Skip to content

Holmgren To Be Removed

The Browns Board
43 29 3.7k
  • hoortaH hoorta wrote on last edited by
    #26

    Formerly Sane said:

    It was such a short time ago that most of you here thought I was just a troll when I said that Holmgren had very limited qualifications to be the head honcho.....and he got fired from that gig too!

    It looks like it won't matter much as it's odds on he's going to get fired again. The McCoy & Weeden picks are all on Mike. BW is going to have to improve 1,000% to make it look like Holmie didn't screw up twice.

  • Formerly Sane said:

    It was such a short time ago that most of you here thought I was just a troll when I said that Holmgren had very limited qualifications to be the head honcho.....and he got fired from that gig too!

    It looks like it won't matter much as it's odds on he's going to get fired again. The McCoy & Weeden picks are all on Mike. BW is going to have to improve 1,000% to make it look like Holmie didn't screw up twice.

    ballpeenB ballpeen wrote on last edited by
    #27

    @hoorta said:

    It looks like it won't matter much as it's odds on he's going to get fired again. The McCoy & Weeden picks are all on Mike. BW is going to have to improve 1,000% to make it look like Holmie didn't screw up twice.

    I agree with that....and I was in favor of Weeden over Colt.

    I still am and will be, but that doesn't mean I won't be in favor of replacing both of them if we continue to look like a bad HS team out there.

  • @hoorta said:

    It looks like it won't matter much as it's odds on he's going to get fired again. The McCoy & Weeden picks are all on Mike. BW is going to have to improve 1,000% to make it look like Holmie didn't screw up twice.

    I agree with that....and I was in favor of Weeden over Colt.

    I still am and will be, but that doesn't mean I won't be in favor of replacing both of them if we continue to look like a bad HS team out there.

    BrownIndianB BrownIndian wrote on last edited by
    #28

    @ballpeen said:

    I agree with that....and I was in favor of Weeden over Colt.

    I still am and will be, but that doesn't mean I won't be in favor of replacing both of them if we continue to look like a bad HS team out there.

    Before replacing the QB's I would first replace the HC and OC and see if we get better.

  • The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #29

    Formerly Sane said:

    It was such a short time ago that most of you here thought I was just a troll when I said that Holmgren had very limited qualifications to be the head honcho.....and he got fired from that gig too!

    If Holmgren is removed it probably won't be because JH didn't think he was qualified, but because he wants to bring in his guy.

  • BadNewsBrownsB BadNewsBrowns wrote on last edited by
    #30

    Well Holmgren is 9-24 so far in his tenure.

    With an Offense and Run Defense that will probably be ranked towards the bottom of the league again.

    How many years can we say "Well let's see if this draft pick pans out" ?

    I think firing Holmgren based on performance alone is justified, remember he was made to step down as GM in Seattle.

  • massbrownsfanM massbrownsfan wrote on last edited by
    #31

    Let the house cleaning begin!!!!

  • PoeticGP PoeticG wrote on last edited by
    #32

  • BodogjoeB Bodogjoe wrote on last edited by Bodogjoe
    #33

    I am just glad the Lerner era is over. I respect the guy, but he was not the best owner.

  • I am just glad the Lerner era is over. I respect the guy, but he was not the best owner.

    VaporTrailV VaporTrail wrote on last edited by
    #34

    @bodogjoe said:

    I am just glad the Lerner era is over. I respect the guy

    Why.

  • jrb12711J jrb12711 wrote on last edited by
    #35

    I'm not afraid to admit that I was riding first class on the Holmgren bandwagon. But over these past two years and change one thing is evident to me. It's not that Holmgren doesn't care or that he doesn't have the fire IMO. For me, I just think the game of football has completely passed him by. He's so sold on his conventional ways and it's clear he either refuses or doesn't understand how to win in today's game. I don't care what anyone says or the implications of hiring Childress, Holmgren has been in the ear of Shurmer about how to run the offense. And as we all know, the way we play offense right now Tom Brady couldn't succeed. I'm glad if this ends up being true because I have a strong gut feeling Haslam knows this and will aggressively bring in a new staff.

  • BadNewsBrownsB BadNewsBrowns wrote on last edited by
    #36

    None of us really know if Holmgren has any influence on the offense besides him picking the guy to draft and coach.

    He's said more than once in interviews that he let's Shurmur do his own thing.

    Shurmur did not call a horrible game last Sunday.

    If not for Weeden missing MoMass in the endzone on the first series and Little dropping the ball that got picked the Browns would of had at least 10 if not 14 more points on the board.

    I just think Shurmur's game managing has been horrible and he comes off like a total dolt, not much faith in the guy.

    And the fact remains the Browns are no better off since Holmgren took over, you could even argue we'd be a better team if Mangini were still here.

