Skip to content

Kitchens fate?

The Browns Board
167 48 5.0k 1
  • So if we were to finish with a 5-1 division record....... does he stay or does he go?

     I say stay. 

  • @tour2ma said:

    Since we run a fair amount of 2 TE sets, who do you want to sit in place of Higgins? OBJ or Landry?

    To me tour it's more that when we do run 3 receiver sets its khadarel hodge that gets 85% of the opportunities and not Higgins. 

    @bjh2130 said:

    To me tour it's more that when we do run 3 receiver sets its khadarel hodge that gets 85% of the opportunities and not Higgins. 

    It is because of Dorsey.  Freddie know Dorsey likes "his" players.  Freddie has no pushback, which is what Dorsey wanted in his head coach...why do you think he hired Kitchens and not Williams?  So we fire Freddie, who's next, Casper Milquetoast, the man who speaks softly and gets hit with a big stick?

  • @the-gipper said:

    Well....that could put a lot of us in a real dilemma.   No matter what, even if it seems to be contrary to the team's long term interests,  I want the team to win.   But, if you say that this game would decide if Freddie stays or goes.....it gives me a quandary.    I do not think that Ferd will really ever be  quality HC in this league.....unless he learns  a lot in the next 5 years.  So I do think that in the team's long term interests it is best that he not be the HC here.  

    But, I can never deep down bring myself to root against them.

    I can't either, but to borrow a line from Jimmy Carter's campaign-- In your heart, you know we're gonna lose.   

    @the-gipper said:

    I think it is just more evidence of Ferd's misuse of his personnel. 

    That IMHO Gipper will be the nail in Freddie's coffin. 

    @richiswhere said:

    Was watching First Take the other day and it was said that the Haslam's  want to get rid of Kitchens but Dorsey wants to give him another year.

    As Dorsey probably would. Problem is- should the Browns get blown out by the Ravens, and then lay an egg against the Bengals the following week- John Boy is going to have a big PR problem hanging on to a coach that 1\2 the National media have been saying all year was a big mistake over his head first time HC.  

    @hoorta said:

    As Dorsey probably would. Problem is- should the Browns get blown out by the Ravens, and then lay an egg against the Bengals the following week- John Boy is going to have a big PR problem hanging on to a coach that 1\2 the National media have been saying all year was a big mistake over his head first time HC.  

    Bingo. A few weeks ago it appeared that the Browns would end up 8-8, which is (slightly) better than the 7-8-1 of last season, and there would be those divisional wins vs Pittsburgh, Baltimore and Cincinnati. 

    If the Browns finish 6-10? Along with all the shenanigans that occurred during this season? Man, that's a tough sell for Dorsey. Literally the only argument for Kitchens at that point would be "you really don't want to fire a head coach AGAIN after one season."

  • This year we watched the Kitchens sink.....

  • This year we watched the Kitchens sink.....

    @mohican said:

    This year we watched the Kitchens sink.....

    We also watched the Kitchens stink...

  • @hoorta said:

    As Dorsey probably would. Problem is- should the Browns get blown out by the Ravens, and then lay an egg against the Bengals the following week- John Boy is going to have a big PR problem hanging on to a coach that 1\2 the National media have been saying all year was a big mistake over his head first time HC.  

    Bingo. A few weeks ago it appeared that the Browns would end up 8-8, which is (slightly) better than the 7-8-1 of last season, and there would be those divisional wins vs Pittsburgh, Baltimore and Cincinnati. 

    If the Browns finish 6-10? Along with all the shenanigans that occurred during this season? Man, that's a tough sell for Dorsey. Literally the only argument for Kitchens at that point would be "you really don't want to fire a head coach AGAIN after one season."

    @dutch-oven said:

     Literally the only argument for Kitchens at that point would be "you really don't want to fire a head coach AGAIN after one season."

    "Tradition!"-Fiddler on the Roof?

  • Kitchens' fate seems to be diabetes. Probably a heart attack incoming at some point, too. 

