PSA
-
Hillis is the guy who is a gimmick.
How so?
How so?
Hillis never produced the numbers Harrison produced in college. Harrison in 3 games last year had more carries that Hillis has had his entire career. I am much more comfortable having Harrison as the feature back. He is more proven and should be getting more carries. Plus Harrison does not have a fumble problem.
-
How so?
Hillis never produced the numbers Harrison produced in college. Harrison in 3 games last year had more carries that Hillis has had his entire career. I am much more comfortable having Harrison as the feature back. He is more proven and should be getting more carries. Plus Harrison does not have a fumble problem.
I am much more comfortable having Harrison as the feature back.
Here is your problem. You are trying to find a feature back out of these options. It isn't possible. It is a RBBC pure and simple.
-
In all honesty, I dont think we are utilizing Harrison the right way. He needs screens, and tosses to go outside the tackles. Otherwise the OL has to make a hole. He is just to good in space to not try to get it to him in space.
-
This is the most ridiculous argument ever.
We clearly have the RBBC personnel. Some days Harrison will get the rock 25, 30 times a game. Other times he might never really see the field. It's all about matchups. A big physical runningback is going to beat a speed defense nine times out of ten, and a speedy back will beat a bulky defense just as many times.
Tampa Bay had an extremely fast defense with tremendous lateral speed. Harrison would have been stuffed more often than not around the edges. The only way to beat a fast defense is to run right up the gut, and that's what Hillis is for.
The playcalling was good, the gameplan was fine. We just needed to work out the kinks.
Harrison is NOT a feature back, no matter how much of a homer you are for him. I'm the biggest James Davis homer on this board, but I know he's better in a 2 back system than as an everydown back. Just accept it, and stop trying to push your boy in detriment to the good of the team. I believe Mangini and co. know a little more about the personnel decisions than you do, whether you want to think so or not.
I'm awesome, and I fuck dolphins. Ghoolie 12/2/2012: I have absolutely no skills, training or pride -
This is the most ridiculous argument ever.
We clearly have the RBBC personnel. Some days Harrison will get the rock 25, 30 times a game. Other times he might never really see the field. It's all about matchups. A big physical runningback is going to beat a speed defense nine times out of ten, and a speedy back will beat a bulky defense just as many times.
Tampa Bay had an extremely fast defense with tremendous lateral speed. Harrison would have been stuffed more often than not around the edges. The only way to beat a fast defense is to run right up the gut, and that's what Hillis is for.
The playcalling was good, the gameplan was fine. We just needed to work out the kinks.
Harrison is NOT a feature back, no matter how much of a homer you are for him. I'm the biggest James Davis homer on this board, but I know he's better in a 2 back system than as an everydown back. Just accept it, and stop trying to push your boy in detriment to the good of the team. I believe Mangini and co. know a little more about the personnel decisions than you do, whether you want to think so or not.
This is the most ridiculous argument ever.
We clearly have the RBBC personnel. Some days Harrison will get the rock 25, 30 times a game. Other times he might never really see the field. It's all about matchups. A big physical runningback is going to beat a speed defense nine times out of ten, and a speedy back will beat a bulky defense just as many times.
Tampa Bay had an extremely fast defense with tremendous lateral speed. Harrison would have been stuffed more often than not around the edges. The only way to beat a fast defense is to run right up the gut, and that's what Hillis is for.
The playcalling was good, the gameplan was fine. We just needed to work out the kinks.
Harrison is NOT a feature back, no matter how much of a homer you are for him. I'm the biggest James Davis homer on this board, but I know he's better in a 2 back system than as an everydown back. Just accept it, and stop trying to push your boy in detriment to the good of the team. I believe Mangini and co. know a little more about the personnel decisions than you do, whether you want to think so or not.
Our most effective running was done last year when we gave Harrison 20+ carries. The results do not lie. You cant expect a 40 yard gain on every play, but you have to get him his carries. Plus he didn't fumble the ball twice on 9 carries. That is unacceptable. And I'm willing to bet i do know more than Mangini about personnel decisions. Football is not rocket science, basic engineering or even chess. It is not that difficult to understand, and you do not need special intelligence or a university degree to coach football.
-
This is the most ridiculous argument ever.
We clearly have the RBBC personnel. Some days Harrison will get the rock 25, 30 times a game. Other times he might never really see the field. It's all about matchups. A big physical runningback is going to beat a speed defense nine times out of ten, and a speedy back will beat a bulky defense just as many times.
