Why not Minkah at #1
-
I'm sorry Gip, but if the Browns get cute and skip QB with their 1st pick again I'm going to officially go oobatz.
Totally on the Fitzpatrick bandwagon though.
Well....it would not be getting cute if they skipped the QB and went for the BPA...if the QBs on the board are, as I said, a mixed bag.
And answer me this: by your analysis then the Browns "got cute" last year by skipping the QB (twice). Two QBs last year that I think perhaps are better than the Jambalaya at QBs we have this year.
Well....it would not be getting cute if they skipped the QB and went for the BPA...if the QBs on the board are, as I said, a mixed bag.
And answer me this: by your analysis then the Browns "got cute" last year by skipping the QB (twice). Two QBs last year that I think perhaps are better than the Jambalaya at QBs we have this year.
before last years draft your jambalaya reference could also been used and so ya I'm saying to draft Darnold to which we could develop into a starting QB,this team needs a freaking direction and drafting Darnold would do that drafting a db from bama doesn't move the needle
-
so looking back would you still take garrett over Watson or trubisky
If you really want me to look back....I take Bosa the year before....and then I go for MT. But that is water over the dam.
-
I want a vet QB then that lets us take Minkah at 1 and Barkley at 4, no QB in this years draft is a top 5 pick IMO
I want a vet QB then that lets us take Minkah at 1 and Barkley at 4, no QB in this years draft is a top 5 pick IMO
I could live with that. Do you see any real franchise QBs in 2018? What about 2019?
GO BUCKEYES, BROWNS, INDIANS, CAVS, YSU, NAVY and yes I like ND! -
Well....it would not be getting cute if they skipped the QB and went for the BPA...if the QBs on the board are, as I said, a mixed bag.
And answer me this: by your analysis then the Browns "got cute" last year by skipping the QB (twice). Two QBs last year that I think perhaps are better than the Jambalaya at QBs we have this year.
before last years draft your jambalaya reference could also been used and so ya I'm saying to draft Darnold to which we could develop into a starting QB,this team needs a freaking direction and drafting Darnold would do that drafting a db from bama doesn't move the needle
before last years draft your jambalaya reference could also been used and so ya I'm saying to draft Darnold to which we could develop into a starting QB,this team needs a freaking direction and drafting Darnold would do that drafting a db from bama doesn't move the needle
If you think that Darnold is the be all end all of the QBs available...that he is John Elway/Peyton Manning/Andrew Luck The Next Generation then you surely go for him. But I hear NO ONE saying anything remotely like that about him. Are you hearing that?
(In fact... he may be sitting there at #4....I hear about Rosen being more often highly ranked)
And I don't care about moving any needles. What needle are you wanting moved? TV ratings? i want wins.
-
What do you think Carson Wentz was rated as an overall prospect when he entered? Or Goff?
Why do I have to think about that? Why not just tell me. Use whatever source you want.
Then explain why this is relevant here.
Why do I have to think about that? Why not just tell me. Use whatever source you want.
Then explain why this is relevant here.
Because before the draft, there might have been a good chance neither were a top 10 overall prospect. Drafted #1 and 2, because they are QBs, but neither were considered "can't miss QBs".
Two years later would anyone complain about where they were taken?
Which speaks directly to your point.
Relevant enough?
-
I could live with that. Do you see any real franchise QBs in 2018? What about 2019?
Lets not even talk about 2019. Hell, my theory is that it may certainly be possible that you could get your best QB coming out of this draft somewhere down the line....2d 3rd round. You know...like a Russell Wilson. I don't predict it....just saying it is possible.
-
before last years draft your jambalaya reference could also been used and so ya I'm saying to draft Darnold to which we could develop into a starting QB,this team needs a freaking direction and drafting Darnold would do that drafting a db from bama doesn't move the needle
If you think that Darnold is the be all end all of the QBs available...that he is John Elway/Peyton Manning/Andrew Luck The Next Generation then you surely go for him. But I hear NO ONE saying anything remotely like that about him. Are you hearing that?
(In fact... he may be sitting there at #4....I hear about Rosen being more often highly ranked)
And I don't care about moving any needles. What needle are you wanting moved? TV ratings? i want wins.
If you think that Darnold is the be all end all of the QBs available...that he is John Elway/Peyton Manning/Andrew Luck The Next Generation then you surely go for him. But I hear NO ONE saying anything remotely like that about him. Are you hearing that?
And I don't care about moving any needles. What needle are you wanting moved? TV ratings? i want wins.
You better have the #1 pick to get one of the above super QBs or prepare to gut your draft to trade up. Throw in Marino and Aikman on that list also.
GO BUCKEYES, BROWNS, INDIANS, CAVS, YSU, NAVY and yes I like ND! -
I could live with that. Do you see any real franchise QBs in 2018? What about 2019?
