Skip to content

The Team of the Decade, MLB

The Tribe Board
10 2 6.4k
  • For regulars you may know that I have maintained a "Team of the Decade" thread for Pro Football for a few years now. That is based on a scoring system I devised whereby I gave a team 10 points for winning a championship, 6 points for losing a championship game, 3 points for losing a conference title game, and 1 point for making the playoffs in any given year.

    I am going to apply the same system here. Bear with me as the changes in the playoff system that MLB has used over the years requires some adjustment in terms of applying my formula.

    From 1903, the year of the first World Series, to 1968 there were ONLY 2 team competing in post season play, an AL champ an an NL champ. To be consistent, I gave the winner of the WS 10 points and the loser 6 points. Its just that no teams were awarded 3 or 1 points for that period.

    After 1969 there were 4 teams in the playoffs, so 4 teams get points 10/6/3. After the playoffs expanded again in 1995 I then applied the 10/6/3/1 formula. So here are the points.....and the awarding of the mantle of "Team of the Decade" for MLB for every decade from the 1900s to now:

    1900s:

    Cubs 6, 10, 10 ........ 26 points. The Cubs are the Team of the Decade for the 1900-1909 Decade

    Tigers 6,6,6 .............. 18 pts

    Pirates 6,10..............16 pts

    White Sox 10.........10 pts

    Giants 10.............10 pts

    Red Sox 10.........10 pts

    Athletics 6......6 pts

    1910s:

    Red Sox 10,10,10, 10......40 points. The Red Sox are the Teams of the Decade for the 1910-1919 Decade

    As 10,10,10,6......36 points

    Giants 6,6,6,6.....24 pts.

    White Sox 10,6....16 pts.

    Cubs 6,6...........12 pts

    Braves 10..........10 pts

    Reds 10.............10 pts.

    Phillies 6...........6 pts

    Dodgers 6.........6 pts.

    1920s

    Yankees 6,6,10,6,10,10.....48 points. The Yankees are the Team of the Decade for 1920-1929

    Giants 10,10, 6, 6.....32 pts.

    Senators 10, 6..........16 pts

    Pirates 10, 6.............16 pts

    Cardinals 10, 6.........16 pts

    Indians 10...............10 pts.

    As 10....................10 pts

    Dodgers 6........6 pts

    Cubs 6 ............6 pts.

    1930s

    Yankees 10,10,10,10, 10.......50 pts. The Yankees are the Team of the Decade for 1930-1939

    Cardinals 6, 10, 10.............26 pts

    Giants 10, 6,6..................22 pts

    Cubs 6, 6, 6, ....................18 pts

    A's 10, 6...........................16 pts

    Tigers 6, 10.....................16 pts.

    Reds 6...........................6 pts

    Senators 6.....................6 pts

    1940s

    Yankees 10, 6, 10, 10, 10 ........46 points. The Yankees are the Team of the Decade for 1940-1949.

    Cardinals 10, 6, 10, 10..........36 pts

    Dodgers 6, 6, 6 ....................18 pts.

    Tigers 6, 10 ........................16 pts.

    Reds 10.............................10 pts

    Indians 10..........................10 pts

    Browns 6...........................6 pts (St. Louis Browns nka Balt. Orioles)

    Cubs 6............................6 pts

    Red Sox 6.....................6 pts

    Braves 6........................6 pts.

    1950s

    Yankees 10, 10, 10, 10 6, 10, 6, 10......72 pts. The Yankees are the Team of the Decade for 1950-1959 (by far the largest point total in a single decade)

    Dodgers 6, 6, 10, 6, 10.......38 pts

    Giants 6, 10.....................16 pts

    Braves 10, 6....................16 pts

    Phillies 6...........................6 pts.

