Skip to content
The Browns Board
Theme
  • System
  • Light
  • Dark
  • Login
  • Register
  • Forums
  • Recent
  • Popular
  • Users
  • Donate
  1. Home
  2. The Browns Board
  3. Draft And Free Agency

Draft And Free Agency

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved The Browns Board
58 Posts 25 Posters 3.0k Views
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • jnuh J
    • 402 Posts
    • 27 Reputation
    J jnuh wrote on last edited by
    #13

    I would love RGIII to be on the board ... just so we can trade that pick to Washington or Miami. The drop off from RGIII to the third best QB this year is a pretty significant dropoff so we should ATLEAST pick up an additional second rounder. I wouldn't be shocked to see a team like Washington give us a first next yr though along with a pick or 2 additionally from this years draft. Picking up a first this yr and next is oobviously a long shot, but you never know (Washington has made some bonehead moves.)

    So I will start with free agency for my off season plan.

    First off I would resign Dqwell, and Mike Adams (as a reserve obviosly) if we lose Adams though no big loss.

    I would also love to have Hillis back at the right price. I wouldn't want him as a "feature back" but I would like him as our main RB in a 2 or 3 headed attack. He catches the ball very well out of the backfield, and we could use him in short yardage situation, and to burn clock late in games if we have leads. He definitly has value ... just not as much value as he thinks. Hopefully he comes to his sense. I don;t think him coming back is realistic though as the front office seems to be dancing around any questions about bringing him back.

    Now the free agents I would love to try and bring in.

    I would go hard at Mario Williams. Our defense was much improved and looks to be headed in the right direction. Adding Williams would would really solidify what could become the best D-Line in football. Williams-Rubin-Taylor-Sheard looks pretty nice on paper. Williams would also add a face to this defense. He is come coaches game plan around. We need that. Those 4 D-lineman could go to war against any 5 offensive lineman in the league for my team anytime.

    I would also go after Desean Jackson. And him saying he would be ok with a franchise tag and the Eagles saying they would franchise him is news to me. Not saying that isn't the case ...just saying I haven't heard that. I also haven't looked into it though. After the offseason the Eagles had this past year I can't imagine them being in good cap situation. We could really use this kid. He is a game breaker. If we can't get Desean I would go after Colston, Bowe, or Steve Johnson (if the deal was right I wouldnt hate Reggie Wayne either but he would be a quick little stop gap for a yr or 2)

    I wouldn't stop with Jackson (or one of the others I named). I would also look to add another WR via FA. The couple guys that really intrigue me that I think we can get at fair prices and that are still young and in there prime are Mario Manningham, and Robert Meachum.

    We need WR's so bad I don;t even want to risk drafting a potential a bust. I want a guy who has proven he could play at this level.

    Next I would like to go after a CD or LB in free agency (the other I would draft) Cortland Finnegan seems to think he may have played his last game in tennesse. I would welcome him with open arms. Dude is a good cover corner and a great CB against the run. And he has attitude. I don't know how realistic it is to sign him (especially if we were to sign the other guys I would like ... but fuck it it aint my money im spending) If Finnegan is out we can always go after a guy Carlos Rogers,Brent Grimes or Brandon Carr.

    If we were to grab a backer to be honest no one really sticks out at me. I would probably prefer drafting a couple. (one in round 1 and if we pick up an additional second rounder I have no problem grabbing another one)

    Draft wise assuming that we A. sign the guys I like and B. trade the 4 to the skins or phins and pick up an additional second rounder. I would ideally like to see ...

    1a Luke Kuechly

    1b best tackle or guard available (depends on there plan for Pinkston if the intent is play him at gaurd we go tackle if it is tackle we go gaurd)

    2a Chase Minifield

    2b Best OLD available

    3 we go RB here My choice would be Lamichael James if he isn;t available there are some other good backs and backs have been slipping lately.

    4-7 we just go BPA maybe even gamble on someone comming off an injury with good upside or someone with big time upside from a small school.

    I would inquire about what it would take to trade for Osi (even if we sign Mario Williams)I would also put fliers out there on MoMass, HArdesty and Cribbs and see if we could get anything for them. MoMass and Hardesty I would take pretty much anything for. Cribbs obviously I wouldn't just throw to the curb ... but if he and a third or fourth rounder got us Osi I would do it 100 out of 100 times a day and double on saturdays.

    hoortaH 1 Reply Last reply
    Quote Reply
    • B brownfish

      #6 Trent Richards

      #22 Jonathon Martin

      Round 2

      Perry, Ingram or Minnifield

      Round 3

      Brian Quick or Doug Martin

      Round 4

      Osweiler or Cousins

      later rounds FB

      DawginIT D
      • 278 Posts
      • 22 Reputation
      D DawginIT wrote on last edited by
      #14

      @brownfish said:

      #6 Trent Richards

      #22 Jonathon Martin

      Round 2

      Perry, Ingram or Minnifield

      Round 3

      Brian Quick or Doug Martin

      Round 4

      Osweiler or Cousins

      later rounds FB

      Why would we draft Martin after we take Richardson? Also, you didn't even come close to addressing receiver (Brian Quick does not count).

