Skip to content

Wtf is happening in Charlottesville?

Political Discussion
303 23 4.6k
  • Keep in mind that the South could have remained in the union and kept their slaves as long as the north got their cut of the cotton money. Slavery would have died out soon enough anyway. Abe Lincoln primarily freed the slaves to fuck with the rebels.

    WSS

    @westside-steve said:

    Keep in mind that the South could have remained in the union and kept their slaves as long as the north got their cut of the cotton money. Slavery would have died out soon enough anyway. Abe Lincoln primarily freed the slaves to fuck with the rebels.

    WSS

    History can be harsh but this is actually what Lincoln said:

    "If I could save the Union without freeing any slave I would do it, and if I could save it by freeing all the slaves I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone I would also do that."

  • Keep in mind that the South could have remained in the union and kept their slaves as long as the north got their cut of the cotton money. Slavery would have died out soon enough anyway. Abe Lincoln primarily freed the slaves to fuck with the rebels.

    WSS

    @westside-steve said:

    Keep in mind that the South could have remained in the union and kept their slaves as long as the north got their cut of the cotton money. Slavery would have died out soon enough anyway. Abe Lincoln primarily freed the slaves to fuck with the rebels.

    WSS

    Keep in mind that westward expansion and the future of free or slave states in new territories was a key factor that had its origins in the Missouri Compromise of 1820. The Kansas-Nebraska Act in 1854 (I believe) repealed the Missouri Compromise and allowed future territories to vote to determine their free or slave status. The resulting violence in "Bleeding Kansas" was a direct precursor of the Civil War in my view.

    Given those decades of history, I do not believe that slavery would have died out "soon enough." The war kicked off with the slave and free states in somewhat of a "balance" in the houses of government. The south knew that any legislative imbalance that was not in their favor meant the end of slavery, so they tried to protect it. Like I said above, there was no foreseeable economic future without slavery, and to prove it, the South gave up about 300,000 lives to try to secure that future. I do not believe that they could have motivated their populace and troops without that vision.

  • Frankly I don't think you are taking a realistic view of world history. Slavery was more and more unacceptable and would continue that way in the United States as it had in Europe. Plus it was increasingly dangerous and very expensive. And automation was certainly making it obsolete little by little. But you can read Lincoln's own words about his views on saving the union and freeing the slaves.

    WSS

  • Not only that but as cotton was replaced by oil as the most valuable commodity in the United States less and less human effort was needed to reap it.

    That was the turn of the century.

    All this shit is being kept alive for one reason and that's so the Democrats can get one of their biggest voting blocs back on the reservation.

    And while the left screams about Russia it's good to remember they are still happy to do business with countries that still involve themselves in slavery.

    WSS

  • Frankly I don't think you are taking a realistic view of world history. Slavery was more and more unacceptable and would continue that way in the United States as it had in Europe. Plus it was increasingly dangerous and very expensive. And automation was certainly making it obsolete little by little. But you can read Lincoln's own words about his views on saving the union and freeing the slaves.

    WSS

    @westside-steve said:

    Frankly I don't think you are taking a realistic view of world history. Slavery was more and more unacceptable and would continue that way in the United States as it had in Europe. Plus it was increasingly dangerous and very expensive. And automation was certainly making it obsolete little by little. But you can read Lincoln's own words about his views on saving the union and freeing the slaves.

    WSS

    Actually, my understanding is based in fact. I understand the pressure to drop slavery that existed at the time from Europe and elsewhere. I also understand that it was necessary to pry it from the cold, dead hands of the people that held on to it. Like I said, the war erupted because the balance of power regarding slavery was due to be potentially upset by the direct threat of adding more slave or free states. So, I am referring to the synchronic forces in play, while you seem to prefer to emphasize the diachronic forces. It's a classic tit for tat in historical discussions, or so I learned in my doctoral history courses at OSU. 🙂

  • @westside-steve said:

    Frankly I don't think you are taking a realistic view of world history. Slavery was more and more unacceptable and would continue that way in the United States as it had in Europe. Plus it was increasingly dangerous and very expensive. And automation was certainly making it obsolete little by little. But you can read Lincoln's own words about his views on saving the union and freeing the slaves.

    WSS

    Actually, my understanding is based in fact. I understand the pressure to drop slavery that existed at the time from Europe and elsewhere. I also understand that it was necessary to pry it from the cold, dead hands of the people that held on to it. Like I said, the war erupted because the balance of power regarding slavery was due to be potentially upset by the direct threat of adding more slave or free states. So, I am referring to the synchronic forces in play, while you seem to prefer to emphasize the diachronic forces. It's a classic tit for tat in historical discussions, or so I learned in my doctoral history courses at OSU. 🙂

    @sober-poet said:

    Actually, my understanding is based in fact. I understand the pressure to drop slavery that existed at the time from Europe and elsewhere. I also understand that it was necessary to pry it from the cold, dead hands of the people that held on to it. Like I said, the war erupted because the balance of power regarding slavery was due to be potentially upset by the direct threat of adding more slave or free states. So, I am referring to the synchronic forces in play, while you seem to prefer to emphasize the diachronic forces. It's a classic tit for tat in historical discussions, or so I learned in my doctoral history courses at OSU. 🙂

    Your assessment is not based on fact because those circumstances never came to pass. Your assessment is based on speculation.

    And the speculation isn't even based on fact.

    As I said before and you choose to ignore oil would soon replace cotton as the commodity of the day. The need for human labor would drop drastically. So why bear the expense and danger of keeping slaves?

    WSS

  • Such moral, good people on here.............

  • Fake news.

  • Fake news.

    @diehardbrownsfan said:

    Fake news.

    No it is not fake news.

  • @diehardbrownsfan said:

    Fake news.

