Bold idea that would change the landscape of sports in Cleveland
-
Apparently Dan Gilbert was on 92.3 this morning, I had just missed his interview when I turned it on at 7:25am... From the interview, which Gilbert talked about the state of downtown Cleveland in relation to it's sports teams, Daryl Ruiter came up with a bold plan... What do you think of it?
1. Tear down CSU's Wolstein Center on the near east side of downtown. It has become somewhat of a white elephant.
2. Build a smaller, more intimate ballpark for the Indians. Think a 32,000-34,000 seat PNC Field. Upper deck that hugs the playing field, unlike Progressive Field. Half the amount of luxury boxes.
3. Tear down Progressive Field, build a new retractable dome for the Browns in its spot. Go after the Super Bowl, NCAA Final Four, Big Ten Championship, etc...
4. Tear down First Energy Stadium, develop (finally) the lakefront. Haslam has made a point a few times about how much money is poured into the stadium there because the damage it takes from being on the lakefront. This is a great piece of real estate, Cleveland needs to finally take advantage of its lakefront.
What say you?
Apparently Dan Gilbert was on 92.3 this morning, I had just missed his interview when I turned it on at 7:25am... From the interview, which Gilbert talked about the state of downtown Cleveland in relation to it's sports teams, Daryl Ruiter came up with a bold plan... What do you think of it?
1. Tear down CSU's Wolstein Center on the near east side of downtown. It has become somewhat of a white elephant.
2. Build a smaller, more intimate ballpark for the Indians. Think a 32,000-34,000 seat PNC Field. Upper deck that hugs the playing field, unlike Progressive Field. Half the amount of luxury boxes.
3. Tear down Progressive Field, build a new retractable dome for the Browns in its spot. Go after the Super Bowl, NCAA Final Four, Big Ten Championship, etc...
4. Tear down First Energy Stadium, develop (finally) the lakefront. Haslam has made a point a few times about how much money is poured into the stadium there because the damage it takes from being on the lakefront. This is a great piece of real estate, Cleveland needs to finally take advantage of its lakefront.
What say you?
How many packs of smokes and bottles are you gonna tax?
tear downs $$
new builds $$$$$$
and you just put a ton of money in First energy and not too long ago the Prog the new scoreboard etc
before they built first energy I was screaming for a dome for the very reasons brought up. Super Bowl, NCAA other big events. We doubled down and remodeled it now too.
too late -
Apparently Dan Gilbert was on 92.3 this morning, I had just missed his interview when I turned it on at 7:25am... From the interview, which Gilbert talked about the state of downtown Cleveland in relation to it's sports teams, Daryl Ruiter came up with a bold plan... What do you think of it?
1. Tear down CSU's Wolstein Center on the near east side of downtown. It has become somewhat of a white elephant.
2. Build a smaller, more intimate ballpark for the Indians. Think a 32,000-34,000 seat PNC Field. Upper deck that hugs the playing field, unlike Progressive Field. Half the amount of luxury boxes.
3. Tear down Progressive Field, build a new retractable dome for the Browns in its spot. Go after the Super Bowl, NCAA Final Four, Big Ten Championship, etc...
4. Tear down First Energy Stadium, develop (finally) the lakefront. Haslam has made a point a few times about how much money is poured into the stadium there because the damage it takes from being on the lakefront. This is a great piece of real estate, Cleveland needs to finally take advantage of its lakefront.
What say you?
How many packs of smokes and bottles are you gonna tax?
tear downs $$
new builds $$$$$$
and you just put a ton of money in First energy and not too long ago the Prog the new scoreboard etc
before they built first energy I was screaming for a dome for the very reasons brought up. Super Bowl, NCAA other big events. We doubled down and remodeled it now too.
too lateHow many packs of smokes and bottles are you gonna tax?
tear downs $$
new builds $$$$$$
and you just put a ton of money in First energy and not too long ago the Prog the new scoreboard etc
before they built first energy I was screaming for a dome for the very reasons brought up. Super Bowl, NCAA other big events. We doubled down and remodeled it now too.
too lateI think it's a pipe dream too...
Someday the Browns will be playing in a retractable dome. I have a feeling if the Haslams are around for the long term, they'll demand an upgrade.
I still think the next ballpark the Indians play in won't be in Cleveland.
-
How many packs of smokes and bottles are you gonna tax?
tear downs $$
new builds $$$$$$
and you just put a ton of money in First energy and not too long ago the Prog the new scoreboard etc
before they built first energy I was screaming for a dome for the very reasons brought up. Super Bowl, NCAA other big events. We doubled down and remodeled it now too.
too lateI think it's a pipe dream too...