      1 Reply Last reply
      Quote Reply
      • B brownfish

        #6 Trent Richards

        #22 Jonathon Martin

        Round 2

        Perry, Ingram or Minnifield

        Round 3

        Brian Quick or Doug Martin

        Round 4

        Osweiler or Cousins

        later rounds FB

        jnuh J
        • 402 Posts
        • 27 Reputation
        J jnuh wrote on last edited by
        #15

        @brownfish said:

        #6 Trent Richards

        #22 Jonathon Martin

        Round 2

        Perry, Ingram or Minnifield

        Round 3

        Brian Quick or Doug Martin

        Round 4

        Osweiler or Cousins

        later rounds FB

        I will probably get blasted for this, but with the running back talent that has been coming into the league after the first round of the draft I wouldn't even consider drafting one in round one. Unless we were a running back away from a complete team. As it stands though we have a lot of holes to fill. I would also take into account that the self life of running backs typically isn't to long

        Look at all the top RB's

        Ray Rice 2nd round

        Arian Foster undrafted

        MJD 2nd round

        Shady MCcoy 2nd round

        Michael Turner 5th round

        Frank Gore 3rd round

        Ahmad Bradshaw 6th round

        Matt Forte 2nd round

        Not saying there isn't talent in the first round obviously there is. I just think you can get great runners after round 1.

        1 Reply Last reply
        Quote Reply
        • Tim Couch Pulls Out Tim Couch Pulls OutT Very Popular Reacting Well Posting Machine Collaborator First Post One Year In One Month Later Week One Done
          • 8k Posts
          • 1k Reputation
          Tim Couch Pulls OutT Tim Couch Pulls Out wrote on last edited by Tim Couch Pulls Out
          #16

          Trade back a couple spots. Maybe Seattle. Grab Alshon. Grab Zach Brown. Grab Vinny Curry, or be DE available. Grab Andrew Datko. Then go for position or go BPA, whatever.

          EDIT: Oh, and in FA resign Hillis, DQ, Steinbach. If we don't nab a DE, make a play for Williams but settle for Mathis. Move Pinkston to RG.

          In one fell swoop we add a playmaker redzone threat WR, grab a speedy cover OLB, a pass rushing DE in either Vinny Curry, Mathis or Williams, and add an outstanding tackle to the right side in Datko.

          Corner position is not as big of a necessity. Safety, maybe. I'd rather see Adams than Young opposite Ward. If we go for Burfict, move DQ to OLB since he's better as a cover LB than as a run stuffer.

          I mean, that just makes sense to me.

          I'm awesome, and I fuck dolphins. Ghoolie 12/2/2012: I have absolutely no skills, training or pride
          1 Reply Last reply
          Quote Reply
          • J jnuh

            I would love RGIII to be on the board ... just so we can trade that pick to Washington or Miami. The drop off from RGIII to the third best QB this year is a pretty significant dropoff so we should ATLEAST pick up an additional second rounder. I wouldn't be shocked to see a team like Washington give us a first next yr though along with a pick or 2 additionally from this years draft. Picking up a first this yr and next is oobviously a long shot, but you never know (Washington has made some bonehead moves.)

            So I will start with free agency for my off season plan.

            First off I would resign Dqwell, and Mike Adams (as a reserve obviosly) if we lose Adams though no big loss.

            I would also love to have Hillis back at the right price. I wouldn't want him as a "feature back" but I would like him as our main RB in a 2 or 3 headed attack. He catches the ball very well out of the backfield, and we could use him in short yardage situation, and to burn clock late in games if we have leads. He definitly has value ... just not as much value as he thinks. Hopefully he comes to his sense. I don;t think him coming back is realistic though as the front office seems to be dancing around any questions about bringing him back.

            Now the free agents I would love to try and bring in.

            I would go hard at Mario Williams. Our defense was much improved and looks to be headed in the right direction. Adding Williams would would really solidify what could become the best D-Line in football. Williams-Rubin-Taylor-Sheard looks pretty nice on paper. Williams would also add a face to this defense. He is come coaches game plan around. We need that. Those 4 D-lineman could go to war against any 5 offensive lineman in the league for my team anytime.

