Skip to content

Jonathan Paul Manziel

The Browns Board
16.0k 396 658.8k 1
  • @canton-dawg said:

    It seems to me that when JM runs to his right, his throws are fairly accurate. When he scrambles to his left, his throws are erratic and off target. Anybody else notice this?

    It's because he's right handed.

    Canton DawgC Canton Dawg wrote on last edited by

    @tim-couch-pulls-out said:

    It's because he's right handed.

    No shit?

  • It seems to me that when JM runs to his right, his throws are fairly accurate. When he scrambles to his left, his throws are erratic and off target. Anybody else notice this?

    Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by

    @canton-dawg said:

    It seems to me that when JM runs to his right, his throws are fairly accurate. When he scrambles to his left, his throws are erratic and off target. Anybody else notice this?

    Actually I've seen him throw some very crisp passes across his body rolling left... when he can throw the ball on a line to his target.

    What I have noticed is that left, right or standing still he's had issues when he has had to put touch on the ball.

  • C Clevfan4life wrote on last edited by

    I'm not knowledgeable about qb arm mechanics, I actually didn't realize that JF had a 3/4 like delivery until it was talked about. Question is to those that do know....does that type of delivery make the deep ball hard to throw? When he had to put real air under the ball it came out awful. Would it absolutely ruin a young kid if they tried to make him throw more overhand? If our power running game pans out we're gonna need a qb that can throw over the top of stacked defense's. If those wobbles are what happens when a 3/4 guy throws deep under pressure...that doesn't bode well for him. Cause he will be under pressure on virtually every snap here in Cleveland..as he's already found out.

  • I'm not knowledgeable about qb arm mechanics, I actually didn't realize that JF had a 3/4 like delivery until it was talked about. Question is to those that do know....does that type of delivery make the deep ball hard to throw? When he had to put real air under the ball it came out awful. Would it absolutely ruin a young kid if they tried to make him throw more overhand? If our power running game pans out we're gonna need a qb that can throw over the top of stacked defense's. If those wobbles are what happens when a 3/4 guy throws deep under pressure...that doesn't bode well for him. Cause he will be under pressure on virtually every snap here in Cleveland..as he's already found out.

    Z Zombo wrote on last edited by

    @clevfan4life said:

    I'm not knowledgeable about qb arm mechanics, I actually didn't realize that JF had a 3/4 like delivery until it was talked about. Question is to those that do know....does that type of delivery make the deep ball hard to throw? When he had to put real air under the ball it came out awful. Would it absolutely ruin a young kid if they tried to make him throw more overhand? If our power running game pans out we're gonna need a qb that can throw over the top of stacked defense's. If those wobbles are what happens when a 3/4 guy throws deep under pressure...that doesn't bode well for him. Cause he will be under pressure on virtually every snap here in Cleveland..as he's already found out.

    It doesn't preclude you from throwing over the top, Phillip Rivers and Bernie Kosar throw/threw beautiful deep balls with a 3/4 delivery.

    They're tall though. My concern with Manziel is getting that ball out of the pocket with 6'6' linemen closing in on him.

    I think Manziel throws a good deep ball and has nice arm strength, he is just too raw for the NFL game as we saw the preseason. No consistency with his delivery, I am sure they are working on that.

    Zombo

  • Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by

    Good summary of the sidearm thing... adding that, no, you do not change it...

    FWIW I don't think it's an issue of "mechanics"... it's a head issue.

  • USFBrownU USFBrown wrote on last edited by

    Shaw > Manziel

  • @tim-couch-pulls-out said:

    It's because he's right handed.

    No shit?

    Tim Couch Pulls OutT Tim Couch Pulls Out wrote on last edited by
  • I'm not knowledgeable about qb arm mechanics, I actually didn't realize that JF had a 3/4 like delivery until it was talked about. Question is to those that do know....does that type of delivery make the deep ball hard to throw? When he had to put real air under the ball it came out awful. Would it absolutely ruin a young kid if they tried to make him throw more overhand? If our power running game pans out we're gonna need a qb that can throw over the top of stacked defense's. If those wobbles are what happens when a 3/4 guy throws deep under pressure...that doesn't bode well for him. Cause he will be under pressure on virtually every snap here in Cleveland..as he's already found out.

    Tim Couch Pulls OutT Tim Couch Pulls Out wrote on last edited by

    @clevfan4life said:

    I'm not knowledgeable about qb arm mechanics, I actually didn't realize that JF had a 3/4 like delivery until it was talked about. Question is to those that do know....does that type of delivery make the deep ball hard to throw? When he had to put real air under the ball it came out awful. Would it absolutely ruin a young kid if they tried to make him throw more overhand? If our power running game pans out we're gonna need a qb that can throw over the top of stacked defense's. If those wobbles are what happens when a 3/4 guy throws deep under pressure...that doesn't bode well for him. Cause he will be under pressure on virtually every snap here in Cleveland..as he's already found out.

    Even those with true over the top deliveries sometimes tend to drop to 3/4 when attempting to throw deep bombs. Brees is guilty just as JF is.

    A 3/4 delivery isn't "wrong". It's just another delivery method.

    Most kids aren't taught proper mechanics and from a young age begin throwing 3/4 because it feels more natural. Trying to force a different delivery forces JF to consciously think about his body movement while trying to simultaneously process what's happening around him and that's when mistakes get made.