    No it is not fake news.

    @texasag1969 said:

    No it is not fake news.

    Actually the disgusting part is that the man said absolutely nothing offensive. Yes the violence was caused by two groups clashing one that came with a permit and the other with baseball bats to attack the others. One fucking asshole came down from Ohio, probably a Michigan fan seeing as how he's from Toledo, and killed a person and he should be hanged for it. But to say that there's violence on both sides is extremely true.

    Now these so-called Business Leaders are again scared shitless of people like Al Sharpton so they are falling all over themselves to do the wrong thing. Fuck them.

    They are afraid of their own shadows and being called racists by some of the worst racists in the world. It really does suck and you really should understand it.

    WSS

  • @diehardbrownsfan said:

    Fake news.

    No it is not fake news.

    @texasag1969 said:

    No it is not fake news.

    Fuck these CEO's.

  • Trump is just speaking the plain truth that the violence was on both sides. The Trump haters are going to pick him apart whatever he says. Trump specifically calls out the neo nazis and KKK as being evil and I don't know what else he can do or say to denounce them.

    One thing I think Trump didn't say very well was that there were good people on both sides. I am sure he was meaning those people who are not racists but want the confederate statues to remain for heritage/historical reasons and have nothing to do with the white supremacist groups. He should have made that more clear as there are no good people in the KKK, white supremacist groups or neo nazis.

  • @baconhound said:

    Obama not mentioning Islamic Terrorism and more stringently denouncing violence against law enforcement as retaliation. Trump not condemning the "white nationalist" movement as racist and not referring to the attack as domestic terrorism.

    All wrong in my book.

    And yet not only did he not condemn BLM after police officers were murdered by them but he invited the motherfuckers to the White House and Hillary dragged them up on stage with her.

    WSS

    @westside-steve said:

    And yet not only did he not condemn BLM after police officers were murdered by them but he invited the motherfuckers to the White House and Hillary dragged them up on stage with her.

    WSS

    Again not defending it. But again why does Obama's missteps excuse Trump"s?

  • @texasag1969 said:

    No it is not fake news.

    Actually the disgusting part is that the man said absolutely nothing offensive. Yes the violence was caused by two groups clashing one that came with a permit and the other with baseball bats to attack the others. One fucking asshole came down from Ohio, probably a Michigan fan seeing as how he's from Toledo, and killed a person and he should be hanged for it. But to say that there's violence on both sides is extremely true.

    Now these so-called Business Leaders are again scared shitless of people like Al Sharpton so they are falling all over themselves to do the wrong thing. Fuck them.

    They are afraid of their own shadows and being called racists by some of the worst racists in the world. It really does suck and you really should understand it.

    WSS

    @westside-steve said:

    Actually the disgusting part is that the man said absolutely nothing offensive. Yes the violence was caused by two groups clashing one that came with a permit and the other with baseball bats to attack the others. One fucking asshole came down from Ohio, probably a Michigan fan seeing as how he's from Toledo, and killed a person and he should be hanged for it. But to say that there's violence on both sides is extremely true.

    Now these so-called Business Leaders are again scared shitless of people like Al Sharpton so they are falling all over themselves to do the wrong thing. Fuck them.

    They are afraid of their own shadows and being called racists by some of the worst racists in the world. It really does suck and you really should understand it.

    WSS

    Came with a permit... And Shields and clubs and guns

  • @westside-steve said:

    Actually the disgusting part is that the man said absolutely nothing offensive. Yes the violence was caused by two groups clashing one that came with a permit and the other with baseball bats to attack the others. One fucking asshole came down from Ohio, probably a Michigan fan seeing as how he's from Toledo, and killed a person and he should be hanged for it. But to say that there's violence on both sides is extremely true.

    Now these so-called Business Leaders are again scared shitless of people like Al Sharpton so they are falling all over themselves to do the wrong thing. Fuck them.

    They are afraid of their own shadows and being called racists by some of the worst racists in the world. It really does suck and you really should understand it.

    WSS

    Came with a permit... And Shields and clubs and guns

    @mld-woody said:

    Came with a permit... And Shields and clubs and guns

    Gotta love the posters in this board. Trump could say the sun rises in the west and sets in the east and they'd say well Obamacare is ruining the middle class. SMH

  • Trump is just speaking the plain truth that the violence was on both sides. The Trump haters are going to pick him apart whatever he says. Trump specifically calls out the neo nazis and KKK as being evil and I don't know what else he can do or say to denounce them.

    One thing I think Trump didn't say very well was that there were good people on both sides. I am sure he was meaning those people who are not racists but want the confederate statues to remain for heritage/historical reasons and have nothing to do with the white supremacist groups. He should have made that more clear as there are no good people in the KKK, white supremacist groups or neo nazis.

    @oldbrownsfan said:

    One thing I think Trump didn't say very well was that there were good people on both sides. I am sure he was meaning those people who are not racists but want the confederate statues to remain for heritage/historical reasons and have nothing to do with the white supremacist groups. He should have made that more clear as there are no good people in the KKK, white supremacist groups or neo nazis.

    More unfortunately he was speaking specifically about the Friday night torchlight rally when talking about good people within that march who just want the statues of our heritage to remain. And anyone with a lick of sense that actually fit that bill would have just left when the Nazi chants started. So I think he is dead wrong that there were any good people there interested only in preserving history. I qualify 3 times over to join the Sons of the Confederacy, but I have no doubt this is just a cover for a racist group and not history buffs per se. So I don't join and I don't attend though I love reading Civil War history. No "good people" with a brain would ever find themselves marching in torchlight parades like Friday's and no one with a brain would think there were any good people there either.

  • clueless in the northeast.....

  • Look, the election of Donald Trump didn't create the Left's hate. It simply revealed it..