Someday the Browns will be playing in a retractable dome. I have a feeling if the Haslams are around for the long term, they'll demand an upgrade.
I still think the next ballpark the Indians play in won't be in Cleveland.
I think it's a pipe dream too...
Someday the Browns will be playing in a retractable dome. I have a feeling if the Haslams are around for the long term, they'll demand an upgrade.
I still think the next ballpark the Indians play in won't be in Cleveland.
The tribes ballpark can last for another 50 or more years
-
Sounds dumb to me...
I noticed that Gilbert commented on every franchise's home other than his.
I love the Jake...
I like that Browns Stadium was built on the site of old Muni...
I agree with you on Progressive Field, but not on First Energy. There is no bigger waste of money and space than an open-air football stadium, especially in the North. Then you add the fact that being on the lakefront makes it very expensive to maintain, and that prime real estate is wasted for 10 dates a year, plus the occasional concert. Having a retractable dome would open up the ability for Cleveland to host huge events like the Super Bowl, NCAA Final Four, etc... All that means more to me that this mediocre stadium sitting on the site of old Cleveland Stadium, IMO....
I would imagine the reason Gilbert didn't comment on the home of the Cavs is because the home of the Cavs just underwent an enormous facelift.
I agree with you on Progressive Field, but not on First Energy. There is no bigger waste of money and space than an open-air football stadium, especially in the North.
Put a lid on that sucker and you guys will finally be able to see the greatest sport ever.....
Supercross baby.
-
Less for baseball and more for football?
Hell yeah let's do it.
Jump in front of the inevitable decline in baseball and move it towards more football. Become a venue for cold weather games (bowls, XFL, etc)
Shut up soccer fag.
Shut up
soccersupercross fag."When you have a shared vision it is a lot easier to make unpopular decisions." - Paul DePodesta "When you win, say nothing. When you lose, say less." - Paul Brown Complete 2017 Browns Board Mock: http://thebrownsboard.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=46196 -
Shut up
soccersupercross fag. -
And how are they (whomever) going to do the financing for all of this ?
I do believe in looking ahead and creative thinking but are the CBS and Progressive beyond their useful lives ?
And how are they (whomever) going to do the financing for all of this ?
I do believe in looking ahead and creative thinking but are the CBS and Progressive beyond their useful lives ?
Put a winning team on the field, and scew the dome. Cold weather? New England, Green Bay, Pittsburgh, and Kansas City. Any of those cities screaming for a dome? Don't think so. Only the wimps. It's bullshit, you can sit out in 10 degree weather for hours and be totally comfortable- if you know how to dress for it.
FWIW, I've been to several domed venues. If that's the ambiance you want, I suggest you stay home, save your money, and watch the game on the tube. Because that's what you get.
Domed stadium for the Browns? Just let Dan and Jimmy toss in a billion each, and no problem. That's the only way it's happening in Cleveland.
The tribes ballpark can last for another 50 or more years
Yeah Gip, they should tear down those Fenway and Wrigley mausoleums too.
-
I'll not argue that a retractable dome may bring Super Bowls & other events to Cleveland but, as a 73 year old Browns' Fan & Season Ticket Member, I prefer football played "in the elements". I really can't imagine sitting "inside" at a football game. It just doesn't seem natural to me.
Bottom line is that, no matter what, I'm all in as a Browns' Fan for the rest of my life.
Mike
-
I'll not argue that a retractable dome may bring Super Bowls & other events to Cleveland but, as a 73 year old Browns' Fan & Season Ticket Member, I prefer football played "in the elements". I really can't imagine sitting "inside" at a football game. It just doesn't seem natural to me.
Bottom line is that, no matter what, I'm all in as a Browns' Fan for the rest of my life.
Mike
I'll not argue that a retractable dome may bring Super Bowls & other events to Cleveland but, as a 73 year old Browns' Fan & Season Ticket Member, I prefer football played "in the elements". I really can't imagine sitting "inside" at a football game. It just doesn't seem natural to me.
Bottom line is that, no matter what, I'm all in as a Browns' Fan for the rest of my life.
Mike
Agree 100%. Dress for the tailgate and weather. Yeah, those windy days can be tough, but if we are still here after all the years of crap, we aren't going anywhere.
In 2007 I took my (at the time) 12 year old son to St. Louis to watch the Browns/Rams game. It was boring sitting in a dome.Felt like a movie theater.