            I would also go after Desean Jackson. And him saying he would be ok with a franchise tag and the Eagles saying they would franchise him is news to me. Not saying that isn't the case ...just saying I haven't heard that. I also haven't looked into it though. After the offseason the Eagles had this past year I can't imagine them being in good cap situation. We could really use this kid. He is a game breaker. If we can't get Desean I would go after Colston, Bowe, or Steve Johnson (if the deal was right I wouldnt hate Reggie Wayne either but he would be a quick little stop gap for a yr or 2)

            I wouldn't stop with Jackson (or one of the others I named). I would also look to add another WR via FA. The couple guys that really intrigue me that I think we can get at fair prices and that are still young and in there prime are Mario Manningham, and Robert Meachum.

            We need WR's so bad I don;t even want to risk drafting a potential a bust. I want a guy who has proven he could play at this level.

            Next I would like to go after a CD or LB in free agency (the other I would draft) Cortland Finnegan seems to think he may have played his last game in tennesse. I would welcome him with open arms. Dude is a good cover corner and a great CB against the run. And he has attitude. I don't know how realistic it is to sign him (especially if we were to sign the other guys I would like ... but fuck it it aint my money im spending) If Finnegan is out we can always go after a guy Carlos Rogers,Brent Grimes or Brandon Carr.

            If we were to grab a backer to be honest no one really sticks out at me. I would probably prefer drafting a couple. (one in round 1 and if we pick up an additional second rounder I have no problem grabbing another one)

            Draft wise assuming that we A. sign the guys I like and B. trade the 4 to the skins or phins and pick up an additional second rounder. I would ideally like to see ...

            1a Luke Kuechly

            1b best tackle or guard available (depends on there plan for Pinkston if the intent is play him at gaurd we go tackle if it is tackle we go gaurd)

            2a Chase Minifield

            2b Best OLD available

            3 we go RB here My choice would be Lamichael James if he isn;t available there are some other good backs and backs have been slipping lately.

            4-7 we just go BPA maybe even gamble on someone comming off an injury with good upside or someone with big time upside from a small school.

            I would inquire about what it would take to trade for Osi (even if we sign Mario Williams)I would also put fliers out there on MoMass, HArdesty and Cribbs and see if we could get anything for them. MoMass and Hardesty I would take pretty much anything for. Cribbs obviously I wouldn't just throw to the curb ... but if he and a third or fourth rounder got us Osi I would do it 100 out of 100 times a day and double on saturdays.

            hoorta hoortaH Conversation Starter Dedicated Very Popular Posting Machine Collaborator First Post Reacting Well One Year In One Month Later Week One Done
            • 20k Posts
            • 5k Reputation
            hoortaH hoorta wrote on last edited by hoorta
            #17

            @jnuh said:

            I would love RGIII to be on the board ... just so we can trade that pick to Washington or Miami. The drop off from RGIII to the third best QB this year is a pretty significant dropoff so we should ATLEAST pick up an additional second rounder. I wouldn't be shocked to see a team like Washington give us a first next yr though along with a pick or 2 additionally from this years draft. Picking up a first this yr and next is oobviously a long shot, but you never know (Washington has made some bonehead moves.)

            So I will start with free agency for my off season plan.

            First off I would resign Dqwell, and Mike Adams (as a reserve obviosly) if we lose Adams though no big loss.

            I would also love to have Hillis back at the right price. I wouldn't want him as a "feature back" but I would like him as our main RB in a 2 or 3 headed attack. He catches the ball very well out of the backfield, and we could use him in short yardage situation, and to burn clock late in games if we have leads. He definitly has value ... just not as much value as he thinks. Hopefully he comes to his sense. I don;t think him coming back is realistic though as the front office seems to be dancing around any questions about bringing him back.

            Now the free agents I would love to try and bring in.

            I would go hard at Mario Williams. Our defense was much improved and looks to be headed in the right direction. Adding Williams would would really solidify what could become the best D-Line in football. Williams-Rubin-Taylor-Sheard looks pretty nice on paper. Williams would also add a face to this defense. He is come coaches game plan around. We need that. Those 4 D-lineman could go to war against any 5 offensive lineman in the league for my team anytime.