Lets not even talk about 2019. Hell, my theory is that it may certainly be possible that you could get your best QB coming out of this draft somewhere down the line....2d 3rd round. You know...like a Russell Wilson. I don't predict it....just saying it is possible.
Lets not even talk about 2019. Hell, my theory is that it may certainly be possible that you could get your best QB coming out of this draft somewhere down the line....2d 3rd round. You know...like a Russell Wilson. I don't predict it....just saying it is possible.
I'm not going to research it, but I'd say that from current NFL QBs, how many were taken in first round? And how many you'd say they are good. A Russell Wilson appears once in 5-10 years. A Brady in the 6th once in a lifetime.
-
Why do I have to think about that? Why not just tell me. Use whatever source you want.
Then explain why this is relevant here.
Because before the draft, there might have been a good chance neither were a top 10 overall prospect. Drafted #1 and 2, because they are QBs, but neither were considered "can't miss QBs".
Two years later would anyone complain about where they were taken?
Which speaks directly to your point.
Relevant enough?
Because before the draft, there might have been a good chance neither were a top 10 overall prospect. Drafted #1 and 2, because they are QBs, but neither were considered "can't miss QBs".
Two years later would anyone complain about where they were taken?
Which speaks directly to your point.
Relevant enough?
Possibly. But you are trying to make future predictions based on past events. (I know, I do it all the time).
All I am saying is that very few actual "rankings of talent" put any of these guys as the best prospects in this draft. Only the Mocks do that. And maybe you are right...perhaps it could be proven a few years down the road that these top QBs taken become the Eli/BR/Rivers of this year. Or, as I said, they could be the Ponders/Lockers/Gabberts. We don't know.
-
I could live with that. Do you see any real franchise QBs in 2018? What about 2019?
Lets not even talk about 2019. Hell, my theory is that it may certainly be possible that you could get your best QB coming out of this draft somewhere down the line....2d 3rd round. You know...like a Russell Wilson. I don't predict it....just saying it is possible.
Lets not even talk about 2019. Hell, my theory is that it may certainly be possible that you could get your best QB coming out of this draft somewhere down the line....2d 3rd round. You know...like a Russell Wilson. I don't predict it....just saying it is possible.
True in a way plus you might not (hopefully) have the #1, 2, 3 picks anyhow......but a few guesses might be interesting just to compare with 2018.
-
every mock draft has rosen and Donald going #1 and #2 only walters has barkley going #1 which they say it could be Donald
we have to go QB drafting a db is not going to win games
-
If you think that Darnold is the be all end all of the QBs available...that he is John Elway/Peyton Manning/Andrew Luck The Next Generation then you surely go for him. But I hear NO ONE saying anything remotely like that about him. Are you hearing that?
And I don't care about moving any needles. What needle are you wanting moved? TV ratings? i want wins.
You better have the #1 pick to get one of the above super QBs or prepare to gut your draft to trade up. Throw in Marino and Aikman on that list also.
You better have the #1 pick to get one of the above super QBs or prepare to gut your draft to trade up. Throw in Marino and Aikman on that list also.
Marino was the #27 pick in the draft. 5 others were taken before him...but he can arguably be considered the best of that group...though you do have Elway and Kelly in there.
Do you think there is a #27 Marino that could go this year? It is certainly possible.
Do you think that as many as 5-6 will go in round one? That has only happened twice in the common draft era...as many as 5 QBs taken. 1983 and 1999.
1983 produced 3 HOFers, one very good one (O/Brien), one mediocre (Eason)..and one bust (Blackledge). 1999 produced one borderline HOF in McNabb. One pretty good one in Culpepper. Another fairly good one imo...whose career was cut short by injury: Couch, and two complete busts: Akili and McCown.
-
every mock draft has rosen and Donald going #1 and #2 only walters has barkley going #1 which they say it could be Donald
we have to go QB drafting a db is not going to win games
-
You better have the #1 pick to get one of the above super QBs or prepare to gut your draft to trade up. Throw in Marino and Aikman on that list also.
Marino was the #27 pick in the draft. 5 others were taken before him...but he can arguably be considered the best of that group...though you do have Elway and Kelly in there.
Do you think there is a #27 Marino that could go this year? It is certainly possible.
Do you think that as many as 5-6 will go in round one? That has only happened twice in the common draft era...as many as 5 QBs taken. 1983 and 1999.
1983 produced 3 HOFers, one very good one (O/Brien), one mediocre (Eason)..and one bust (Blackledge). 1999 produced one borderline HOF in McNabb. One pretty good one in Culpepper. Another fairly good one imo...whose career was cut short by injury: Couch, and two complete busts: Akili and McCown.
