Skip to content
The Browns Board
  1. Home
  2. The Browns Board
  3. Tradition aside, would you protest the NFL if they eliminated placekicking?

Tradition aside, would you protest the NFL if they eliminated placekicking?

The Browns Board
61 26 1.7k

  • Why not eliminate the 6 points for a touchdown?

    Just issue participation trophies, so nobody wins, and nobody loses.

    Then trolls would have no reason to come here and stink up the board.

    And, during the game, on every play not a touchdown, they could just line up,

    and the captains of each team on offense...could just roll dice, and as long as they roll

    a double, they get double participation points. But the team with more participation

    points, would lose a turn until the other team catches up....

    Well, that would make all the pansies happy.

    Our country is just headed in a bad direction. Old school ROCKS - it's time tested,

    blood sweat and tears tempered, a couple of centuries to build it.

    Well, dropping the extra is just plain stupid.

  • A team winning because the other team's kicker missed a FG is much closer to participation trophy than a team actually having to win with their gladiators.

  • Z Zombo

    Fundamental part of the game. I enjoy the kicking aspect.

    Z

    Zombo said:

    Fundamental part of the game. I enjoy the kicking aspect.

    Nailed it...

    @mudfly said:

    wouldnt change a thing....except maybe bring back the drop kick... 😉

    It is still a thing, isn't it? I know Fluties kicked one for the Pats IIRC a while ago.

    @ibleedbrown said:

    Just saw a window for a joke. Not seriously bashing anyone.

    Agree... a serious bash would have worked "the gf" into it somehow.

    "When you have a shared vision it is a lot easier to make unpopular decisions." - Paul DePodesta "When you win, say nothing. When you lose, say less." - Paul Brown Complete 2017 Browns Board Mock: http://thebrownsboard.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=46196

  • Is the game decided by the kicker or the QB and offense who have gone 60 yards down the field to get into range?

    It's of course the latter.

  • W wargograw

    No, it's not easy, and they're wimps, so they shouldn't control the outcome of the game.

    @wargograw said:

    No, it's not easy, and they're wimps, so they shouldn't control the outcome of the game.

    Yeah?.. Try calling Matt Bahr a wimp.. He was a kicker on the Browns back in the 80's.. this kicker would tackle people.. wimps My ass...

    Nickers...."There are no old running QB's in the NFL "~Sam Rutigliano~
    W 1 Reply

  • Something that I've thought about for extra points is to do like rugby - the conversion (worth two points, 5 for a try) is taken from as close to the goal line as you want, but it is in line with where the try is scored (or the touchdown is scored). So if you score down the middle, you get an easy chip shot, but if you score in the corner you maybe have a 45-yarder from a narrow angle.

  • One old man's opinion....

    Do NOT take the foot out of football.

    Also, in the thread title, you mention "Tradtion aside..." We need MORE tradition, not less.

    Mike

    IN DORSEY I TRUST

  • You have to give the Turtle man credit for reaping so many responses to such a stupid fucking question.

    WSS

    www.westsidesteve.com www.myspace.com/westsidestevemusic www.cdbaby.com/artist/westsidestevesimmons
    gumby73G 1 Reply

  • Exactly what Steve just posted...

  • nickersN nickers

    @wargograw said:

    No, it's not easy, and they're wimps, so they shouldn't control the outcome of the game.

    Yeah?.. Try calling Matt Bahr a wimp.. He was a kicker on the Browns back in the 80's.. this kicker would tackle people.. wimps My ass...

    @nickers said:

    Yeah?.. Try calling Matt Bahr a wimp.. He was a kicker on the Browns back in the 80's.. this kicker would tackle people.. wimps My ass...

    Anecdotes are the enemy of real analysis.

  • W wargograw

    @skippinturtles said:

    No one talks to their friends about kickers for a reason. Their skill is purely fundamental. Why do we let these no-contact, non-athletes decide almost every game?

    Said exactly this for years. You've got 100 absolute gladiators killing each other for 60 minutes and the game is decided by the scrawny virgin guy. Ridiculous.

    @wargograw said:

    Said exactly this for years. You've got 100 absolute gladiators killing each other for 60 minutes and the game is decided by the scrawny virgin guy. Ridiculous.

    Our leading receiver is 5'10" and 195 lbs.