Went to Jerry's Palace in 2012, Browns/Cowboys. While it's not a true "dome," it is pretty darn close. Honestly, I wasn't impressed with that stadium at all. I found myself looking at the giant TV too much (and bitching about Brandon Weeden lol...who throws a ball into the bleachers on 4th and goal from the 3?).
Went to Phoenix this year, Browns/Cardinals. Funny, I completely agree they need a dome, it's way to hot down there, but once again, just an odd atmosphere.
Our problem in Cleveland is simply our sports teams owners are all mixed up. Dolan needs to own an NBA or NFL team with a salary cap. Gilbert or Haslam should own the Tribe, they'd ante up for Lindor.
-
I'll not argue that a retractable dome may bring Super Bowls & other events to Cleveland but, as a 73 year old Browns' Fan & Season Ticket Member, I prefer football played "in the elements". I really can't imagine sitting "inside" at a football game. It just doesn't seem natural to me.
Bottom line is that, no matter what, I'm all in as a Browns' Fan for the rest of my life.
Mike
Agree 100%. Dress for the tailgate and weather. Yeah, those windy days can be tough, but if we are still here after all the years of crap, we aren't going anywhere.
In 2007 I took my (at the time) 12 year old son to St. Louis to watch the Browns/Rams game. It was boring sitting in a dome.Felt like a movie theater.
Went to Jerry's Palace in 2012, Browns/Cowboys. While it's not a true "dome," it is pretty darn close. Honestly, I wasn't impressed with that stadium at all. I found myself looking at the giant TV too much (and bitching about Brandon Weeden lol...who throws a ball into the bleachers on 4th and goal from the 3?).
Went to Phoenix this year, Browns/Cardinals. Funny, I completely agree they need a dome, it's way to hot down there, but once again, just an odd atmosphere.
Our problem in Cleveland is simply our sports teams owners are all mixed up. Dolan needs to own an NBA or NFL team with a salary cap. Gilbert or Haslam should own the Tribe, they'd ante up for Lindor.
Agree 100%. Dress for the tailgate and weather. Yeah, those windy days can be tough, but if we are still here after all the years of crap, we aren't going anywhere.
In 2007 I took my (at the time) 12 year old son to St. Louis to watch the Browns/Rams game. It was boring sitting in a dome.Felt like a movie theater.
Went to Jerry's Palace in 2012, Browns/Cowboys. While it's not a true "dome," it is pretty darn close. Honestly, I wasn't impressed with that stadium at all. I found myself looking at the giant TV too much (and bitching about Brandon Weeden lol...who throws a ball into the bleachers on 4th and goal from the 3?).
Went to Phoenix this year, Browns/Cardinals. Funny, I completely agree they need a dome, it's way to hot down there, but once again, just an odd atmosphere.
Our problem in Cleveland is simply our sports teams owners are all mixed up. Dolan needs to own an NBA or NFL team with a salary cap. Gilbert or Haslam should own the Tribe, they'd ante up for Lindor.
Great post Bob!! Your last statements about owners & Lindor are PERFECT!!
Mike
-
Shut up
soccersupercross fag.Did you not get the memo on immature name-calling, Tour? ?
The original post is still standing, apparently that stand is on a case-by-case situation.
-
Football indoors sucks, especially for Browns fans used to football being played in the mud and snow.
But financially there is nothing more idiotic than building an astronomically expensive building that gets used 12 or so times a year, especially when it sits on prime real estate.
-
I agree with you on Progressive Field, but not on First Energy. There is no bigger waste of money and space than an open-air football stadium, especially in the North.
Put a lid on that sucker and you guys will finally be able to see the greatest sport ever.....
Supercross baby.
Put a lid on that sucker and you guys will finally be able to see the greatest sport ever.....
Supercross baby.
Can’t they do that outdoors
-
Sounds dumb to me...
I noticed that Gilbert commented on every franchise's home other than his.
I love the Jake...
I like that Browns Stadium was built on the site of old Muni...
Sounds dumb to me...
I noticed that Gilbert commented on every franchise's home other than his.
I love the Jake...
I like that Browns Stadium was built on the site of old Muni...
Rather than ripping down Browns Stadium long before it's a fossil, couldn't they just add a retractable roof to it?
If we're going to get really open-minded here, why not bring Paul Brown's franchise here for the 8 games Cleveland plays away - so the football fans in Ohio finally have a chance to see 6-8 wins in the stadium on Lake Erie? Paul Brown was the only good owner we've had and same with Cincy. Cincy wanted to keep the orange and brown colors and tradition Paul started so why not do so in the only place Paul Brown won multiple Pro Football Championships? Cincy can change their name to the Ohio Junior Varsity.