            I would also go after Desean Jackson. And him saying he would be ok with a franchise tag and the Eagles saying they would franchise him is news to me. Not saying that isn't the case ...just saying I haven't heard that. I also haven't looked into it though. After the offseason the Eagles had this past year I can't imagine them being in good cap situation. We could really use this kid. He is a game breaker. If we can't get Desean I would go after Colston, Bowe, or Steve Johnson (if the deal was right I wouldnt hate Reggie Wayne either but he would be a quick little stop gap for a yr or 2)

            I wouldn't stop with Jackson (or one of the others I named). I would also look to add another WR via FA. The couple guys that really intrigue me that I think we can get at fair prices and that are still young and in there prime are Mario Manningham, and Robert Meachum.

            We need WR's so bad I don;t even want to risk drafting a potential a bust. I want a guy who has proven he could play at this level.

            Next I would like to go after a CD or LB in free agency (the other I would draft) Cortland Finnegan seems to think he may have played his last game in tennesse. I would welcome him with open arms. Dude is a good cover corner and a great CB against the run. And he has attitude. I don't know how realistic it is to sign him (especially if we were to sign the other guys I would like ... but fuck it it aint my money I'm spending) If Finnegan is out we can always go after a guy Carlos Rogers,Brent Grimes or Brandon Carr.

            If we were to grab a backer to be honest no one really sticks out at me. I would probably prefer drafting a couple. (one in round 1 and if we pick up an additional second rounder I have no problem grabbing another one)

            Draft wise assuming that we A. sign the guys I like and B. trade the 4 to the skins or phins and pick up an additional second rounder. I would ideally like to see ...

            1a Luke Kuechly

            1b best tackle or guard available (depends on there plan for Pinkston if the intent is play him at gaurd we go tackle if it is tackle we go gaurd)

            2a Chase Minifield

            2b Best OLD available

            3 we go RB here My choice would be Lamichael James if he isn;t available there are some other good backs and backs have been slipping lately.

            4-7 we just go BPA maybe even gamble on someone comming off an injury with good upside or someone with big time upside from a small school.

            I would inquire about what it would take to trade for Osi (even if we sign Mario Williams)I would also put fliers out there on MoMass, HArdesty and Cribbs and see if we could get anything for them. MoMass and Hardesty I would take pretty much anything for. Cribbs obviously I wouldn't just throw to the curb ... but if he and a third or fourth rounder got us Osi I would do it 100 out of 100 times a day and double on saturdays.

            You're right about it not being your money- I love these pie in the sky projections during the silly season. Let's try and sign every FA out there at a position of need. Get Williams, and give up our #4 overall to the Colts for Manning, pick up his $28 million bonus and blow our cap to hell. EDIT: on two players.

            1 Reply Last reply
            Quote Reply
            • choco chocoC
              • 4k Posts
              • 352 Reputation
              chocoC choco wrote on last edited by
              #18

              ^yup...amusing to say the least.

              i think the "its not my money" approach is fundamentally flawed, and almost always results in a) grandiose projections, and 😎 unrealistic expectations.

              try imagining what you'd do if you didn't have an unlimited budget....look at some actual numbers. cause the parameters we operate under with some of these ridiculous and utterly absurd predictions/plans are completely different than a GM with a budget and an actual job to do.

              J 1 Reply Last reply
              Quote Reply
              • calfoxwc C Dedicated Very Popular Conversation Starter Collaborator First Post Posting Machine Reacting Well Week One Done One Year In One Month Later
                • 64k Posts
                • 8k Reputation
                C calfoxwc wrote on last edited by
                #19

                In FA, I'd go for Jeremy Minrey, DE Jags, or Robert Mathis, DE, Colts. Mathis is 30, but that gives the Browns at least a year or two

                to draft a DE.

                And, Measham, WR, Saints..... or Harry Douglas, WR, Falcons, or Vincent Jackson, WR Chargers...

                With those two positions filled in FA, that lets the Browns draft Richardson or Blackmon at #4,

                and they won't have to draft a DE this year at all. Polk doesn't seem to be the guy for the Browns - he lacks

                the speed to get to the corner like Richardson can.

                But, I'd like to see the Browns trade down a bit, get another first round pick (three all together) and whatever other picks...

                and draft the LB in the first round.

                nobody knows.

                1 Reply Last reply
                Quote Reply
                • bringbackbrownie2 B
                  • 1k Posts
                  • 118 Reputation
                  B bringbackbrownie2 wrote on last edited by
                  #20

                  Zombo said:

                  Yes! What an addition he would be to that young defensive line. You pay him a boatload, but if you are expecting to be in the playoffs in two years you need these kind of vets.

                  Guy is consistent as hell and would turn Sheard loose.