  • Kitchens' fate seems to be diabetes. Probably a heart attack incoming at some point, too. 

    @the-cysko-kid said:

    Kitchens' fate seems to be diabetes. Probably a heart attack incoming at some point, too. 

    Unfortunately, he's already had a massive heart attack.  He actually should've died, but he somehow survived.  He's literally a walking miracle.  He should be doing ANYTHING but coaching right now to extend his life, but I guess it's his call.

  • @the-cysko-kid said:

    Kitchens' fate seems to be diabetes. Probably a heart attack incoming at some point, too. 

    Unfortunately, he's already had a massive heart attack.  He actually should've died, but he somehow survived.  He's literally a walking miracle.  He should be doing ANYTHING but coaching right now to extend his life, but I guess it's his call.

    @jiggins7919 said:

    Unfortunately, he's already had a massive heart attack.  He actually should've died, but he somehow survived.  He's literally a walking miracle.  He should be doing ANYTHING but coaching right now to extend his life, but I guess it's his call.

    Is this true?  I am not sure I have heard about that. 

  • @jiggins7919 said:

    Unfortunately, he's already had a massive heart attack.  He actually should've died, but he somehow survived.  He's literally a walking miracle.  He should be doing ANYTHING but coaching right now to extend his life, but I guess it's his call.

    Is this true?  I am not sure I have heard about that. 

    @the-gipper said:

    Is this true?  I am not sure I have heard about that. 

    Oh, very true.  There's a good Youtube video about it.  The man should've died while working with the Cards.  He basically blew out a heart valve before practice and had to go through like 10 hours of surgery or something crazy like that.  He got a new valve from a pig and apparently he's doing better.  But he's a miracle walking.

    I think this link is the one I'm thinking of, but not totally sure.

  • Well then, we should relieve him of the stress of an NFL HC job.

  • I'm lukewarm on Freddie at this point.  Unlike others I don't have a ton of problems with his play calling.  Team discipline on the other hand seems to be lacking.  Again, it seems that a lot fans in here continue to hold coaches more responsible than GMs and forgive players almost entirely.  The issues I see.

    Baker Mayfield - he hasn't been good.  Not sure about blaming the play calling when he misses guys that are open, doesn't trust throwing guys open, holds the ball to long on certain routes and has consistently missed high.

    Offensive Line - Screw John Dorsey.  For a GM to believe this cast of characters would be good enough to compete for a playoff spot is an indictment on that GM.

    OBJ Trade - Screw Dorsey again.  Weakened the OL for a guy who appears to be overrated.  OBJs hands have been average at best, doesn't seem to separate as well as one would hope and is still a distraction (watch, visor, does he want to be here)

    Secondary - Screw Dorsey once again.  Ward has been good but not to the level of the #4 pick, Williams is awful, Randall is very inconsistent and what's with all the hamstring issues?  Losing Peppers hurt us in the run game so another thanks Dorsey

    Attitude - Team is not focused and lacks leadership.  Baker, Landry, Garrett, Ward, OBJ, etc. are not leaders.  Chubb who is clearly 110% of what Cleveland is about and needs, is a quiet guy and doesn't seem like the guiding force.  Freddie doesn't seem capable in this area either.  

    @baconhound said:

    I'm lukewarm on Freddie at this point.  Unlike others I don't have a ton of problems with his play calling.  Team discipline on the other hand seems to be lacking.  Again, it seems that a lot fans in here continue to hold coaches more responsible than GMs and forgive players almost entirely.  The issues I see.

    Baker Mayfield - he hasn't been good.  Not sure about blaming the play calling when he misses guys that are open, doesn't trust throwing guys open, holds the ball to long on certain routes and has consistently missed high.

    Offensive Line - Screw John Dorsey.  For a GM to believe this cast of characters would be good enough to compete for a playoff spot is an indictment on that GM.