    White Sox 6.....................6 pts

    Indians 6..........................6 pts

    1960s

    Yankees 6, 10, 10, 6, 6.......38 pts. The Yankees are the Team of the Decade for 1960-1969

    Dodgers 10, 10, 6.............26 pts

    Cardinals 10, 10, 6...........26 pts

    Orioles 10, 6...................16 pts

    Mets 10.........................10 pts

    Tigers 10......................10 pts

    Pirates 10....................10 pts

    Twins 6, 3...................9 pts

    Reds 6........................6 pts

    Giants 6......................6 pts

    Red Sox 6..................6 pts

    Braves 3 ..................3 pts

    1969 is the first year of the League Championship Series where more than 2 teams made postseason.

    I will treat each subsequent decade in a separate post hereafter, as it gets a bit more complex now.

  • 1970s

    Reds 6,6,3,10,10,3.............38 points. The Reds are the Team of the Decade of the 1970s

    As 3, 10, 10, 10, 3............36 pts

    Pirates 3, 10, 3, 3, 3, 10...32 pts

    Orioles 10, 6, 3, 3, 6.....28 pts.

    Yankees 6, 10, 10.......26 pts.

    Dodgers 6, 6, 6..........18 pts

    Royals 3, 3, 3, ..........9 pts.

    Phillies 3, 3, 3...........9 pts

    Red Sox 6.............6 pts

    Mets 6..................6 pts.

    Twins 3........3 pts

    Giants 3......3 pts

    Tigers 3......3 pts

    Angels........3 pts.

    The 1970s is the closest Team of the Decade Race in history, with only 2 points separating the first and second place team.

    (Oddly, the same is true in football, the 70s was the closest race...Steelers/Cowboys only 2 pts apart)

  • 1980s

    Dodgers 10, 3, 3, 10 ............26 points. The Dodgers are the Team of the Decade from 1980 to 1989

    Cardinals 10, 6, 6 ................22 pts.

    Royals 6, 1, 3, 6..................20 pts

    A's 3, 6, 10 ........................19 pts

    Phillies 10, 1, 6..................17 pts

    Tigers 10, 3 ......................13 pts

    Mets 10, 3........................13 pts

    Orioles 10........................10 pts

    Twins 10..........................10 pts

    Yankees 3, 6...................9 pts

    Red Sox 6, 3...................9 pts

    Giants 3, 6......................9 pts.

    Astros 3, 1, 6..................7 pts

    Brewers 1, 6..................7 pts

    Angels 3, 3...................6 pts

    Padres 6......................6 pts

    Cubs 3, 3.....................6 pts

    Blue Jays 3, 3.............6 pts

    White Sox 3 .............3 pts

    Braves 3 ...................3 pts

    Expos 3 ...................3 pts (nka Washington Nationals)

    Note, in 1981, due to a strike I believe MLB expanded the playoffs to include wildcard teams. After that they went back to just division winners playing. Not until 1995 did wildcards come back into play. That is why you see a few teams with 1 pt.

  • 1990s

    Braves 6, 3, 10, 6, 3, 3, 6......37 points. The Braves are the Team of the Decade for the 1990s

    Yankees 1, 10, 1, 10, 10 ......32 pts.

    Blue Jays 3, 10, 10...............23 pts

    Indians 6, 1, 6, 3, 1..............17 pts

    Red Sox 3, 3, 1, 1, 3...........11 pts

    Reds 10 .............................10 pts

    Marlins 10...........................10 pts

    Twins 10.............................10 pts

    Padres 6, 1........................7 pts

    As 6................................6 pts

    Pirates 3, 3....................6 pts

    Phillies 6.......................6 pts

    Orioles 3, 3...................6 pts

    Mariners 3, 1................4 pts

    White Sox 3...............3 pts

    Cardinals 3...............3 pts

    Rangers 1, 1, 1.........3 pts

    Astros 1, 1, 1............3 pts

    Mets 3......................3 pts

    Dodgers 1, 1............2 pts

    Rockies 1................1 pt.