                  Zombo

                  I wouldn't be opposed to this either but who would move to RE? Mathis has played LE his whole career and Sheard already plays LE for us. I'm not sure how difficult it is to switch to the other side..

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  Quote Reply
                  • chocoC choco

                    ^yup...amusing to say the least.

                    i think the "its not my money" approach is fundamentally flawed, and almost always results in a) grandiose projections, and 😎 unrealistic expectations.

                    try imagining what you'd do if you didn't have an unlimited budget....look at some actual numbers. cause the parameters we operate under with some of these ridiculous and utterly absurd predictions/plans are completely different than a GM with a budget and an actual job to do.

                    jnuh J
                    • 402 Posts
                    • 27 Reputation
                    J jnuh wrote on last edited by jnuh
                    #21

                    @choco said:

                    ^yup...amusing to say the least.

                    i think the "its not my money" approach is fundamentally flawed, and almost always results in a) grandiose projections, and 😎 unrealistic expectations.

                    try imagining what you'd do if you didn't have an unlimited budget....look at some actual numbers. cause the parameters we operate under with some of these ridiculous and utterly absurd predictions/plans are completely different than a GM with a budget and an actual job to do.

                    Honestly money wise it is doable. I can't find the exact figure but off the top of my head I remember us having between 25-30 mil under the cap. We have a ton of cap space signing Williams and Jackson could happen if they wanted it to. Adding a quality CB and quality WR additionally might be out of reach but it really depends on what people are willing to pay Meachum and Manningham of the world.

                    hoortaH chocoC 2 Replies Last reply
                    Quote Reply
                    • J jnuh

                      @choco said:

                      ^yup...amusing to say the least.

                      i think the "its not my money" approach is fundamentally flawed, and almost always results in a) grandiose projections, and 😎 unrealistic expectations.

                      try imagining what you'd do if you didn't have an unlimited budget....look at some actual numbers. cause the parameters we operate under with some of these ridiculous and utterly absurd predictions/plans are completely different than a GM with a budget and an actual job to do.

                      Honestly money wise it is doable. I can't find the exact figure but off the top of my head I remember us having between 25-30 mil under the cap. We have a ton of cap space signing Williams and Jackson could happen if they wanted it to. Adding a quality CB and quality WR additionally might be out of reach but it really depends on what people are willing to pay Meachum and Manningham of the world.

                      hoorta hoortaH Conversation Starter Dedicated Very Popular Posting Machine Collaborator First Post Reacting Well One Year In One Month Later Week One Done
                      • 20k Posts
                      • 5k Reputation
                      hoortaH hoorta wrote on last edited by
                      #22

                      @jnuh said:

                      Honestly money wise it is doable. I can't find the exact figure but off the top of my head I remember us having between 25-30 mil under the cap. We have a ton of cap space signing Williams and Jackson could happen if they wanted it to. Adding a quality CB and quality WR additionally might be out of reach but it really depends on what people are willing to pay Meachum and Manningham of the world.

                      Gotta lower your expectations, kiddo. Here's some real world numbers. Williams will get an $80 million contract- take it to the bank- pun intended. We'll have to overpay like hell to persuade him to leave Super Bowl contender Houston, something Heckert is extremely unlikely to do. Franchise money for a wr receiver is $9.5 million so forget about Jackson, headcase problems aside. So you've already blown all the cap on two players.

                      Not only that, once you have those two guys on board- it creates a ripple effect on salary demands from guys you already have on the team. Exhibit "A" would be the Browns picking up FA Raymond Clayborn from the Patriots for big bucks way back when. And you can't blame them. So we bring in Williams- Sheard has as many sacks- he's gonna say- "Well I'm playing as good as Mario, so now I want Mario money too."

                      Another WR? Well Manningham is going to think he's worth Anquan Boldin money, which is around $8.5 million a year, not counting signing bonus. Adding a CB the caliber of Jonathan Joseph (5 year deal, $48.5 million) about $12 million up front = tilt. Your scenario might work if you're playing Madden, won't work for the Browns. Doubly, because with a 4-12 record, we're going to have to overpay anyone we get.

                      Look no farther than the current Super Bowl teams, maybe only a couple of superstars- but a bunch of solid players and great coaching.

                      J 1 Reply Last reply
                      👍
                      Quote Reply
                      • DawginIT D
                        • 278 Posts
                        • 22 Reputation
                        D DawginIT wrote on last edited by
                        #23

                        Zombo said:

                        Sheard is more comfortable at LE, but with Mathis at LE I think he would learn to excel at RE. Talent is talent, and he's got it.