    I'm awesome, and I fuck dolphins. Ghoolie 12/2/2012: I have absolutely no skills, training or pride
    W 1 Reply
  • W Westside Steve

    You have to give the Turtle man credit for reaping so many responses to such a stupid fucking question.

    WSS

    @westside-steve said:

    You have to give the Turtle man credit for reaping so many responses to such a stupid fucking question.

    WSS

    Last chance TurtleMan. Do we ever want to see 300lbs. Lineman trying to kick it between the Pipes at end of Camp. NNNNOOOOOOO!! Game Over!! 🥷

    Browns & Buffett: Got to go fishin, Down to rock bottom again, with just a few Friends

  • Sebastian Janikowski would beat the shit outta many NFL players

    Mark OM W 2 Replies
  • B BaconHound

    Sebastian Janikowski would beat the shit outta many NFL players

    @baconhound said:

    Sebastian Janikowski would beat the shit outta many NFL players

    Depends on how many vodka/sodas he has had that day.

  • Mark OM Mark O

    @baconhound said:

    Sebastian Janikowski would beat the shit outta many NFL players

    Depends on how many vodka/sodas he has had that day.

    @mark-o said:

    Depends on how many vodka/sodas he has had that day.

    Or if he had any GHB in his system

  • Tim Couch Pulls OutT Tim Couch Pulls Out

    @wargograw said:

    Said exactly this for years. You've got 100 absolute gladiators killing each other for 60 minutes and the game is decided by the scrawny virgin guy. Ridiculous.

    Our leading receiver is 5'10" and 195 lbs.

    @tim-couch-pulls-out said:

    Our leading receiver is 5'10" and 195 lbs.

    And he works his butt off, takes huge hits, deals with corners that try to punch him at the line, etc.

    The potential of a kicker getting hit, despite it rarely happening, doesn't make him a gladiator.

    If you want to argue for the kickers then just stick to the "it's always been this way, so it should stay this way." Don't try to equate the general toughness of kickers with the rest of the team.

    Tim Couch Pulls OutT 1 Reply
  • B BaconHound

    Sebastian Janikowski would beat the shit outta many NFL players

    @baconhound said:

    Sebastian Janikowski would beat the shit outta many NFL players

    You guys equate "this guy is a bigger badass than myself" with "this guy is a bigger badass than NFL players" way too much.

    B 1 Reply
  • "We are Americans. We don't quit doing something because it's wrong. We just keep doing the wrong thing till it turns out right." Browns maybe the most American Football team ever.
  • Z Zombo

    @wargograw said:

    No, it's not easy, and they're wimps, so they shouldn't control the outcome of the game.

    Our punter and our kicker are both bigger than our backup QB and could probaly take him in a street fight. I have no doubt, CoonDawg could.

    Z

    Zombo said:

    Our punter and our kicker are both bigger than our backup QB and could probaly take him in a street fight. I have no doubt, CoonDawg could.

    Z

    I have to admit in over 50 years of watching the NFL, I can't think of another kicker getting a flag thrown for an unnecessary roughness penalty.
    Two things that will define you: Your determination when you have nothing. Your attitude when you have everything. - Mike McCartney
  • W wargograw

    @tim-couch-pulls-out said:

    Our leading receiver is 5'10" and 195 lbs.

    And he works his butt off, takes huge hits, deals with corners that try to punch him at the line, etc.

    The potential of a kicker getting hit, despite it rarely happening, doesn't make him a gladiator.

    If you want to argue for the kickers then just stick to the "it's always been this way, so it should stay this way." Don't try to equate the general toughness of kickers with the rest of the team.

    @wargograw said:

    And he works his butt off, takes huge hits, deals with corners that try to punch him at the line, etc.

    The potential of a kicker getting hit, despite it rarely happening, doesn't make him a gladiator.

    If you want to argue for the kickers then just stick to the "it's always been this way, so it should stay this way." Don't try to equate the general toughness of kickers with the rest of the team.

    So kickers don't work their butt off? They don't take huge hits? I've seen just as many highlight videos of kickers getting blindside blasted as I have wide receivers.

    What's the matter, a kicker fuck your boyfriend?

    I'm awesome, and I fuck dolphins. Ghoolie 12/2/2012: I have absolutely no skills, training or pride
Log in to reply