Skip to content

Pirates trade McCutchen to SF

The Tribe Board
11 4 748
  • OFFICIAL: The Pirates today acquired pitcher Kyle Crick, minor league OF Bryan Reynolds and $500,000 in international bonus pool space from the San Francisco Giants in exchange for Andrew McCutchen and cash considerations.

    6:23 PM - Jan 15, 2018
    Pittsburgh Pirates@Pirates
    OFFICIAL: The Pirates today acquired pitcher Kyle Crick, minor league OF Bryan Reynolds and $500,000 in international bonus pool space from the San Francisco Giants in exchange for Andrew McCutchen and cash considerations.

    McCutchen is, of course, not the first former MVP to make the move from Pittsburgh to San Francisco. Barry Bonds left the Pirates to join the Giants as a free agent way back in 1993. 

    Earlier this offseason the Giants were in on Giancarlo Stanton -- they agreed to a trade with the Miami Marlins only to have Stanton veto it with his no-trade clause -- so it was no secret they wanted to upgrade their outfield. In fact, prior to the McCutchen deal, FanGraphs projected San Francisco to have the worst outfield in baseball.........

  • McCutchen was one of several Pirates players who figured to be on the move in the wake of the Cole trade. He had been on the trade block since last offseason, and the Giants had been interested in him for weeks.

    In addition to McCutchen, the Giants have also added Evan Longoriathis offseason, so they've acquired two players who were the faces of their old franchise. McCutchen in the outfield and Longoria at third improves two major weaknesses. Giants skipper Bruce Bochy could trot out a lineup that looks something like this now:

    1. 2B Joe Panik
    2. CF Andrew McCutchen
    3. C Buster Posey
    4. 3B Evan Longoria
    5. 1B Brandon Belt
    6. RF Hunter Pence
    7. SS Brandon Crawford
    8. LF TBD
    9. Pitcher

    If the Giants do not acquire another outfielder, McCutchen will join some combination of Pence, Gorkys Hernandez, Mac Williamson, Jarrett Parker, and Steven Duggar in the outfield.

  • pit fans must be pissed

  • sydS syd

    pit fans must be pissed

    @syd said:

    pit fans must be pissed

    They have a petition going now about 46,000 (+/-) signatures to have the owner sell the team, I believe that it started before the McCutchen trade, still they're dumping salary......I heard that they picked up a big dollar pitcher today.

  • Who gives a shite about the Pirates and their fans.

  • @syd said:

    pit fans must be pissed

    They have a petition going now about 46,000 (+/-) signatures to have the owner sell the team, I believe that it started before the McCutchen trade, still they're dumping salary......I heard that they picked up a big dollar pitcher today.

    @mjp28 said:

    They have a petition going now about 46,000 (+/-) signatures to have the owner sell the team, I believe that it started before the McCutchen trade, still they're dumping salary......I heard that they picked up a big dollar pitcher today.

    last time i went to a pirates game bonds was on the team,maybe Cuban will buy em and move em to cuba

  • sydS syd

    @mjp28 said:

    They have a petition going now about 46,000 (+/-) signatures to have the owner sell the team, I believe that it started before the McCutchen trade, still they're dumping salary......I heard that they picked up a big dollar pitcher today.

    last time i went to a pirates game bonds was on the team,maybe Cuban will buy em and move em to cuba

    @syd said:

    last time i went to a pirates game bonds was on the team,maybe Cuban will buy em and move em to cuba

    Just to review the Pirate's postseason successes, the fans were pretty pumped in 2013:

    Year Round Opponent Result
    1903 World Series Boston Americans Lost, 3-5
    1909 World Series Detroit Tigers Won, 4-3
    1925 World Series Washington Senators Won, 4-3
    1927 World Series New York Yankees Lost, 0-4
    1960 World Series New York Yankees Won, 4-3
    1970 NL Championship Series Cincinnati Reds Lost, 0-3
    1971 NL Championship Series San Francisco Giants Won, 3-1
      World Series Baltimore Orioles Won, 4-3
    1972 NL Championship Series Cincinnati Reds Lost, 2-3
    1974 NL Championship Series Los Angeles Dodgers Lost, 1-3
    1975 NL Championship Series Cincinnati Reds Lost, 0-3
    1979 NL Championship Series Cincinnati Reds Won, 3-0
      World Series Baltimore Orioles Won, 4-3
    1990 NL Championship Series Cincinnati Reds Lost, 2-4
    1991 NL Championship Series Atlanta Braves Lost, 3-4
    1992 NL Championship Series Atlanta Braves Lost, 3-4
    2013 NL Wild Card Cincinnati Reds Won Game, 6-2
      NL Division Series St. Louis Cardinals Lost, 2-3
    2014 NL Wild Card San Francisco Giants Lost Game, 8-0
    2015 NL Wild Card Chicago Cubs Lost Game, 4-0
  • 2013 wasn't that pos dusty baker the skipper for the reds ?

  • sydS syd

    pit fans must be pissed

    @syd said:

    pit fans must be pissed

    It's funny to listen to Pirate fans - they have the same complaints as Indians fans... The owner is cheap, all they are is a farm system to the Yankees, Red Sox, etc...

    Then again, you couldn't find a Pirates fan five or so years ago.

  • @syd said:

    pit fans must be pissed

    It's funny to listen to Pirate fans - they have the same complaints as Indians fans... The owner is cheap, all they are is a farm system to the Yankees, Red Sox, etc...

    Then again, you couldn't find a Pirates fan five or so years ago.

    @dutch-oven said:

    It's funny to listen to Pirate fans - they have the same complaints as Indians fans... The owner is cheap, all they are is a farm system to the Yankees, Red Sox, etc...

    Then again, you couldn't find a Pirates fan five or so years ago.

    Outside of the 1960's 7th inning WS win and their run in the 1970s with the 1979 WS win their postseason record has been well dismal......but they did win two, "generationally speaking".

    I had a friend who was  Bucco fan growing up in the 1960s and saw some games in the 1970s in particular in 1976 when I spent 3 weeks with my former employer USSTEEL one summer in 1976 saw 9 pirate's games and 1 World Team Tennis match, Cleveland vs Pittsburgh naturally Cleveland won in the old Civic Arena next door to the Chatham Center where we stayed which was about 2 blocks from the USS 64 story main office where we went for additional management training....all expenses paid, what a summer.

    Yes Cleveland and Pittsburgh are similar in many ways  I liked downtown Pittsburgh much better, but the Indians history is deeper "generationally speaking".