Tampa Bay had an extremely fast defense with tremendous lateral speed. Harrison would have been stuffed more often than not around the edges. The only way to beat a fast defense is to run right up the gut, and that's what Hillis is for.
The playcalling was good, the gameplan was fine. We just needed to work out the kinks.
Harrison is NOT a feature back, no matter how much of a homer you are for him. I'm the biggest James Davis homer on this board, but I know he's better in a 2 back system than as an everydown back. Just accept it, and stop trying to push your boy in detriment to the good of the team. I believe Mangini and co. know a little more about the personnel decisions than you do, whether you want to think so or not.
This is the most ridiculous argument ever.
We clearly have the RBBC personnel. Some days Harrison will get the rock 25, 30 times a game. Other times he might never really see the field. It's all about matchups. A big physical runningback is going to beat a speed defense nine times out of ten, and a speedy back will beat a bulky defense just as many times.
Tampa Bay had an extremely fast defense with tremendous lateral speed. Harrison would have been stuffed more often than not around the edges. The only way to beat a fast defense is to run right up the gut, and that's what Hillis is for.
The playcalling was good, the gameplan was fine. We just needed to work out the kinks.
Yup, Tampa didn't beat the Browns yesterday, the Browns beat themselves. Error free game and Cleveland wins that game going away.
-
How so?
Hillis never produced the numbers Harrison produced in college. Harrison in 3 games last year had more carries that Hillis has had his entire career. I am much more comfortable having Harrison as the feature back. He is more proven and should be getting more carries. Plus Harrison does not have a fumble problem.
Hillis never produced the numbers Harrison produced in college.
Also, Hillis was on the same team With Felix Jones and Darren McFadden for Christ's sake.
-
isn't hillis a FB? why isn't he blowing up holes for harrison? if you want power running have more than 2 backs in the backfield. did davis even get a touch yesterday?
-
This is the most ridiculous argument ever.
We clearly have the RBBC personnel. Some days Harrison will get the rock 25, 30 times a game. Other times he might never really see the field. It's all about matchups. A big physical runningback is going to beat a speed defense nine times out of ten, and a speedy back will beat a bulky defense just as many times.
Tampa Bay had an extremely fast defense with tremendous lateral speed. Harrison would have been stuffed more often than not around the edges. The only way to beat a fast defense is to run right up the gut, and that's what Hillis is for.
The playcalling was good, the gameplan was fine. We just needed to work out the kinks.
Harrison is NOT a feature back, no matter how much of a homer you are for him. I'm the biggest James Davis homer on this board, but I know he's better in a 2 back system than as an everydown back. Just accept it, and stop trying to push your boy in detriment to the good of the team. I believe Mangini and co. know a little more about the personnel decisions than you do, whether you want to think so or not.
Our most effective running was done last year when we gave Harrison 20+ carries. The results do not lie. You cant expect a 40 yard gain on every play, but you have to get him his carries. Plus he didn't fumble the ball twice on 9 carries. That is unacceptable. And I'm willing to bet i do know more than Mangini about personnel decisions. Football is not rocket science, basic engineering or even chess. It is not that difficult to understand, and you do not need special intelligence or a university degree to coach football.
Our most effective running was done last year when we gave Harrison 20+ carries. The results do not lie. You cant expect a 40 yard gain on every play, but you have to get him his carries. Plus he didn't fumble the ball twice on 9 carries. That is unacceptable. And I'm willing to bet i do know more than Mangini about personnel decisions. Football is not rocket science, basic engineering or even chess. It is not that difficult to understand, and you do not need special intelligence or a university degree to coach football.
Yes, that was our most effective running. And once again, that running was against Jacksonville, Oakland, and Kansas City. Those teams finished 19th, 28th, and 31st in rush defense in the league, respectively.
And don't flatter yourself. People are so quick to belittle Mangini, but he's an NFL head coach. He's making six figures on Sundays, and you're stuck at home bitching about him online. If you honestly believe you can do better, then by all means go up to Berea and sit in on a practice. Offer your two cents.
There are millions of men in America who think they can coach better than the pros. They're called armchair quarterbacks, and you're just one of them.
-
isn't hillis a FB? why isn't he blowing up holes for harrison? if you want power running have more than 2 backs in the backfield. did davis even get a touch yesterday?
isn't hillis a FB? why isn't he blowing up holes for harrison? if you want power running have more than 2 backs in the backfield. did davis even get a touch yesterday?
Lawrence Vickers is the best FB in the game. Hillis won't start over him.
