Hall of Fame QB win percentages

[wargograw]

@the-gipper said:

@mudfly said:

We know thats your opinion. And you know our opinion.

My point is that I presented an argument showing a consensus supporting Young as a top 10 all timer...

So, Ill ask again....can you produce the same to support your views?.....got any lists that show anyone else supports your argument(or do you just assume you know more than everyone else, including the HOF committee).(10 lists would be nice, since I easily did it).....or some top 10 lists w/o young?(cause I could get 20 more with him)...

Yea, here is a list: He is at best 6th among his own contemporaries:

Favre

Kelly

Elway

Marino

Aikman

All better. That means I only need to find 5 more from the rest of football history. Let's see:

How about Peyton, Brady, Brees

How about Graham, Unitas, Starr, Staubach, Bradshaw, Tarkenton, Baugh, Luckman

He said "anyone else."

[The Gipper]

@wargograw said:

He said "anyone else."

I am all the authority one needs.

at least in this regard.

[Zombo]

You're boy Kenny might get in after all. Got nominated as one of the Senior finalists for the Hall. I'd post the link but can't do it on this computer.

Z

[Tour2ma]

[The Gipper]

Zombo said:

You're boy Kenny might get in after all. Got nominated as one of the Senior finalists for the Hall. I'd post the link but can't do it on this computer.

Z

He'll get in. Along with Dick Stanfel.....and these other players:

Brett Favre

Kurt Warner

Orlando Pace

Marvin Harrison

Alan Faneca

plus a coach or contributor

T.O will have to wait a while.

[The Gipper]

Here are the semi-finalists from last year who did not make it.....I say that half of the new group (non Senior, non contributor) comes from this group...even if my choices aren't there:

Morten Anderson

Steve Atwater

Isaac Bruce

Don Coryell

Roger Craig

Terrell Davis

Tony Dungy

Kevin Greene

Tory Holt

Joe Jacoby

Edgerrin James

Jimmy Johnson

Mike Kenn

Ty Law

John Lynch

Kevin Mawae

Karl Mecklenberg

Kurt Warner

Darren Woodson

Orlando Pace

Marvin Harrison

[The Gipper]

@tour2ma said:

You need to go back to your own free speech zone and not intrude on mine.

[Tour2ma]

I meant it as a compliment, Gip...

No one beats a dead horse like you do.

[The Gipper]

@tour2ma said:

I meant it as a compliment, Gip...

No one beats a dead horse like you do.

I'm pretty good at riding a live one:

[The Gipper]

But, there are those who do it better: