know.....can a team pay  3 of its players nearly 40% of their entire budget....and still be a good team?

    Pay him that and see what his team's record would be in the future.   He would be lucky to achieve the reverse of that record. 

    I say it would doom them to a future of  3-6 wins per season for the foreseeable future. 

  • The GipperT The Gipper

    @sdbacker80 said:

    I’m with you assuming we know the Cowboys find another draftee that will have a 42-27 record and win rookie of the year.

    Most accomplished during first season.... on a rookie deal with a great OL and defense.  

    Now they are shite.....and now  he wants to be paid  20% of his team's salary cap.

    Notes, just for reference:  On a 53 man roster with a  185 million salary cap,  the average salary...i.e if each and every player got 1/53 of the team's salary cap, that would be 3.5 million per player.   But if one guy gets  37 million, that means that  means the other  52 players must share 148 million....or  2.84 million.    Zeke Elliot has a 13.7 million cap hit.   So those 2 players alone could take up  50.7 million of the 185 mill cap hit.  Amari Cooper's cap hit is 22 million.  So, their "triplets"   would take up  72.7  million of their cap number...or  39.3%  of their total salary.  That leaves  112.3 million to be divided between  50 players...or  an average of 2.246 mill per player.  

    I don't know.....can a team pay  3 of its players nearly 40% of their entire budget....and still be a good team?

    Pay him that and see what his team's record would be in the future.   He would be lucky to achieve the reverse of that record. 

    I say it would doom them to a future of  3-6 wins per season for the foreseeable future. 

    @the-gipper said:

    Most accomplished during first season.... on a rookie deal with a great OL and defense.  

    Now they are shite.....and now  he wants to be paid  20% of his team's salary cap.

    Notes, just for reference:  On a 53 man roster with a  185 million salary cap,  the average salary...i.e if each and every player got 1/53 of the team's salary cap, that would be 3.5 million per player.   But if one guy gets  37 million, that means that  means the other  52 players must share 148 million....or  2.84 million.    Zeke Elliot has a 13.7 million cap hit.   So those 2 players alone could take up  50.7 million of the 185 mill cap hit.  Amari Cooper's cap hit is 22 million.  So, their "triplets"   would take up  72.7  million of their cap number...or  39.3%  of their total salary.  That leaves  112.3 million to be divided between  50 players...or  an average of 2.246 mill per player.  

    I don't know.....can a team pay  3 of its players nearly 40% of their entire budget....and still be a good team?

    Pay him that and see what his team's record would be in the future.   He would be lucky to achieve the reverse of that record. 

    I say it would doom them to a future of  3-6 wins per season for the foreseeable future. 

    Welcome To this era of football.  We are Browns fans we haven’t been here before...I get it. But I think we are here.

    Browns will be Baker and Myles and hopefully some wise draft selections under rookie contracts and vets taking discounts. 
     

    Lots of cap talk on the forum these days and too many us think we are re-signing guys like Bitonio, Landry, etc- see my vets taking discounts comment if they want to stay.  The beauty of our situation - WE don’t have bad contracts.  Myles is bad if he flops.  You can make a slight case for Hooper.  That’s all!!! The FO right now is measuring Baker figuring out that number is the first domino - the Cowboys didn’t do that but they will fit Dak’s contract in- my guess- my prediction.
     

    In regard to Dak, Jerry screwed it up...but what is the alternative?  Your suggestions while an option don’t provide the right answer to the question What Would Jerry Do?
     

    And what is exactly wrong with Dak?  You think this is a middle of the road QB...I don’t.  

    E6AF5EFF-C27E-494C-BC8E-4DDA99E6B66B.jpeg

  • In regard to Dak, Jerry screwed it up...but what is the alternative?  Your suggestions while an option don’t provide the right answer to the question What Would Jerry Do?

    I would never propose to figure what Jerry Jones will do...

    I will only say: "  I think it can reliably be said that  Jerry will fuck things up.   And I am good with that." 

  • Could there be a possible switch of QBs between Dallas and  Seattle?   Rumblings are that Wilson may want out of Seattle, and would accept a trade to Dallas.   Would Jerry Jones drop his interest in  Dak like a rock if he thinks he could get Wilson?

    https://www.si.com/nfl/cowboys/news/florio-seahawks-qb-russell-wilson-has-eye-on-dallas-cowboys

  • Washington prepared to part ways with  Alex Smith?

    https://sports.yahoo.com/nfl-rumors-possible-alex-smith-155702779.html

    Perhaps a done deal?

    https://sports.yahoo.com/does-alex-smith-release-mean-160007134.html

  • Could Rudolph the Racist Reindeer be out in Pittsburgh?

    https://sports.yahoo.com/tim-benz-does-ben-roethlisberger-190100583.html

  • Old Buddy  Josh McCown cut.    Could turn to coaching:

    https://sports.yahoo.com/texans-cut-josh-mccown-may-213937023.html

  • Marcus Mariota,   possibly to the Eagles?

    https://sports.yahoo.com/nfl-rumors-eagles-reportedly-team-172835801.html

  • 1. Colts.....Carson Wentz  to Colts in trade  with Eagles.

    2. Saints

    3. Texans

    4. Lions.....Jared Goff....to Lions in trade with Rams

    5. Cowboys

    6. Bears

    7. Jaguars.....belief is that  Trevor Lawrence will be the guy...noting official until the draft. 

    8. Patriots

    9. Broncos

    10.  Washington

    11. Eagles.....Jalen Hurts???

    12. Panthers

    13. Dolphins

    14. Falcons

    15. 49ers

    16. Steelers.....Ben Roethlisberger

    17.  Packers

    18. Rams?  Matt Stafford to Rams in trade for Goff.

    Over half the teams in the league. 

    BR signing a reduced deal  ensures that he will at least start the season as the Starting QB for the Squeelers. 

Log in to reply