@flugel said:Awesome topic JD! I actually posted something similar preseason or maybe it was earlier in the regular season. Anyway, I saw the personnel to use a 4-3. Williams came from a 4-3. Tennessee uses the 4-3 and that's what we pulled Robaire out of. Rogers played in a 4-3 before coming here. I think Wimbley might have better success standing up and coming in off outside X stunts where he isn't being blocked by the best athlete on the opponent's oline every single play. Jackson would probably get touched less frequently by Centers if we had Shaun Smith and Shaun Rogers going Sumo and Slamo on the G-C gaps.
That said, a few weeks ago it was either Gannon, Beuerline or Randy Cross pointing out we had 4 guys with a hand down up front on every play so he said the Browns are not in a 3-4 right now. On the replay he showed you only have 2 backers, 4 dlinemen and 5 DBs on the field. I watched the majority of our plays thereafter and he was right.
while i agree that wimbley would have greater success if he weren't rushing from the same spot all the time or if he could stunt some, that's something that can be done from the 3-4 if the coach is willing to either move him around or has a creative, blitz-oriented mind.
when we go to a four-man line in our nickel package, we're switching to a 2-4-5 and taking a d-lineman out in favor of a third corner. we move our OLBs to the line and have them play with their hands down like traditional DEs. it's pretty much the same thing as a traditional nickel, but the personnel switch is a little different because we're switching out a d-lineman and not a LB. we normally switch out shaun smith for one of our terrible backup corners.
one thing that rac hasn't tried that i wish he would is a 3-3-5 with our normal line and pulling andra davis in favor of mike adams and having adams play somewhat of a roaming role as a hybrid third corner/outside linebacker.
the big difference might be that d'qwell would be less exposed to having a center or guard come after him, but rogers always swallows at least two guys on any given play unless they let him run himself out of it, so there's minimal exposure to d'qwell as it is.
switching schemes entirely would set us back personnel-wise, and i don't think that's something we can afford at this point. we need a creative defensive mind who can draw up a scheme that works with the people we have, someone like rex ryan.