Skip to content

Candidates

The Browns Board
119 44 4.8k
  • @the-gipper said:

    Here is to hoping that whomever they get can win. No matter what his status. 

    And no need to respond in depth....there is nothing you can say that would/could be  persuasive or intelligent on this subject.  

    I mean, think about it...why on earth would anyone have ever given Bill B.  a second chance after his failed stint here? 

    Because his stint wasn't failed.  The team improved each of the first 4 years and made the playoffs and won a game in the playoffs.   As the history professor around here you know that the 95 team was good as well and probably on the way to the playoffs again but once the move was announced the season went into the shitter.

    I say no to any "retread" coach who has already won a super bowl somewhere else.   They don't win again somewhere else...they just don't.  Some get close but they don't win again in a new place.

    As for a head coach who was good somewhere else and for whatever reason things went downhill and was fired, I'm not totally opposed to it but wouldn't be my preference.  I think a young coordinator who is hungry to take that step up to be the HC would be my choice.   I have no idea who this guy is, but that's my preference.

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #92

    @mark-o said:

    Because his stint wasn't failed.  The team improved each of the first 4 years and made the playoffs and won a game in the playoffs.   As the history professor around here you know that the 95 team was good as well and probably on the way to the playoffs again but once the move was announced the season went into the shitter.

    I say no to any "retread" coach who has already won a super bowl somewhere else.   They don't win again somewhere else...they just don't.  Some get close but they don't win again in a new place.

    As for a head coach who was good somewhere else and for whatever reason things went downhill and was fired, I'm not totally opposed to it but wouldn't be my preference.  I think a young coordinator who is hungry to take that step up to be the HC would be my choice.   I have no idea who this guy is, but that's my preference.

    Well, I think you prove my point.  I think, objectively, it appears that BBs time here was a failure.   He had 4 losing seasons out of the 5 he was here.....but as you say.... subjectively you could see the team was improving....and made the playoffs, and may have continued to get better if not for the stupidity of Modell.

    If there were a BB type "retread" out there, I would not just dismiss him out of hand simply because he had coached before.....as apparently D Bone would do.  And maybe that young hungry coordinator IS the way to go.  

    All I am saying is that there is no justification to eliminate any potential candidate simply because of some arbitrary status he may hold, be that former HC, college HC,  age,  whether he coach offense, or defense, etc.  etc.

  • @mark-o said:

    Because his stint wasn't failed.  The team improved each of the first 4 years and made the playoffs and won a game in the playoffs.   As the history professor around here you know that the 95 team was good as well and probably on the way to the playoffs again but once the move was announced the season went into the shitter.

    I say no to any "retread" coach who has already won a super bowl somewhere else.   They don't win again somewhere else...they just don't.  Some get close but they don't win again in a new place.

    As for a head coach who was good somewhere else and for whatever reason things went downhill and was fired, I'm not totally opposed to it but wouldn't be my preference.  I think a young coordinator who is hungry to take that step up to be the HC would be my choice.   I have no idea who this guy is, but that's my preference.

    Well, I think you prove my point.  I think, objectively, it appears that BBs time here was a failure.   He had 4 losing seasons out of the 5 he was here.....but as you say.... subjectively you could see the team was improving....and made the playoffs, and may have continued to get better if not for the stupidity of Modell.

    If there were a BB type "retread" out there, I would not just dismiss him out of hand simply because he had coached before.....as apparently D Bone would do.  And maybe that young hungry coordinator IS the way to go.  

    All I am saying is that there is no justification to eliminate any potential candidate simply because of some arbitrary status he may hold, be that former HC, college HC,  age,  whether he coach offense, or defense, etc.  etc.

    Mark OM Mark O wrote on last edited by
    #93

    @the-gipper said:

    All I am saying is that there is no justification to eliminate any potential candidate simply because of some arbitrary status he may hold, be that former HC, college HC,  age,  whether he coach offense, or defense, etc.  etc.

    Unless he's already won a super bowl somewhere else because it doesn't happen again with a different franchise.

  • KvoetheK Kvoethe wrote on last edited by
    #94

    Im hearing Mike Mcarthy rumors.

  • Im hearing Mike Mcarthy rumors.

    Mark OM Mark O wrote on last edited by
    #95

    @kvoethe said:

    Im hearing Mike Mcarthy rumors.

    He was a name thrown out by someone on NFL network yesterday as a long shot candidate because of his ties to Dorsey and if the Packers decided to move on from him.  Lots of ifs and everything is just speculation and rumors at this point.   Hell, it could be Gregg Williams team again next year for all we know.

  • @the-gipper said:

    All I am saying is that there is no justification to eliminate any potential candidate simply because of some arbitrary status he may hold, be that former HC, college HC,  age,  whether he coach offense, or defense, etc.  etc.

    Unless he's already won a super bowl somewhere else because it doesn't happen again with a different franchise.