-
Lawrence Vickers is the best FB in the game. Hillis won't start over him.
did they play him?
-
Lawrence Vickers is the best FB in the game. Hillis won't start over him.
did they play him?
-
Tim Couch Pulls Out deserves a special thanks for his comments on this thread. Thank you, Tim.
-
Think about this. In 2 of the 3 games that you are using as your examples he averaged 3.79 and 3.85. That is not good. Using his career YPC isn't a very good strategy either. A lot of those yards were in garbage time or as a 3rd down back and are inflated. Take a look at the numbers of players like K. Faulk or Sproles to see what happens when an ill equipped RB tries to carry the load. Their YPC goes from mid 5s to mid 3s.
All those games were wins buddy. Plus we had absolutely no passing game to speak of. Yet he helped us win those games. He is not Sproles or K. Faulk. He can carry the load. Hillis is the guy who is a gimmick.
All those games were wins buddy. Plus we had absolutely no passing game to speak of. Yet he helped us win those games. He is not Sproles or K. Faulk. He can carry the load. Hillis is the guy who is a gimmick.
YOU ARE THE ONLY GUY ON THIS BOARD THAT DESERVES A CHANCE TO SPEAK, XXXX HILLIS HE'S GARBAGE JEROME IS AN HAS BEEN THE ANSWER FOR A LONG TIME NOW
-
Our most effective running was done last year when we gave Harrison 20+ carries. The results do not lie. You cant expect a 40 yard gain on every play, but you have to get him his carries. Plus he didn't fumble the ball twice on 9 carries. That is unacceptable. And I'm willing to bet i do know more than Mangini about personnel decisions. Football is not rocket science, basic engineering or even chess. It is not that difficult to understand, and you do not need special intelligence or a university degree to coach football.
Yes, that was our most effective running. And once again, that running was against Jacksonville, Oakland, and Kansas City. Those teams finished 19th, 28th, and 31st in rush defense in the league, respectively.
And don't flatter yourself. People are so quick to belittle Mangini, but he's an NFL head coach. He's making six figures on Sundays, and you're stuck at home bitching about him online. If you honestly believe you can do better, then by all means go up to Berea and sit in on a practice. Offer your two cents.
There are millions of men in America who think they can coach better than the pros. They're called armchair quarterbacks, and you're just one of them.
Yes, that was our most effective running. And once again, that running was against Jacksonville, Oakland, and Kansas City. Those teams finished 19th, 28th, and 31st in rush defense in the league, respectively.
And don't flatter yourself. People are so quick to belittle Mangini, but he's an NFL head coach. He's making six figures on Sundays, and you're stuck at home bitching about him online. If you honestly believe you can do better, then by all means go up to Berea and sit in on a practice. Offer your two cents.
There are millions of men in America who think they can coach better than the pros. They're called armchair quarterbacks, and you're just one of them.
And I do believe Tampa was horrible against the run last year. They allowed 4.8 YPC. So why not run Jerome Harrison at least 20 times. And there plenty of people who could handle personnel better than Mangini. Getting into pro coaching is all about connections, not how smart you are. A smart person would never have jacked up the QB situation last year the way Mangini did. There are hundreds of people who knew that was a bad idea, yet they aren't getting paid big money. There's a reason we hire sports columnists to second guess sports coaches, because its not complicated. On the other hand when is the last time you read a newspaper column criticizing design calculations for a jet fighter. Never. Because most people don't have that expertise. Stop acting like football is complicated.
-
Yes, that was our most effective running. And once again, that running was against Jacksonville, Oakland, and Kansas City. Those teams finished 19th, 28th, and 31st in rush defense in the league, respectively.
And don't flatter yourself. People are so quick to belittle Mangini, but he's an NFL head coach. He's making six figures on Sundays, and you're stuck at home bitching about him online. If you honestly believe you can do better, then by all means go up to Berea and sit in on a practice. Offer your two cents.
There are millions of men in America who think they can coach better than the pros. They're called armchair quarterbacks, and you're just one of them.
And I do believe Tampa was horrible against the run last year. They allowed 4.8 YPC. So why not run Jerome Harrison at least 20 times. And there plenty of people who could handle personnel better than Mangini. Getting into pro coaching is all about connections, not how smart you are. A smart person would never have jacked up the QB situation last year the way Mangini did. There are hundreds of people who knew that was a bad idea, yet they aren't getting paid big money. There's a reason we hire sports columnists to second guess sports coaches, because its not complicated. On the other hand when is the last time you read a newspaper column criticizing design calculations for a jet fighter. Never. Because most people don't have that expertise. Stop acting like football is complicated.