    OBJ Trade - Screw Dorsey again.  Weakened the OL for a guy who appears to be overrated.  OBJs hands have been average at best, doesn't seem to separate as well as one would hope and is still a distraction (watch, visor, does he want to be here)

    Secondary - Screw Dorsey once again.  Ward has been good but not to the level of the #4 pick, Williams is awful, Randall is very inconsistent and what's with all the hamstring issues?  Losing Peppers hurt us in the run game so another thanks Dorsey

    Attitude - Team is not focused and lacks leadership.  Baker, Landry, Garrett, Ward, OBJ, etc. are not leaders.  Chubb who is clearly 110% of what Cleveland is about and needs, is a quiet guy and doesn't seem like the guiding force.  Freddie doesn't seem capable in this area either.  

    @baconhound said:

    I'm lukewarm on Freddie at this point.  Unlike others I don't have a ton of problems with his play calling.  Team discipline on the other hand seems to be lacking.  Again, it seems that a lot fans in here continue to hold coaches more responsible than GMs and forgive players almost entirely.  The issues I see.

    Baker Mayfield - he hasn't been good.  Not sure about blaming the play calling when he misses guys that are open, doesn't trust throwing guys open, holds the ball to long on certain routes and has consistently missed high.

    Offensive Line - Screw John Dorsey.  For a GM to believe this cast of characters would be good enough to compete for a playoff spot is an indictment on that GM.

    OBJ Trade - Screw Dorsey again.  Weakened the OL for a guy who appears to be overrated.  OBJs hands have been average at best, doesn't seem to separate as well as one would hope and is still a distraction (watch, visor, does he want to be here)

    Secondary - Screw Dorsey once again.  Ward has been good but not to the level of the #4 pick, Williams is awful, Randall is very inconsistent and what's with all the hamstring issues?  Losing Peppers hurt us in the run game so another thanks Dorsey

    Attitude - Team is not focused and lacks leadership.  Baker, Landry, Garrett, Ward, OBJ, etc. are not leaders.  Chubb who is clearly 110% of what Cleveland is about and needs, is a quiet guy and doesn't seem like the guiding force.  Freddie doesn't seem capable in this area either.  

    i like all your point, but i do believe freddy is not an nfl coach....and all his playcalling is not that good. or his clock mgmt....he lost the game vs. the ravens yesterday with his clock mgmt in the first half...he totally lost that game...and there were others during the season also...he's no good...yeah, as you say, baker was not good either...i wanted to see wentz quarterbacking this team....the guy is a leader....we have zilcho leadership and dorsey, if you look at it...sucks...

  • I'd be absolutely shocked if Mike McCarthy isn't the coach next year.  I give it 85% McCarthy, and 15% Josh McDaniels.  

  • I'd be absolutely shocked if Mike McCarthy isn't the coach next year.  I give it 85% McCarthy, and 15% Josh McDaniels.  

    @jiggins7919 said:

    I'd be absolutely shocked if Mike McCarthy isn't the coach next year.  I give it 85% McCarthy, and 15% Josh McDaniels.  

    McDaniels is a great mind, but I wouldn't trust him. Didn't he back out on a team recently, after a verbal "yes?"

    Yep....he backed out on Indianhapless in January 2018. 

  • I'd be absolutely shocked if Mike McCarthy isn't the coach next year.  I give it 85% McCarthy, and 15% Josh McDaniels.  

    @jiggins7919 said:

    I'd be absolutely shocked if Mike McCarthy isn't the coach next year.  I give it 85% McCarthy, and 15% Josh McDaniels.  

    Prepare to  be shocked  then. Dorsey & Wolf know  exactly  what they'd be getting in Mike, and I  doubt  they'll be interested.  

    If you saw the McCarthy  interview,  he essentially has his entire  coaching  staff  in place already,  they've  been hanging out  at Mike's house  for months.  So if you want  Mike the whole  package  comes along for the  ride. Think  Dorsey  will  buy  into  something  like that?  I sure as hell don't. 

    Too  early to  speculate,  but I'd  put  better  odds on Greg Williams  coming  back as HC than I  would  on McCarthy  getting  the job. 