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by
    #96

    @mark-o said:

    Unless he's already won a super bowl somewhere else because it doesn't happen again with a different franchise.

    It could have, easily.  If not for referree intervention, Holmgren could have had a title in Seattle as well as Green Bay. 

    Six coaches have taken two teams to Super Bowls with 2 different teams:

    Don Shula,  lost 1 with Colts,  won 2 lost 3 with the Dolphins

    Dan Reeves,  lost 3 with Broncos and lost 1 with Falcons

    Bill Parcells, won 2 with Giants,  lost 1 with Pats

    Holmgren,  won 1 lost 1 with Packers, lost 1 with Seattle

    finger Vermeil,   lost 1 with Eagles, won 1 with Rams

    John Fox,  lost 1 with  Panthers and lost 1 with Denver

    What you may be saying actually is.....if you hire a coach that has appeared in a Super Bowl.....make sure he lost it .....as coaches that lost have had more success the second time around, where no one who has won has ever come back to win again:  Shula and Vermeil came back to win with a new team, having lost and not won with a previous team.  

    So, that could mean we could consider these......who have lost SBs but not won: Fox, Jim Caldwell, Ken Whisenhunt, Lovie Smith, Bill Callahan, Mike Martz, Jim Fassell, Jeff Fisher, Bobby Ross, Sam Wyche, etc.  😉

  • @mark-o said:

    Unless he's already won a super bowl somewhere else because it doesn't happen again with a different franchise.

    It could have, easily.  If not for referree intervention, Holmgren could have had a title in Seattle as well as Green Bay. 

    Six coaches have taken two teams to Super Bowls with 2 different teams:

    Don Shula,  lost 1 with Colts,  won 2 lost 3 with the Dolphins

    Dan Reeves,  lost 3 with Broncos and lost 1 with Falcons

    Bill Parcells, won 2 with Giants,  lost 1 with Pats

    Holmgren,  won 1 lost 1 with Packers, lost 1 with Seattle

    finger Vermeil,   lost 1 with Eagles, won 1 with Rams

    John Fox,  lost 1 with  Panthers and lost 1 with Denver

    What you may be saying actually is.....if you hire a coach that has appeared in a Super Bowl.....make sure he lost it .....as coaches that lost have had more success the second time around, where no one who has won has ever come back to win again:  Shula and Vermeil came back to win with a new team, having lost and not won with a previous team.  

    So, that could mean we could consider these......who have lost SBs but not won: Fox, Jim Caldwell, Ken Whisenhunt, Lovie Smith, Bill Callahan, Mike Martz, Jim Fassell, Jeff Fisher, Bobby Ross, Sam Wyche, etc.  😉

    Mark OM Mark O wrote on last edited by
    #97

    @the-gipper said:

    So, that could mean we could consider these......who have lost SBs but not won: Fox, Jim Caldwell, Ken Whisenhunt, Lovie Smith, Bill Callahan, Mike Martz, Jim Fassell, Jeff Fisher, Bobby Ross, Sam Wyche, etc.  😉

    That list completely and totally depresses me.  

  • @tacosman said:

    lmao....Riley makes over 5 million a year now and is likely to bump up to 6.5-7 shortly if they make the playoff.....he proably wouldnt even take the Browns HC ob if offered.  The idea that he is going to go from a perfect HC situation at OU to a coordinator job anywhere in the nfl is absurd.

    And tell me how or when I remotely said he would? I swear to God, some of you mofos just love posting dramatic crap because you love how panties feel bunched up in your butt.

    Yes wise guy I understand he wouldn't take an OC job. I was simply stating that ideally I'd want to see Riley succeed offensively in the NFL like McVay did before taking the plunge. We've seen too many wonder coaches from the NCAA ranks (Chip Kelly anyone?) fall flat on their faces. I don't think the Browns can afford to take that risk.

    T Tacosman wrote on last edited by
    #98

    @jrb12711 said:

    And tell me how or when I remotely said he would? I swear to God, some of you mofos just love posting dramatic crap because you love how panties feel bunched up in your butt.

    Yes wise guy I understand he wouldn't take an OC job. I was simply stating that ideally I'd want to see Riley succeed offensively in the NFL like McVay did before taking the plunge. We've seen too many wonder coaches from the NCAA ranks (Chip Kelly anyone?) fall flat on their faces. I don't think the Browns can afford to take that risk.

    ummm...so whats the point of posting that then? Since there is no chance in hell he would ever go that path now....at least you should have phrased it "I WOULD HAVE wanted....."

  • W Westside Steve wrote on last edited by
    #99

    And a possibility to come back to Cleveland?

    Seems like I just heard the talking heads on the radio say they loved him in Minnesota.

    https://www.dailynorseman.com/2018/10/30/18045926/is-defilippowatch-officially-on-minnesota-vikings-john-defilippo-cleveland-browns

    WSS

  • OrionO Orion wrote on last edited by

    I started a thread on him a day or so ago.   I liked him when he was here.

  • flyingfooldougF flyingfooldoug wrote on last edited by

    Isn’t he teamed up with Pet there?

  • @jrb12711 said:

    And tell me how or when I remotely said he would? I swear to God, some of you mofos just love posting dramatic crap because you love how panties feel bunched up in your butt.

    Yes wise guy I understand he wouldn't take an OC job. I was simply stating that ideally I'd want to see Riley succeed offensively in the NFL like McVay did before taking the plunge. We've seen too many wonder coaches from the NCAA ranks (Chip Kelly anyone?) fall flat on their faces. I don't think the Browns can afford to take that risk.

    ummm...so whats the point of posting that then? Since there is no chance in hell he would ever go that path now....at least you should have phrased it "I WOULD HAVE wanted....."

    jrb12711J jrb12711 wrote on last edited by jrb12711

    @tacosman said:

    ummm...so whats the point of posting that then? Since there is no chance in hell he would ever go that path now....at least you should have phrased it "I WOULD HAVE wanted....."

    My exact quote is " I'd want to see Riley start as an OC in the NFL at least a year before jumping head first into that situation. " Perhaps you never learned about contractions in school, but "I'd" in that sentence means "I would". Grammar is fun!

    The point is provide a counterargument to a popular opinion on a head coach as conversation on a football forum. Hey bud, nice try though.

  • Isn’t he teamed up with Pet there?

    darren15D darren15 wrote on last edited by

    @flyingfooldoug said:

    Isn’t he teamed up with Pet there?

    Pet is in Green Bay isnt he ?

  • @flyingfooldoug said:

    Isn’t he teamed up with Pet there?

    Pet is in Green Bay isnt he ?

    nickersN nickers wrote on last edited by

    @darren15 said:

    Pet is in Green Bay isnt he ?

    yes!

  • @flyingfooldoug said:

    Isn’t he teamed up with Pet there?

    Pet is in Green Bay isnt he ?

    flyingfooldougF flyingfooldoug wrote on last edited by flyingfooldoug

    @darren15 said:

    Pet is in Green Bay isnt he ?

    Ok, I knew he was NFCN 

  • M MDDawg wrote on last edited by

    I also liked him while he was here, our offense outperformed it's talent and I hoped he'd be retained after Haslam bought the franchise.

  • D BoneD D Bone wrote on last edited by

    Here we go..... 

  • David Shaw from Stanford is another name to watch.

    LogicIsForSquaresL LogicIsForSquares wrote on last edited by

    @mark-o said:

    David Shaw from Stanford is another name to watch.

    I wouldn't be mad at this.

  • darren15D darren15 wrote on last edited by darren15

    Why would you trade for someone you can talk to at the end of the season for free .... I would want to have someone who wanted to be here not made to be here via a trade

    ESPN Cleveland‏ @ESPNCleveland 4m4 minutes ago
    ESPN Cleveland@ESPNCleveland
    Florio says not to discount the possibility that the Browns could trade for their next head coach. Who is the favorite? Mike says Josh McDaniels.
    More

    Florio says not to discount the possibility that the Browns could trade for their next head coach. Who is the favorite? Mike says Josh McDaniels.

  • Why would you trade for someone you can talk to at the end of the season for free .... I would want to have someone who wanted to be here not made to be here via a trade

    ESPN Cleveland‏ @ESPNCleveland 4m4 minutes ago
    ESPN Cleveland@ESPNCleveland
    Florio says not to discount the possibility that the Browns could trade for their next head coach. Who is the favorite? Mike says Josh McDaniels.
    More

    Florio says not to discount the possibility that the Browns could trade for their next head coach. Who is the favorite? Mike says Josh McDaniels.

    The GipperT The Gipper wrote on last edited by

    @darren15 said:

    Why would you trade for someone you can talk to at the end of the season for free .... I would want to have someone who wanted to be here not made to be here via a trade

    Florio says not to discount the possibility that the Browns could trade for their next head coach. Who is the favorite? Mike says Josh McDaniels.

    McDaniels is the HC in waiting of the Patriots.   When BB and TB are done, he takes over. He is only just now 42. 

  • @darren15 said:

    Why would you trade for someone you can talk to at the end of the season for free .... I would want to have someone who wanted to be here not made to be here via a trade

    Florio says not to discount the possibility that the Browns could trade for their next head coach. Who is the favorite? Mike says Josh McDaniels.

    McDaniels is the HC in waiting of the Patriots.   When BB and TB are done, he takes over. He is only just now 42. 

    Mark OM Mark O wrote on last edited by

    @the-gipper said:

    McDaniels is the HC in waiting of the Patriots.   When BB and TB are done, he takes over. He is only just now 42. 

    I agree.  I really don't see him leaving New England.  I would also think that teams will be a bit gun shy with him after last year.