    Giants 1..................1 pts

    Cubs 1....................1 pts

    D-backs..................1 pt

  • 2000s

    Yankees 10, 6, 1, 6, 3, 1, 1, 1, 1, 10........40 points. The Yankees are the Team of the Decade for 2000-2009

    Red Sox 3, 10, 1, 10, 3, 1....................31 pts

    Cardinals 3, 1, 3, 6, 3, 10, 1................27 pts

    Angels 10, 1, 3, 1, 1, 3.......................19 pts

    Phillies 1, 10, 6..................................17 pts

    Diamondbacks 10, 1, 3......................14 pts

    White Sox 1, 10.................................11 pts

    Marlins 10 ........................................10 pts

    Astros 1, 3, 6.....................................10 pts

    Mets 6, 3...........................................9 pts

    Giants 1, 6, 1, 1...............................9 pts

    Braves 1, 3, 1, 1, 1, 1......................8 pts

    Dodgers 1, 1, 3, 3...........................8 pts

    As 1, 1, 1, 1, 3.................................7 pts

    Twins 3, 1, 1, 1, 1...........................7 pts

    Rockies 6, 1 .................................7 pts

    Rays 6.........................................6 pts

    Tigers 6.......................................6 pts

    Mariners 3, 3..............................6 pts

    Cubs 3, 1, 1...............................5 pts

    Indians 1, 3................................4 pts

    Padres1, 1................................2 pts.

    Brewers 1.................................1 pt

  • 2010s so far:

    The lead for Team of the Decade is in the balance

    Giants 10, 10...............20 pts so far

    Cardinals 10, 3..........13 pts so far

    Rangers 6, 6.............12 pts

    Tigers 3,6,3..............12 pts

    Yankees 3, 1, 3........7 pts

    Phillies 3, 1..............4 pts

    Rays 1, 1, 1............3 pts

    Brewers 3..............3 pts

    Dodgers 3.............3 pts

    Reds 1, 1..............2 pts

    Bravess 1, 1,.........2 pts

    A's 1, 1.................2 pts

    Reds 1, 1............2 pts

    Twins 1................ 1 pts

    D-backs...............1 pt

    Nationals 1..........1 pt

    Indians 1..............1 pt.

    Pirates 1..............1 pt.

    If the Cardinals win the World Series, they will take over the lead for Team of the Decade. If they don't win, the Giants maintain the lead by 1 point.

    The Red Sox will get either 6 or 10 pts...but those will be their first points of the decade....and would give them at best 5th place

  • Lol at the Cubs.

  • Lol at the Cubs.

    @koalabazooka said:

    Lol at the Cubs.

    A hundred plus years ago they were the best....but it is now 105 years and running since they won a WS.

  • After Last night's win by the Red XoS here is the current standings in this category:

    Team of the Decade 2010s, so far:

    Giants 10, 10...............20 pts so far

    Cardinals 10, 3, 6..........19 pts so far

    Rangers 6, 6.............12 pts

    Tigers 3,6,3..............12 pts

    Red Sox 10..............10 pts.

    Yankees 3, 1, 3........7 pts

    Phillies 3, 1..............4 pts

    Rays 1, 1, 1............3 pts

    Brewers 3..............3 pts

    Dodgers 3.............3 pts

    Reds 1, 1..............2 pts

    Bravess 1, 1,.........2 pts

    A's 1, 1.................2 pts

    Reds 1, 1............2 pts

    Twins 1................ 1 pts

    D-backs...............1 pt

    Nationals 1..........1 pt

    Indians 1..............1 pt.

    Pirates 1..............1 pt

  • Just a note: this was the 4th meeting in the World Series between the Red Sox and Cardinals. Other 4 or more WS matchups in history:

    Yankees/Dodgers 11 times

    Yankees/Giants 7 times

    Yankees/Cardinals 5 times

    Yankees/Braves 4 times

    As/Giants 4 times

    Tigers/Cubs 4 times

    and now Red Xos/Cards