When Roger finally gets his dream of putting another NFL franchise in London or Toronto or Mexico - we can finally combine the 2 Ohio teams (that would already be playing here) and put Mike Brown/family out of their misery of tarnishing what Paul started. That, or we could have a contest to see what ownership deserves the blended teams by then... If they both keep on keepin on - let the owner's spouses mud wrestle for it. Loser at least gets the money the winner has to pay in buy-out. The Winner gets to keep playing Charlie Brown trying to kick the game winning points with Lucy holding. The fans get to keep reminding themselves how much they appreciate Ohio State - where winning is a tradition!
-
Sounds dumb to me...
I noticed that Gilbert commented on every franchise's home other than his.
I love the Jake...
I like that Browns Stadium was built on the site of old Muni...
Rather than ripping down Browns Stadium long before it's a fossil, couldn't they just add a retractable roof to it?
If we're going to get really open-minded here, why not bring Paul Brown's franchise here for the 8 games Cleveland plays away - so the football fans in Ohio finally have a chance to see 6-8 wins in the stadium on Lake Erie? Paul Brown was the only good owner we've had and same with Cincy. Cincy wanted to keep the orange and brown colors and tradition Paul started so why not do so in the only place Paul Brown won multiple Pro Football Championships? Cincy can change their name to the Ohio Junior Varsity.
When Roger finally gets his dream of putting another NFL franchise in London or Toronto or Mexico - we can finally combine the 2 Ohio teams (that would already be playing here) and put Mike Brown/family out of their misery of tarnishing what Paul started. That, or we could have a contest to see what ownership deserves the blended teams by then... If they both keep on keepin on - let the owner's spouses mud wrestle for it. Loser at least gets the money the winner has to pay in buy-out. The Winner gets to keep playing Charlie Brown trying to kick the game winning points with Lucy holding. The fans get to keep reminding themselves how much they appreciate Ohio State - where winning is a tradition!
Rather than ripping down Browns Stadium long before it's a fossil, couldn't they just add a retractable roof to it?
If we're going to get really open-minded here, why not bring Paul Brown's franchise here for the 8 games Cleveland plays away - so the football fans in Ohio finally have a chance to see 6-8 wins in the stadium on Lake Erie? Paul Brown was the only good owner we've had and same with Cincy. Cincy wanted to keep the orange and brown colors and tradition Paul started so why not do so in the only place Paul Brown won multiple Pro Football Championships? Cincy can change their name to the Ohio Junior Varsity.
When Roger finally gets his dream of putting another NFL franchise in London or Toronto or Mexico - we can finally combine the 2 Ohio teams (that would already be playing here) and put Mike Brown/family out of their misery of tarnishing what Paul started. That, or we could have a contest to see what ownership deserves the blended teams by then... If they both keep on keepin on - let the owner's spouses mud wrestle for it. Loser at least gets the money the winner has to pay in buy-out. The Winner gets to keep playing Charlie Brown trying to kick the game winning points with Lucy holding. The fans get to keep reminding themselves how much they appreciate Ohio State - where winning is a tradition!
FYI....Paul Brown was never the owner of the Cleveland Browns.
Owners
Person Teams From To Titles Notes Arthur McBride Browns 1946 1952 Principal Owner David Jones Browns 1953 1960 Partial Owner, President/Majority Owner Ellis Ryan Browns 1953 1960 Partial Owner, President/Partial Owner Art Modell Browns 1961 1995 Principal Owner Al Lerner Browns 1999 2001 Principal Owner Randy Lerner Browns 2002 2011 Principal Owner, Principal Owner/President Jimmy Haslam III Browns 2012 2019 Principal Owner -
Rather than ripping down Browns Stadium long before it's a fossil, couldn't they just add a retractable roof to it?
If we're going to get really open-minded here, why not bring Paul Brown's franchise here for the 8 games Cleveland plays away - so the football fans in Ohio finally have a chance to see 6-8 wins in the stadium on Lake Erie? Paul Brown was the only good owner we've had and same with Cincy. Cincy wanted to keep the orange and brown colors and tradition Paul started so why not do so in the only place Paul Brown won multiple Pro Football Championships? Cincy can change their name to the Ohio Junior Varsity.
