Skip to content

Need based picks, or BPA? Which do you prefer?

The Browns Board
29 13 941
  • BPA for me, having a stacked position is no bad thing, it means you can potentially let some guys go that might otherwise cost you a fortune. If you have someone to come in at C for instance you can let Mack get paid elsewhere* and use that money on 1-2 free agents at other positions that don't have that depth.

    *before people want to stab me this is just an example, I am aware how good Mack is

    B BitchTits wrote on last edited by
    #3

    @londonbrown said:

    BPA for me, having a stacked position is no bad thing, it means you can potentially let some guys go that might otherwise cost you a fortune. If you have someone to come in at C for instance you can let Mack get paid elsewhere* and use that money on 1-2 free agents at other positions that don't have that depth.

    *before people want to stab me this is just an example, I am aware how good Mack is

    Makes sense, and is a good argument. No right answers here, just curious what people think. Always good to see and maybe learn 😁

  • gftChrisG gftChris wrote on last edited by
    #4

    If it's possible, I move around to where BPA coincides with need.

  • ballpeenB ballpeen wrote on last edited by
    #5

    To me it depends on the round.

    In the 1st round, BPA is the way to go IMO. The 2nd and 3rd rounds can be more geared towards needs. From the 4th-6th rounds, BPA. The goal in these rounds is to pluck some good down the road players. Not simply some guy to play left guard for a season or two. The 7th round, I look for the fastest player I can find.

    One exception is when you are looking for a kicker or long snapper. Then you might us a 5th on down pick to fill that need.

  • MudflyM Mudfly wrote on last edited by
    #6

    Dont think you can rely on either BPA or NEED alone....its gotta be a combination of both....plus consideration has to be given to what positions are deep and what positions gotta be tapped early....

  • miktoxicM miktoxic wrote on last edited by
    #7

    i lean on NEED more than anything else.

    what is the biggest need for the browns to become better this year? stop the run (NT) rush the passer (LB) pass/run block better (OL backup C) make dynamic plays on offense (WR and QB).

    to get the best available when we pick at those positions will prob take the 10 picks the browns have.

  • C cuwoohio wrote on last edited by
    #8

    BPA is much safer, but there are times you have to plug a hole, so the you take BPA at the position of need. The real trick is grading the players.

  • Flyin JF Flyin J wrote on last edited by
    #9

    We shouldnt even be scouting players at locked up positions. Unless its a player who is obviously on another level we have enough needs to not have to worry about it.

  • miktoxicM miktoxic wrote on last edited by
    #10

    browns past draft history going BPA is atrocious.

    courtney brown anyone?

  • browns past draft history going BPA is atrocious.

    courtney brown anyone?

    B BitchTits wrote on last edited by
    #11

    @miktoxic said:

    browns past draft history going BPA is atrocious.

    courtney brown anyone?

    True, but he could have been considered a need as well. I personally though he was good WHEN he played. Just couldn't stay in the season more then 5 or so games a year.

  • B BitchTits wrote on last edited by
    #12

    I guess my question for this thread would be better with an example.

    If Mariotta/Winston (I know unlikely, it's just an example) fell to 12, would you take our "need" at QB whether you think they would be good or not, or go with the best available player?

    I would use a different set of QB's, but QB is a huge need for us. Names actually are irrelevant, would you reach(still first round pick) for a QB because of need? Or would you take a player(like a left tackle, that will play left tackle no moving) because he is the best player?

  • I guess my question for this thread would be better with an example.

    If Mariotta/Winston (I know unlikely, it's just an example) fell to 12, would you take our "need" at QB whether you think they would be good or not, or go with the best available player?

    I would use a different set of QB's, but QB is a huge need for us. Names actually are irrelevant, would you reach(still first round pick) for a QB because of need? Or would you take a player(like a left tackle, that will play left tackle no moving) because he is the best player?

    Flyin JF Flyin J wrote on last edited by
    #13

    cbbacker said:

    I guess my question for this thread would be better with an example.

    If Mariotta/Winston (I know unlikely, it's just an example) fell to 12, would you take our "need" at QB whether you think they would be good or not, or go with the best available player?

    I would use a different set of QB's, but QB is a huge need for us. Names actually are irrelevant, would you reach(still first round pick) for a QB because of need? Or would you take a player(like a left tackle, that will play left tackle no moving) because he is the best player?

    A better example would be the new B/R mock that has us taking Grayson at 19 smh....
  • cbbacker said:

    I guess my question for this thread would be better with an example.

    If Mariotta/Winston (I know unlikely, it's just an example) fell to 12, would you take our "need" at QB whether you think they would be good or not, or go with the best available player?