Marino was the #27 pick in the draft. 5 others were taken before him...but he can arguably be considered the best of that group...though you do have Elway and Kelly in there.
Do you think there is a #27 Marino that could go this year? It is certainly possible.
Do you think that as many as 5-6 will go in round one? That has only happened twice in the common draft era...as many as 5 QBs taken. 1983 and 1999.
1983 produced 3 HOFers, one very good one (O/Brien), one mediocre (Eason)..and one bust (Blackledge). 1999 produced one borderline HOF in McNabb. One pretty good one in Culpepper. Another fairly good one imo...whose career was cut short by injury: Couch, and two complete busts: Akili and McCown.
Marino was in the 1983 best ever QB draft hard to make the top 10 there! PLUS the drug rumours (some said planted) dropped Marino but Don Shula didn't buy it.
GO BUCKEYES, BROWNS, INDIANS, CAVS, YSU, NAVY and yes I like ND! -
-
guess we have a long time to talk about it
99 bottles of beer on the wall, 99 bottles of beer. Take one down and pass it around
98 bottles of beer on the wall. 98 bottles of beer on the wall, 98 bottles of beer. Take one down and pass it around,
97 bottles of beer on the wall.97 bottles of beer on the wall, 97 bottles of beer. Take one down and pass it around, 96 bottles of beer on the wall.........v
Yeah the Indians will be playing before long.
-
Marino was the #27 pick in the draft. 5 others were taken before him...but he can arguably be considered the best of that group...though you do have Elway and Kelly in there.
Do you think there is a #27 Marino that could go this year? It is certainly possible.
Do you think that as many as 5-6 will go in round one? That has only happened twice in the common draft era...as many as 5 QBs taken. 1983 and 1999.
1983 produced 3 HOFers, one very good one (O/Brien), one mediocre (Eason)..and one bust (Blackledge). 1999 produced one borderline HOF in McNabb. One pretty good one in Culpepper. Another fairly good one imo...whose career was cut short by injury: Couch, and two complete busts: Akili and McCown.
Marino was in the 1983 best ever QB draft hard to make the top 10 there! PLUS the drug rumours (some said planted) dropped Marino but Don Shula didn't buy it.
Marino was in the 1983 best ever QB draft hard to make the top 10 there! PLUS the drug rumours (some said planted) dropped Marino but Don Shula didn't buy it.
thing is times have changed since then so many sports channels national sports radio (cough cough) the internet a lot of info out there some true some not but it usually gets figured out on message boards like these
-
I'll start to count draft-related threads from now on and enjoy the artillery sound.
I am going to do some pop corn. Wanna some?
99 bottles of beer on the wall, 99 bottles of beer. Take one down and pass it around
98 bottles of beer on the wall. 98 bottles of beer on the wall, 98 bottles of beer. Take one down and pass it around,
97 bottles of beer on the wall.97 bottles of beer on the wall, 97 bottles of beer. Take one down and pass it around, 96 bottles of beer on the wall.........v
Yeah the Indians will be playing before long.
oh hell yes popcorn and beer and drunken bantering gotta love it
-
Lets not even talk about 2019. Hell, my theory is that it may certainly be possible that you could get your best QB coming out of this draft somewhere down the line....2d 3rd round. You know...like a Russell Wilson. I don't predict it....just saying it is possible.
I'm not going to research it, but I'd say that from current NFL QBs, how many were taken in first round? And how many you'd say they are good. A Russell Wilson appears once in 5-10 years. A Brady in the 6th once in a lifetime.
I'm not going to research it, but I'd say that from current NFL QBs, how many were taken in first round? And how many you'd say they are good. A Russell Wilson appears once in 5-10 years. A Brady in the 6th once in a lifetime.
Not sure what you are asking? Are you asking where, of the starting QBs on the 32 teams this past year, did they get drafted?
I know at least about half of them were 1st rounders. Just off the top of my head:
Goff #1 overall
Rivers #4
Palmer #1...now retired
Watson #10
Alex Smith #1
Rodgers (injured like #24..not sure about Hundley)
Trubisky #2
Stafford #1
Mariota #2
Ryan #3
Newton #1
Bortles #3
Cutler mid 1st...like #11
Winston #1
Flaco...like #18 I think
Ben R. #11
Wentz #2
Eli #1
Luck #1 injured
Others:
Wilson 3rd round
Carr 2d round
Garrapolo 2d
Prescott 4th round
Keenum: UDFA
Brees 2d (#32...which was 2d at the time)
Brissett...not sure...mid rounder
Kizer 2d
Dalton 2d
Cousins 4th
Taylor...not sure mid rounder?
Brady 6th
And if you can tell me who the Jets and Broncos started...I guess I may be able to tell what round they came in. Siemian was like 7th round. Bryce Petty was 3rd. Osweiler was 2d or 3rd.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login