    The reason he was throwing ducks isn't because of his delivery method, it's because he was strong arming it. His tempo was off, his mechanics were falling apart and he was throwing all arm rather than planting, driving and using his entire body. Nearly all of his passes seemed to be slung rather than thrown and that's why they looked the way they did.

    A nice lesson I learned about reviewing tape from many different coaches - ball don't lie. When your mechanics are off, the ball shows it. Passes where the nose of the ball is off kilter and pointed slightly up indicate arm throws, a weak grip and open shoulders. If the nose is pointed down, you're likely using too much wrist and your throwing from a closed position.

  • @clevfan4life said:

    I'm not knowledgeable about qb arm mechanics, I actually didn't realize that JF had a 3/4 like delivery until it was talked about. Question is to those that do know....does that type of delivery make the deep ball hard to throw? When he had to put real air under the ball it came out awful. Would it absolutely ruin a young kid if they tried to make him throw more overhand? If our power running game pans out we're gonna need a qb that can throw over the top of stacked defense's. If those wobbles are what happens when a 3/4 guy throws deep under pressure...that doesn't bode well for him. Cause he will be under pressure on virtually every snap here in Cleveland..as he's already found out.

    Even those with true over the top deliveries sometimes tend to drop to 3/4 when attempting to throw deep bombs. Brees is guilty just as JF is.

    A 3/4 delivery isn't "wrong". It's just another delivery method.

    Most kids aren't taught proper mechanics and from a young age begin throwing 3/4 because it feels more natural. Trying to force a different delivery forces JF to consciously think about his body movement while trying to simultaneously process what's happening around him and that's when mistakes get made.

    The reason he was throwing ducks isn't because of his delivery method, it's because he was strong arming it. His tempo was off, his mechanics were falling apart and he was throwing all arm rather than planting, driving and using his entire body. Nearly all of his passes seemed to be slung rather than thrown and that's why they looked the way they did.

    A nice lesson I learned about reviewing tape from many different coaches - ball don't lie. When your mechanics are off, the ball shows it. Passes where the nose of the ball is off kilter and pointed slightly up indicate arm throws, a weak grip and open shoulders. If the nose is pointed down, you're likely using too much wrist and your throwing from a closed position.

    Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by

    @tim-couch-pulls-out said:

    The reason he was throwing ducks isn't because of his delivery method, it's because he was strong arming it. His tempo was off, his mechanics were falling apart and he was throwing all arm rather than planting, driving and using his entire body.

    Is "strong-arming" a "touch-pass" is not nearly as oxymoronic as it seems at first blush?

  • @tim-couch-pulls-out said:

    The reason he was throwing ducks isn't because of his delivery method, it's because he was strong arming it. His tempo was off, his mechanics were falling apart and he was throwing all arm rather than planting, driving and using his entire body.

    Is "strong-arming" a "touch-pass" is not nearly as oxymoronic as it seems at first blush?

    Tim Couch Pulls OutT Tim Couch Pulls Out wrote on last edited by

    @tour2ma said:

    Is "strong-arming" a "touch-pass" is not nearly as oxymoronic as it seems at first blush?

    Yeah, it does seem a bit oxymoronic.

    To clear up what I mean, I don't mean he was trying to put strength behind the pass, I mean that he was purely using all arm and nothing else.

  • @tour2ma said:

    Is "strong-arming" a "touch-pass" is not nearly as oxymoronic as it seems at first blush?

    Yeah, it does seem a bit oxymoronic.

    To clear up what I mean, I don't mean he was trying to put strength behind the pass, I mean that he was purely using all arm and nothing else.

    Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by Tour2ma

    @tim-couch-pulls-out said:

    Yeah, it does seem a bit oxymoronic.

    To clear up what I mean, I don't mean he was trying to put strength behind the pass, I mean that he was purely using all arm and nothing else.

    Got ya...

    I was clearing up what seemed on the surface to be a disagreement between what we were seeing... Not that that would be a bad thing... or a first... 🙂

  • KvoetheK Kvoethe wrote on last edited by
  • B BrownsFanatic wrote on last edited by BrownsFanatic

    idk if any of you guys realize this but hoyer is garbage. He is weeden-esque and its going to show come sunday. Weeden would've won those games that brian won

  • D BoneD D Bone wrote on last edited by

    Johnny?? Is that you? Oh, my bad, you're just an idiot.

  • idk if any of you guys realize this but hoyer is garbage. He is weeden-esque and its going to show come sunday. Weeden would've won those games that brian won

    Tour2maT Tour2ma wrote on last edited by

    @brownsfanatic said:

    idk if any of you guys realize this but hoyer is garbage. He is weeden-esque and its going to show come sunday. Weeden would've won those games that brian won

    The difference between Hoyer and Wheezy is only slightly less than the difference between yours and an intelligent post...

  • The Cysko KidT The Cysko Kid wrote on last edited by

    Are we not supposed to see Johnny tackling dummy when rg3 throws?

  • KvoetheK Kvoethe wrote on last edited by

    I think thats part of the humor.

  • T TexasAg1969 wrote on last edited by

    LOL-you can see the real JM just stepping out from behind the guy with the red, white & blue shirt on the right.

  • TopDawg31T TopDawg31 wrote on last edited by

    Movie magic do you really think Manziel would stand there and let RG3 throw a ball 30 mph at his face?, I doubt we see the dummy in the actual commercial.

  • MLD WoodyM MLD Woody wrote on last edited by

    They tried it with the roles reversed at first, but Johnny kept missing the apple.