                        Zombo

                        I agree Sheard could probably play either position he wanted to. But why move him to RE for a few seasons at most with Mathis? Once Mathis leaves the Sheard is going to want to move back. Sheard is the future, let him play where he is more comfortable.

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        Quote Reply
                        • J jnuh

                          @choco said:

                          ^yup...amusing to say the least.

                          i think the "its not my money" approach is fundamentally flawed, and almost always results in a) grandiose projections, and 😎 unrealistic expectations.

                          try imagining what you'd do if you didn't have an unlimited budget....look at some actual numbers. cause the parameters we operate under with some of these ridiculous and utterly absurd predictions/plans are completely different than a GM with a budget and an actual job to do.

                          Honestly money wise it is doable. I can't find the exact figure but off the top of my head I remember us having between 25-30 mil under the cap. We have a ton of cap space signing Williams and Jackson could happen if they wanted it to. Adding a quality CB and quality WR additionally might be out of reach but it really depends on what people are willing to pay Meachum and Manningham of the world.

                          choco chocoC
                          • 4k Posts
                          • 352 Reputation
                          chocoC choco wrote on last edited by
                          #24

                          @jnuh said:

                          Honestly money wise it is doable. I can't find the exact figure but off the top of my head I remember us having between 25-30 mil under the cap. We have a ton of cap space signing Williams and Jackson could happen if they wanted it to. Adding a quality CB and quality WR additionally might be out of reach but it really depends on what people are willing to pay Meachum and Manningham of the world.

                          about 18 mil as we sit now was last i heard after gocong got paid. sure we could do it, to the detriment of the rest of the squad.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          Quote Reply
                          • DawginIT D
                            • 278 Posts
                            • 22 Reputation
                            D DawginIT wrote on last edited by
                            #25

                            I'd rather pay big money to one player that would finish out a very good unit (defensive line) than pay the same amount of money to players like we have recently. Scott Fujita, Chris Gocong, Sheldon Brown, Evan Moore, etc. We could have the best defensive line in football with Williams. Then draft a DB that can hopefully upgrade over Brown or Adams or a linebacker that will upgrade Fujita.

                            miktoxicM 1 Reply Last reply
                            Quote Reply
                            • D DawginIT

                              I'd rather pay big money to one player that would finish out a very good unit (defensive line) than pay the same amount of money to players like we have recently. Scott Fujita, Chris Gocong, Sheldon Brown, Evan Moore, etc. We could have the best defensive line in football with Williams. Then draft a DB that can hopefully upgrade over Brown or Adams or a linebacker that will upgrade Fujita.

                              miktoxic miktoxicM
                              • 13k Posts
                              • 1k Reputation
                              miktoxicM miktoxic wrote on last edited by
                              #26

                              @dawginit said:

                              I'd rather pay big money to one player that would finish out a very good unit (defensive line) than pay the same amount of money to players like we have recently. Scott Fujita, Chris Gocong, Sheldon Brown, Evan Moore, etc. We could have the best defensive line in football with Williams. Then draft a DB that can hopefully upgrade over Brown or Adams or a linebacker that will upgrade Fujita.

                              we won't sign williams but we will draft all three positions that you mentioned.

                              D 1 Reply Last reply
                              Quote Reply
                              • hoortaH hoorta

                                @jnuh said:

                                Honestly money wise it is doable. I can't find the exact figure but off the top of my head I remember us having between 25-30 mil under the cap. We have a ton of cap space signing Williams and Jackson could happen if they wanted it to. Adding a quality CB and quality WR additionally might be out of reach but it really depends on what people are willing to pay Meachum and Manningham of the world.

                                Gotta lower your expectations, kiddo. Here's some real world numbers. Williams will get an $80 million contract- take it to the bank- pun intended. We'll have to overpay like hell to persuade him to leave Super Bowl contender Houston, something Heckert is extremely unlikely to do. Franchise money for a wr receiver is $9.5 million so forget about Jackson, headcase problems aside. So you've already blown all the cap on two players.

                                Not only that, once you have those two guys on board- it creates a ripple effect on salary demands from guys you already have on the team. Exhibit "A" would be the Browns picking up FA Raymond Clayborn from the Patriots for big bucks way back when. And you can't blame them. So we bring in Williams- Sheard has as many sacks- he's gonna say- "Well I'm playing as good as Mario, so now I want Mario money too."

                                Another WR? Well Manningham is going to think he's worth Anquan Boldin money, which is around $8.5 million a year, not counting signing bonus. Adding a CB the caliber of Jonathan Joseph (5 year deal, $48.5 million) about $12 million up front = tilt. Your scenario might work if you're playing Madden, won't work for the Browns. Doubly, because with a 4-12 record, we're going to have to overpay anyone we get.