    We'll  let our Vegas odds shark mjp give us the line on the probability of  Freddie  getting  fired first. Should  he manage to  lose to the Bengals  Sunday,  I'd say they're  prohibitive.  🙂

  • @the-cysko-kid said:

    Kitchens' fate seems to be diabetes. Probably a heart attack incoming at some point, too. 

    Unfortunately, he's already had a massive heart attack.  He actually should've died, but he somehow survived.  He's literally a walking miracle.  He should be doing ANYTHING but coaching right now to extend his life, but I guess it's his call.

    @jiggins7919 said:

    Unfortunately, he's already had a massive heart attack.  He actually should've died, but he somehow survived.  He's literally a walking miracle.  He should be doing ANYTHING but coaching right now to extend his life, but I guess it's his call.

    He didn't have a heart attck...I believe he tore his aorta, which is worse than a heart attack.

  • @jiggins7919 said:

    Unfortunately, he's already had a massive heart attack.  He actually should've died, but he somehow survived.  He's literally a walking miracle.  He should be doing ANYTHING but coaching right now to extend his life, but I guess it's his call.

    He didn't have a heart attck...I believe he tore his aorta, which is worse than a heart attack.

    @ballpeen said:

    He didn't have a heart attack...I believe he tore his aorta, which is worse than a heart attack.

    You're correct 'Peen. Rupture an aorta badly enough, and you bleed to death before they can ever get you to a hospital. Depending on where the leak is, the surgery can be really tricky. 

  • @jiggins7919 said:

    Unfortunately, he's already had a massive heart attack.  He actually should've died, but he somehow survived.  He's literally a walking miracle.  He should be doing ANYTHING but coaching right now to extend his life, but I guess it's his call.

    He didn't have a heart attck...I believe he tore his aorta, which is worse than a heart attack.

    @ballpeen said:

    He didn't have a heart attck...I believe he tore his aorta, which is worse than a heart attack.

    That's what I meant when I said massive, but I didn't think everyone would really want the details. ?

  • @jiggins7919 said:

    I'd be absolutely shocked if Mike McCarthy isn't the coach next year.  I give it 85% McCarthy, and 15% Josh McDaniels.  

    Prepare to  be shocked  then. Dorsey & Wolf know  exactly  what they'd be getting in Mike, and I  doubt  they'll be interested.  

    If you saw the McCarthy  interview,  he essentially has his entire  coaching  staff  in place already,  they've  been hanging out  at Mike's house  for months.  So if you want  Mike the whole  package  comes along for the  ride. Think  Dorsey  will  buy  into  something  like that?  I sure as hell don't. 

    Too  early to  speculate,  but I'd  put  better  odds on Greg Williams  coming  back as HC than I  would  on McCarthy  getting  the job. 

    We'll  let our Vegas odds shark mjp give us the line on the probability of  Freddie  getting  fired first. Should  he manage to  lose to the Bengals  Sunday,  I'd say they're  prohibitive.  🙂

    @hoorta said:

    Prepare to  be shocked  then. Dorsey & Wolf know  exactly  what they'd be getting in Mike, and I  doubt  they'll be interested.  

    If you saw the McCarthy  interview,  he essentially has his entire  coaching  staff  in place already,  they've  been hanging out  at Mike's house  for months.  So if you want  Mike the whole  package  comes along for the  ride. Think  Dorsey  will  buy  into  something  like that?  I sure as hell don't. 

    Too  early to  speculate,  but I'd  put  better  odds on Greg Williams  coming  back as HC than I  would  on McCarthy  getting  the job. 

    We'll  let our Vegas odds shark mjp give us the line on the probability of  Freddie  getting  fired first. Should  he manage to  lose to the Bengals  Sunday,  I'd say they're  prohibitive.  🙂

    I don't know my friend.  Dorsey lost a power struggle in KC.  I get the feeling Dorsey is only interested in hiring a coach he has under his thumb.  I don't think he wants a coach who knows what he wants.  Dorsey wants a coach who takes what he is given.