    I would use a different set of QB's, but QB is a huge need for us. Names actually are irrelevant, would you reach(still first round pick) for a QB because of need? Or would you take a player(like a left tackle, that will play left tackle no moving) because he is the best player?

    A better example would be the new B/R mock that has us taking Grayson at 19 smh....
    miktoxicM miktoxic wrote on last edited by
    #14

    XxDaBuckeyexX said:

    A better example would be the new B/R mock that has us taking Grayson at 19 smh....

    that's dumb because grayson might be there in the 3rd round.

  • Dont think you can rely on either BPA or NEED alone....its gotta be a combination of both....plus consideration has to be given to what positions are deep and what positions gotta be tapped early....

    Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by
    #15

    Not if we take him in the first... 😉 Shades of Wheezy reach!

    @mudfly said:

    Dont think you can rely on either BPA or NEED alone....its gotta be a combination of both....plus consideration has to be given to what positions are deep and what positions gotta be tapped early....

    Yup... call it a hybrid...

    Cluster players into groups based upon grades.

    When your pick rolls around take the player left in the top cluster of greatest need with consideration of options in subsequent rounds.

  • The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #16

    I don't give a damn which way they think about it.....as long as they make a proper, quality choice for a change.

  • Opal312O Opal312 wrote on last edited by
    #17

    But the Browns need to stop the run. Who is the best player in this draft? ESPN's Bill Polian says Danny Shelton is a two down player. So is Malcom Brown or Eddie Goldman a better fit?

  • But the Browns need to stop the run. Who is the best player in this draft? ESPN's Bill Polian says Danny Shelton is a two down player. So is Malcom Brown or Eddie Goldman a better fit?

    miktoxicM miktoxic wrote on last edited by
    #18

    @opal312 said:

    But the Browns need to stop the run. Who is the best player in this draft? ESPN's Bill Polian says Danny Shelton is a two down player. So is Malcom Brown or Eddie Goldman a better fit?

    if taylor can stay healthy a rotation between him and shelton is fine with me.

  • BPA for me, having a stacked position is no bad thing, it means you can potentially let some guys go that might otherwise cost you a fortune. If you have someone to come in at C for instance you can let Mack get paid elsewhere* and use that money on 1-2 free agents at other positions that don't have that depth.

    *before people want to stab me this is just an example, I am aware how good Mack is

    gumby73G gumby73 wrote on last edited by gumby73
    #19

    @londonbrown said:

    BPA for me, having a stacked position is no bad thing, it means you can potentially let some guys go that might otherwise cost you a fortune. If you have someone to come in at C for instance you can let Mack get paid elsewhere* and use that money on 1-2 free agents at other positions that don't have that depth.

    *before people want to stab me this is just an example, I am aware how good Mack is

    If you see Cam Irving selected at 19 there's your answer. They say he's a better C than G or T. With our Line I would take him anyhow for anywhere IMO.. Resign Mack my best Option..

  • miktoxicM miktoxic wrote on last edited by miktoxic
    #20

    i saw something on a sports channel somewhere that marpet would be best moved to C and if he is, is rated the #2 by mayock (don't know if a lot of people take mayock as being very knowledgeable, but i do). if he goes in the 2nd it will be a surprise to me even though people love his combine and senior bowl stuff.

    i'll pull for him anyways seeing as he grew up a mile from where i live now.

  • W Westside Steve wrote on last edited by
    #21

    I guess it depends on the gap between BPA and need. if you need an ex backer and one is rated at 9. 5 but the next available player, the BPA, is rated at 9. 6...

    WSS

  • i saw something on a sports channel somewhere that marpet would be best moved to C and if he is, is rated the #2 by mayock (don't know if a lot of people take mayock as being very knowledgeable, but i do). if he goes in the 2nd it will be a surprise to me even though people love his combine and senior bowl stuff.

    i'll pull for him anyways seeing as he grew up a mile from where i live now.

    gumby73G gumby73 wrote on last edited by
    #22

    @miktoxic said:

    i saw something on a sports channel somewhere that marpet would be best moved to C and if he is, is rated the #2 by mayock (don't know if a lot of people take mayock as being very knowledgeable, but i do). if he goes in the 2nd it will be a surprise to me even though people love his combine and senior bowl stuff.

    i'll pull for him anyways seeing as he grew up a mile from where i live now.

    In your same Boat. Living in N.C. Watching RB Todd Gurley in High School and WR Justin Hardy got to be a fan. But God not a Cowboy and not in our Division Please...