                                Look no farther than the current Super Bowl teams, maybe only a couple of superstars- but a bunch of solid players and great coaching.

                                jnuh J
                                • 402 Posts
                                • 27 Reputation
                                J jnuh wrote on last edited by
                                #27

                                @hoorta said:

                                Gotta lower your expectations, kiddo. Here's some real world numbers. Williams will get an $80 million contract- take it to the bank- pun intended. We'll have to overpay like hell to persuade him to leave Super Bowl contender Houston, something Heckert is extremely unlikely to do. Franchise money for a wr receiver is $9.5 million so forget about Jackson, headcase problems aside. So you've already blown all the cap on two players.

                                Not only that, once you have those two guys on board- it creates a ripple effect on salary demands from guys you already have on the team. Exhibit "A" would be the Browns picking up FA Raymond Clayborn from the Patriots for big bucks way back when. And you can't blame them. So we bring in Williams- Sheard has as many sacks- he's gonna say- "Well I'm playing as good as Mario, so now I want Mario money too."

                                Another WR? Well Manningham is going to think he's worth Anquan Boldin money, which is around $8.5 million a year, not counting signing bonus. Adding a CB the caliber of Jonathan Joseph (5 year deal, $48.5 million) about $12 million up front = tilt. Your scenario might work if you're playing Madden, won't work for the Browns. Doubly, because with a 4-12 record, we're going to have to overpay anyone we get.

                                Look no farther than the current Super Bowl teams, maybe only a couple of superstars- but a bunch of solid players and great coaching.

                                Those are by no means my expectations. That is just what I would try and do. And I would get rid of as much dead weight I needed to to get it done.

                                Also there is way in hell Manningham commands Boldin money. He has never had a Boldin type of year. His best year probably isn't as good as Boldins worst year.

                                hoortaH 1 Reply Last reply
                                Quote Reply
                                • miktoxicM miktoxic

                                  @dawginit said:

                                  I'd rather pay big money to one player that would finish out a very good unit (defensive line) than pay the same amount of money to players like we have recently. Scott Fujita, Chris Gocong, Sheldon Brown, Evan Moore, etc. We could have the best defensive line in football with Williams. Then draft a DB that can hopefully upgrade over Brown or Adams or a linebacker that will upgrade Fujita.

                                  we won't sign williams but we will draft all three positions that you mentioned.

                                  DawginIT D
                                  • 278 Posts
                                  • 22 Reputation
                                  D DawginIT wrote on last edited by
                                  #28

                                  @miktoxic said:

                                  we won't sign williams but we will draft all three positions that you mentioned.

                                  We better not blow a pick on a tight end unless Dwayne Allen some how falls to the 4th round or later. But ya we seriously need help at OLB.

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  Quote Reply
                                  • PoeticG PoeticGP Dedicated Reacting Well Very Popular Posting Machine Collaborator First Post One Year In One Month Later Week One Done
                                    • 4k Posts
                                    • 658 Reputation
                                    PoeticGP PoeticG wrote on last edited by
                                    #29

                                    Either Blackmon, Richardson, Kalil or Luck at #4

                                    Chase Minnifield at #22

                                    The secret of getting ahead is getting started. The secret of getting started is breaking your complex overwhelming tasks into small manageable tasks, and then starting on the first one. -Mark Twain- "It's not the size of the dog in the fight, it's the size of the fight in the dog." -Mark Twain-
                                    D 1 Reply Last reply
                                    Quote Reply
                                    • PoeticGP PoeticG

                                      Either Blackmon, Richardson, Kalil or Luck at #4

                                      Chase Minnifield at #22

                                      DawginIT D
                                      • 278 Posts
                                      • 22 Reputation
                                      D DawginIT wrote on last edited by
                                      #30

                                      @poeticg said:

                                      Either Blackmon, Richardson, Kalil or Luck at #4

                                      Chase Minnifield at #22

                                      What is you damn obsession with Minniefield? He WILL be there in the second round so CHILLLLLLL. I'd also like to see him in a Browns Uni but you would be reaching for him at 22.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      Quote Reply
                                      • J jnuh

                                        @hoorta said:

                                        Gotta lower your expectations, kiddo. Here's some real world numbers. Williams will get an $80 million contract- take it to the bank- pun intended. We'll have to overpay like hell to persuade him to leave Super Bowl contender Houston, something Heckert is extremely unlikely to do. Franchise money for a wr receiver is $9.5 million so forget about Jackson, headcase problems aside. So you've already blown all the cap on two players.