    So to me so far Holmgren has failed.

  • Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by
    #37

    @poeticg said:

    Banner certainly looks like a bean-counter...

    I wonder if this means "we'll" being going after Reid as his Eagles' contract expires at the end of the year???

  • Formerly Sane said:

    It was such a short time ago that most of you here thought I was just a troll when I said that Holmgren had very limited qualifications to be the head honcho.....and he got fired from that gig too!

    If Holmgren is removed it probably won't be because JH didn't think he was qualified, but because he wants to bring in his guy.

    ballpeenB ballpeen wrote on last edited by ballpeen
    #38

    @the-gipper said:

    If Holmgren is removed it probably won't be because JH didn't think he was qualified, but because he wants to bring in his guy.

    Exactly. One also has to figure that Homie as pretty much had unbridled rein the past several years. Something tells me JH isn't going to be the type of owner who turns everything over to someone else. He will be in the locker room. He will sit in on meetings as a participant. He will have a word on draft day.

    You start new, you bring in your own people. By seasons end I'd say a change at head coach and GM are also better than 50/50......way better.

  • None of us really know if Holmgren has any influence on the offense besides him picking the guy to draft and coach.

    He's said more than once in interviews that he let's Shurmur do his own thing.

    Shurmur did not call a horrible game last Sunday.

    If not for Weeden missing MoMass in the endzone on the first series and Little dropping the ball that got picked the Browns would of had at least 10 if not 14 more points on the board.

    I just think Shurmur's game managing has been horrible and he comes off like a total dolt, not much faith in the guy.

    And the fact remains the Browns are no better off since Holmgren took over, you could even argue we'd be a better team if Mangini were still here.

    So to me so far Holmgren has failed.

    jrb12711J jrb12711 wrote on last edited by
    #39

    @badnewsbrowns said:

    None of us really know if Holmgren has any influence on the offense besides him picking the guy to draft and coach.

    He's said more than once in interviews that he let's Shurmur do his own thing.

    Shurmur did not call a horrible game last Sunday.

    You can believe that, but I don't buy it for a second. I'm not talking about actual in game play calling, but behind the scenes. I get this strong feeling Shurmer's offensive gameplan overall is influenced highly by the big guy.

  • VaporTrailV VaporTrail wrote on last edited by
    #40

    Has this been confirmed by anyone else?

  • @badnewsbrowns said:

    None of us really know if Holmgren has any influence on the offense besides him picking the guy to draft and coach.

    He's said more than once in interviews that he let's Shurmur do his own thing.

    Shurmur did not call a horrible game last Sunday.

    You can believe that, but I don't buy it for a second. I'm not talking about actual in game play calling, but behind the scenes. I get this strong feeling Shurmer's offensive gameplan overall is influenced highly by the big guy.

    BadNewsBrownsB BadNewsBrowns wrote on last edited by BadNewsBrowns
    #41

    @jrb12711 said:

    You can believe that, but I don't buy it for a second. I'm not talking about actual in game play calling, but behind the scenes. I get this strong feeling Shurmer's offensive gameplan overall is influenced highly by the big guy.

    Well of course it is, that's why Holmgren picked him.

    Shurmur will run the style of offense that Holmgren wanted I don't disagree.

    You think Holmgren is attending coaches meetings or something?

    Who really knows how much if any he has week to week, as of right now I really don't think Holmgren gives a hoot since he knows he's one foot out of the door anyhow.

  • @jrb12711 said:

    You can believe that, but I don't buy it for a second. I'm not talking about actual in game play calling, but behind the scenes. I get this strong feeling Shurmer's offensive gameplan overall is influenced highly by the big guy.

    Well of course it is, that's why Holmgren picked him.

    Shurmur will run the style of offense that Holmgren wanted I don't disagree.

    You think Holmgren is attending coaches meetings or something?

    Who really knows how much if any he has week to week, as of right now I really don't think Holmgren gives a hoot since he knows he's one foot out of the door anyhow.

    djdawg2010D djdawg2010 wrote on last edited by
    #42

    @badnewsbrowns said:

    Well of course it is, that's why Holmgren picked him.

    Shurmur will run the style of offense that Holmgren wanted I don't disagree.

    You think Holmgren is attending coaches meetings or something?

    Who really knows how much if any he has week to week, as of right now I really don't think Holmgren gives a hoot since he knows he's one foot out of the door anyhow.

    Probably not. He got his pay day!

    PS Bad News Browns... I love your signature line! That is so true!

  • The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #43

    Formerly Sane said:

    True...what proves that Holmgren is not qualified is his track record.

    OK. No, I would not expect him to be high on anyone's list to come in to run their franchise.