And I do believe Tampa was horrible against the run last year. They allowed 4.8 YPC. So why not run Jerome Harrison at least 20 times. And there plenty of people who could handle personnel better than Mangini. Getting into pro coaching is all about connections, not how smart you are. A smart person would never have jacked up the QB situation last year the way Mangini did. There are hundreds of people who knew that was a bad idea, yet they aren't getting paid big money. There's a reason we hire sports columnists to second guess sports coaches, because its not complicated. On the other hand when is the last time you read a newspaper column criticizing design calculations for a jet fighter. Never. Because most people don't have that expertise. Stop acting like football is complicated.
I never once acted like football is complicated. You're just acting like you're the next boy genius, when in reality you're just an armchair quarterback. Believe it or not, I'm quite well learned in football, and I know that you are severely underestimating what it takes to run a professional football team. If you think it's all sunshine and giggles, go right ahead and be my guest. It's not rocket science, but it's not just looking at a guy and saying "Hey, you're fast. You had yards against shit teams. I like you, you be the starter."
Giving Jerome the rock 20 times against Tampa Bay could have given him 200 yards. Or, which is more likely, it would have given him around 60 yards.
Hindsight is 20/20. Stop acting like you're a xxxxing genius.
I'm awesome, and I fuck dolphins. Ghoolie 12/2/2012: I have absolutely no skills, training or pride -
Yes, that was our most effective running. And once again, that running was against Jacksonville, Oakland, and Kansas City. Those teams finished 19th, 28th, and 31st in rush defense in the league, respectively.
And don't flatter yourself. People are so quick to belittle Mangini, but he's an NFL head coach. He's making six figures on Sundays, and you're stuck at home bitching about him online. If you honestly believe you can do better, then by all means go up to Berea and sit in on a practice. Offer your two cents.
There are millions of men in America who think they can coach better than the pros. They're called armchair quarterbacks, and you're just one of them.
And I do believe Tampa was horrible against the run last year. They allowed 4.8 YPC. So why not run Jerome Harrison at least 20 times. And there plenty of people who could handle personnel better than Mangini. Getting into pro coaching is all about connections, not how smart you are. A smart person would never have jacked up the QB situation last year the way Mangini did. There are hundreds of people who knew that was a bad idea, yet they aren't getting paid big money. There's a reason we hire sports columnists to second guess sports coaches, because its not complicated. On the other hand when is the last time you read a newspaper column criticizing design calculations for a jet fighter. Never. Because most people don't have that expertise. Stop acting like football is complicated.
And I do believe Tampa was horrible against the run last year. They allowed 4.8 YPC. So why not run Jerome Harrison at least 20 times. And there plenty of people who could handle personnel better than Mangini. Getting into pro coaching is all about connections, not how smart you are. A smart person would never have jacked up the QB situation last year the way Mangini did. There are hundreds of people who knew that was a bad idea, yet they aren't getting paid big money. There's a reason we hire sports columnists to second guess sports coaches, because its not complicated. On the other hand when is the last time you read a newspaper column criticizing design calculations for a jet fighter. Never. Because most people don't have that expertise. Stop acting like football is complicated.
Well you can say uncomplicated if you wish- but mind bogglingly detailed. Each player gets critiqued on every freaking play, and opponents are scouted for the slightest tendencies that will give you an advantage. Probably isn't a HC in the NFL that doesn't put in a minimum 16 hour day, seven days a week during the season. Those guys earn their money.
-
And I do believe Tampa was horrible against the run last year. They allowed 4.8 YPC. So why not run Jerome Harrison at least 20 times. And there plenty of people who could handle personnel better than Mangini. Getting into pro coaching is all about connections, not how smart you are. A smart person would never have jacked up the QB situation last year the way Mangini did. There are hundreds of people who knew that was a bad idea, yet they aren't getting paid big money. There's a reason we hire sports columnists to second guess sports coaches, because its not complicated. On the other hand when is the last time you read a newspaper column criticizing design calculations for a jet fighter. Never. Because most people don't have that expertise. Stop acting like football is complicated.
I never once acted like football is complicated. You're just acting like you're the next boy genius, when in reality you're just an armchair quarterback. Believe it or not, I'm quite well learned in football, and I know that you are severely underestimating what it takes to run a professional football team. If you think it's all sunshine and giggles, go right ahead and be my guest. It's not rocket science, but it's not just looking at a guy and saying "Hey, you're fast. You had yards against shit teams. I like you, you be the starter."