                                        Not only that, once you have those two guys on board- it creates a ripple effect on salary demands from guys you already have on the team. Exhibit "A" would be the Browns picking up FA Raymond Clayborn from the Patriots for big bucks way back when. And you can't blame them. So we bring in Williams- Sheard has as many sacks- he's gonna say- "Well I'm playing as good as Mario, so now I want Mario money too."

                                        Another WR? Well Manningham is going to think he's worth Anquan Boldin money, which is around $8.5 million a year, not counting signing bonus. Adding a CB the caliber of Jonathan Joseph (5 year deal, $48.5 million) about $12 million up front = tilt. Your scenario might work if you're playing Madden, won't work for the Browns. Doubly, because with a 4-12 record, we're going to have to overpay anyone we get.

                                        Look no farther than the current Super Bowl teams, maybe only a couple of superstars- but a bunch of solid players and great coaching.

                                        Those are by no means my expectations. That is just what I would try and do. And I would get rid of as much dead weight I needed to to get it done.

                                        Also there is way in hell Manningham commands Boldin money. He has never had a Boldin type of year. His best year probably isn't as good as Boldins worst year.

                                        hoorta hoortaH Conversation Starter Dedicated Very Popular Posting Machine Collaborator First Post Reacting Well One Year In One Month Later Week One Done
                                        • 20k Posts
                                        • 5k Reputation
                                        hoortaH hoorta wrote on last edited by
                                        #31

                                        @jnuh said:

                                        Those are by no means my expectations. That is just what I would try and do. And I would get rid of as much dead weight I needed to to get it done.

                                        Also there is way in hell Manningham commands Boldin money. He has never had a Boldin type of year. His best year probably isn't as good as Boldins worst year.

                                        If you try and do that, you're going to have to unload 1\2 the the team in the process. BTW, Manningham has had a couple years as good as Boldin- but hasn't had the super stud years, so whoop-te-do, he'll only get $6 million a year. About $3 million more than he's worth- not a significant upgrade over Little.

                                        J 1 Reply Last reply
                                        Quote Reply
                                        • hoortaH hoorta

                                          @jnuh said:

                                          Those are by no means my expectations. That is just what I would try and do. And I would get rid of as much dead weight I needed to to get it done.

                                          Also there is way in hell Manningham commands Boldin money. He has never had a Boldin type of year. His best year probably isn't as good as Boldins worst year.

                                          If you try and do that, you're going to have to unload 1\2 the the team in the process. BTW, Manningham has had a couple years as good as Boldin- but hasn't had the super stud years, so whoop-te-do, he'll only get $6 million a year. About $3 million more than he's worth- not a significant upgrade over Little.

                                          jnuh J
                                          • 402 Posts
                                          • 27 Reputation
                                          J jnuh wrote on last edited by
                                          #32

                                          @hoorta said:

                                          If you try and do that, you're going to have to unload 1\2 the the team in the process. BTW, Manningham has had a couple years as good as Boldin- but hasn't had the super stud years, so whoop-te-do, he'll only get $6 million a year. About $3 million more than he's worth- not a significant upgrade over Little.

                                          Our records for the last 3 years as you know are 5-11. 5-11 and 4-12. I am just fine with getting rid of half the crap on this team if we can bring in guys like DJax, Mario Williams, another good WR, and a good CB. We can fill the holes with rookies and lesser known free agents.

                                          As far as Boldin and Manningham. Boldins last 2 seasons have been un Boldin like in comparison to what he has done in the past. Those are the 2 years though that yuou can compare to Manninghams better years statistically. Boldin however got his money after the big years not after the Manningham like years. I also don't think Manningham will get overpaid because of the abundance of good WRs available this year in free agency. If Manningham gets paid according to what he has actually produced he could be good value because he does have some upside. My interest in Manningham would realy depend on his asking price.

                                          I agree about Manningham not being a significant upgrade over Litte. I wasn't looking to replace Little though. I was looking to add a good legit third option to go along with a guy like a Desean Jackson (or a big name WR) and Little.

                                          B 1 Reply Last reply
                                          Quote Reply

                                          Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                          Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                          With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                          Register Login
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          Theme
                                          • System
                                          • Light
                                          • Dark
                                          The Browns Board Terms Privacy

                                          The Browns Board is an independent fan community. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by the Cleveland Browns, Cleveland Cavaliers, Cleveland Guardians, the NFL, NBA, MLB, or any of their affiliates. Team names, logos, and other marks are the property of their respective owners.

                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Forums
                                          • Recent
                                          • Popular
                                          • Users
                                          • Donate