When Roger finally gets his dream of putting another NFL franchise in London or Toronto or Mexico - we can finally combine the 2 Ohio teams (that would already be playing here) and put Mike Brown/family out of their misery of tarnishing what Paul started. That, or we could have a contest to see what ownership deserves the blended teams by then... If they both keep on keepin on - let the owner's spouses mud wrestle for it. Loser at least gets the money the winner has to pay in buy-out. The Winner gets to keep playing Charlie Brown trying to kick the game winning points with Lucy holding. The fans get to keep reminding themselves how much they appreciate Ohio State - where winning is a tradition!
FYI....Paul Brown was never the owner of the Cleveland Browns.
Owners
Person Teams From To Titles Notes Arthur McBride Browns 1946 1952 Principal Owner David Jones Browns 1953 1960 Partial Owner, President/Majority Owner Ellis Ryan Browns 1953 1960 Partial Owner, President/Partial Owner Art Modell Browns 1961 1995 Principal Owner Al Lerner Browns 1999 2001 Principal Owner Randy Lerner Browns 2002 2011 Principal Owner, Principal Owner/President Jimmy Haslam III Browns 2012 2019 Principal Owner FYI....Paul Brown was never the owner of the Cleveland Browns.
Owners
Person Teams From To Titles Notes Arthur McBride Browns 1946 1952 Principal Owner David Jones Browns 1953 1960 Partial Owner, President/Majority Owner Ellis Ryan Browns 1953 1960 Partial Owner, President/Partial Owner Art Modell Browns 1961 1995 Principal Owner Al Lerner Browns 1999 2001 Principal Owner Randy Lerner Browns 2002 2011 Principal Owner, Principal Owner/President Jimmy Haslam III Browns 2012 2019 Principal Owner Come on Gipper - I was on the same roll Belushi was on in Animal House. And btw nobody ever answered his question - "Was it over when the Germans bombed Pear Harbor?"
For some absurd reason, I thought he once owned/partially owned the team before/when it first joined the NFL (long before Modell arrived). I miss the days when I didn't have to think about who the owners were. Last week, feels like such a long time ago.
-
............ and you guys think going across the middle is for tough guys. We think that's cute.
Thatta boy D-Bone! Rumor has it Steeler fans try the same thing on a metal unicorn.
-
Football indoors sucks, especially for Browns fans used to football being played in the mud and snow.
But financially there is nothing more idiotic than building an astronomically expensive building that gets used 12 or so times a year, especially when it sits on prime real estate.
Football indoors sucks, especially for Browns fans used to football being played in the mud and snow.
But financially there is nothing more idiotic than building an astronomically expensive building that gets used 12 or so times a year, especially when it sits on prime real estate.
The outdoor vs dome/retractable stadium talk is about drawing other venues to a football stadium besides two preseason games and eight regular season games in 365 days a year.
Fan and player comfort is just nice if you have a rare 0° day with 25 mph winds or maybe torrential rain.
Also the joint football/baseball stadiums are gone forever.........unless Al Davis rises out of his grave just to piss us all off again.
-
Did you not get the memo on immature name-calling, Tour? ?
The original post is still standing, apparently that stand is on a case-by-case situation.
Hardly name calling Dutch. Tour was expressing his personal opinion (which happens to be different) than yours.
There's ways to disagree without resorting to calling someone a racist bigot.
Your feelings hurt because I'm tired of you and Gorka calling each other names? FWIW, I wound up wasting a lot of time deleting what amounted to roughly 30% of the Garrett thread that was just off topic personal insult bullshit.
-
How many packs of smokes and bottles are you gonna tax?
tear downs $$
new builds $$$$$$
and you just put a ton of money in First energy and not too long ago the Prog the new scoreboard etc
before they built first energy I was screaming for a dome for the very reasons brought up. Super Bowl, NCAA other big events. We doubled down and remodeled it now too.
too lateI think it's a pipe dream too...
Someday the Browns will be playing in a retractable dome. I have a feeling if the Haslams are around for the long term, they'll demand an upgrade.
I still think the next ballpark the Indians play in won't be in Cleveland.
I think it's a pipe dream too...
Someday the Browns will be playing in a retractable dome. I have a feeling if the Haslams are around for the long term, they'll demand an upgrade.
I still think the next ballpark the Indians play in won't be in Cleveland.
The Jake... Prog...has at least 20-25 years left.
it will be interesting in that time it could very well be a early-mid 90s type scenario again. Browns and Indians looking for new Stadiums. Absolutely nothing wrong with First energy it is as modern as any stadium out there.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login