Giving Jerome the rock 20 times against Tampa Bay could have given him 200 yards. Or, which is more likely, it would have given him around 60 yards.
Hindsight is 20/20. Stop acting like you're a xxxxing genius.
I never once acted like football is complicated. You're just acting like you're the next boy genius, when in reality you're just an armchair quarterback. Believe it or not, I'm quite well learned in football, and I know that you are severely underestimating what it takes to run a professional football team. If you think it's all sunshine and giggles, go right ahead and be my guest. It's not rocket science, but it's not just looking at a guy and saying "Hey, you're fast. You had yards against shit teams. I like you, you be the starter."
Giving Jerome the rock 20 times against Tampa Bay could have given him 200 yards. Or, which is more likely, it would have given him around 60 yards.
Hindsight is 20/20. Stop acting like you're a xxxxing genius.
He had 9 carries for 52 yards. If you do the math that's better than 5.0 YPC. So what makes you think he would carry 20 times for 60 yards. You don't seem to be well learned in football to me buddy. Last time i checked 5 YPC is pretty good. So why not give him the ball more? Making football more complicated than what it has to be is why Coaches fail. It's not that difficult.
-
I never once acted like football is complicated. You're just acting like you're the next boy genius, when in reality you're just an armchair quarterback. Believe it or not, I'm quite well learned in football, and I know that you are severely underestimating what it takes to run a professional football team. If you think it's all sunshine and giggles, go right ahead and be my guest. It's not rocket science, but it's not just looking at a guy and saying "Hey, you're fast. You had yards against shit teams. I like you, you be the starter."
Giving Jerome the rock 20 times against Tampa Bay could have given him 200 yards. Or, which is more likely, it would have given him around 60 yards.
Hindsight is 20/20. Stop acting like you're a xxxxing genius.
He had 9 carries for 52 yards. If you do the math that's better than 5.0 YPC. So what makes you think he would carry 20 times for 60 yards. You don't seem to be well learned in football to me buddy. Last time i checked 5 YPC is pretty good. So why not give him the ball more? Making football more complicated than what it has to be is why Coaches fail. It's not that difficult.
He had 9 carries for 52 yards. If you do the math that's better than 5.0 YPC. So what makes you think he would carry 20 times for 60 yards. You don't seem to be well learned in football to me buddy. Last time i checked 5 YPC is pretty good. So why not give him the ball more? Making football more complicated than what it has to be is why Coaches fail. It's not that difficult.
And one of those runs was a 40 yard run. Take that run out, and he's got 8 carries for 12 yards. He got stuffed the entire day, except for one lucky run he broke. Whereas Hillis was picking up yards every time he touched the ball. He didn't break open for any real big gains, but he moved the chains. And that's what you want when you're up by only a score in the second half. Ball control offense, look it up.
I'm awesome, and I fuck dolphins. Ghoolie 12/2/2012: I have absolutely no skills, training or pride -
He had 9 carries for 52 yards. If you do the math that's better than 5.0 YPC. So what makes you think he would carry 20 times for 60 yards. You don't seem to be well learned in football to me buddy. Last time i checked 5 YPC is pretty good. So why not give him the ball more? Making football more complicated than what it has to be is why Coaches fail. It's not that difficult.
And one of those runs was a 40 yard run. Take that run out, and he's got 8 carries for 12 yards. He got stuffed the entire day, except for one lucky run he broke. Whereas Hillis was picking up yards every time he touched the ball. He didn't break open for any real big gains, but he moved the chains. And that's what you want when you're up by only a score in the second half. Ball control offense, look it up.
And one of those runs was a 40 yard run. Take that run out, and he's got 8 carries for 12 yards. He got stuffed the entire day, except for one lucky run he broke. Whereas Hillis was picking up yards every time he touched the ball. He didn't break open for any real big gains, but he moved the chains. And that's what you want when you're up by only a score in the second half. Ball control offense, look it up.
Your a moron. Hillis had two fumbles, including one that cost us the game. Fumbling isn't part of ball control offense sir. Harrison had no trouble moving the chains while averaging 30+ carries with no passing game to speak of. When has Hillis shown he can do that? And even guys like Chris Johnson don't break long ones every time. He had half of his yards on one play against the Raiders. You have to give running backs their carries for them to be effective.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login