Skip to content

Why We Need A Qb

The Browns Board
132 31 4.1k
  • @brownfish said:

    you do not need a great QB to get there... Flaco, Yates, Tebow, A. Smith. If stephen hawkings could coach a footaball team their offense would be awesome...our running backs would run into a black hole and shoot out a worm hole for a TD.

    Flacco, Tebow, and Smith were all first round draft picks.

    I don't understand the point you are trying to make.

    @tim-couch-pulls-out said:

    Flacco, Tebow, and Smith were all first round draft picks.

    I don't understand the point you are trying to make.

    Draft position does not denote talent in the nfl

    Best guard in the league was a 5th round pick

    Reigning MVP was a 6th round pick

    Most consistent WR went undrafted

    Don't pretend like the reason you need a QB is because colt isn't a first round pick

    Don't be that dumb

  • @tim-couch-pulls-out said:

    Flacco, Tebow, and Smith were all first round draft picks.

    I don't understand the point you are trying to make.

    Draft position does not denote talent in the nfl

    Best guard in the league was a 5th round pick

    Reigning MVP was a 6th round pick

    Most consistent WR went undrafted

    Don't pretend like the reason you need a QB is because colt isn't a first round pick

    Don't be that dumb

    @cantonlegend said:

    Draft position does not denote talent in the nfl

    Best guard in the league was a 5th round pick

    Reigning MVP was a 6th round pick

    Most consistent WR went undrafted

    Don't pretend like the reason you need a QB is because colt isn't a first round pick

    Don't be that dumb

    You are clearly being the dumb one. Look at those players in the HOF. Look at who is named Pro Bowl, look at who is named All Pro. A greater percentage of the players designated as such come from the first round of the draft....and it goes down incrementally from there a you get to players in the lower rounds.

    Yes, you are going to find the exceptions. Yes you will find a Brady in the 6th round....but you will need a first rounder to find a Manning, a Rodgers, a BR, a Flacco, a Ryan, a Newton, a Freeman, a Palmer, a Rivers etc. etc. etc.

  • @cantonlegend said:

    Draft position does not denote talent in the nfl

    Best guard in the league was a 5th round pick

    Reigning MVP was a 6th round pick

    Most consistent WR went undrafted

    Don't pretend like the reason you need a QB is because colt isn't a first round pick

    Don't be that dumb

    You are clearly being the dumb one. Look at those players in the HOF. Look at who is named Pro Bowl, look at who is named All Pro. A greater percentage of the players designated as such come from the first round of the draft....and it goes down incrementally from there a you get to players in the lower rounds.

    Yes, you are going to find the exceptions. Yes you will find a Brady in the 6th round....but you will need a first rounder to find a Manning, a Rodgers, a BR, a Flacco, a Ryan, a Newton, a Freeman, a Palmer, a Rivers etc. etc. etc.

    @the-gipper said:

    You are clearly being the dumb one. Look at those players in the HOF. Look at who is named Pro Bowl, look at who is named All Pro. A greater percentage of the players designated as such come from the first round of the draft....and it goes down incrementally from there a you get to players in the lower rounds.

    Yes, you are going to find the exceptions. Yes you will find a Brady in the 6th round....but you will need a first rounder to find a Manning, a Rodgers, a BR, a Flacco, a Ryan, a Newton, a Freeman, a Palmer, a Rivers etc. etc. etc.

    Or you could find guys like Jamarcus russel, Tim couch, ryan leaf, Alex smith, akili smith, etc etc etc

    First round QBs are a gamble

    You can hit or miss and set ur franchise up for success...or set ur franchise back another decade

  • Read this

    http://blogs.palmbeachpost.com/thedailydolphin/2011/04/17/by-the-numbers-first-round-quarterbacks-dominate-nfl-landscape/

    The draft is a gamble. Stick with the proven commodity in colt who is still growing and learning

  • @the-gipper said:

    You are clearly being the dumb one. Look at those players in the HOF. Look at who is named Pro Bowl, look at who is named All Pro. A greater percentage of the players designated as such come from the first round of the draft....and it goes down incrementally from there a you get to players in the lower rounds.

    Yes, you are going to find the exceptions. Yes you will find a Brady in the 6th round....but you will need a first rounder to find a Manning, a Rodgers, a BR, a Flacco, a Ryan, a Newton, a Freeman, a Palmer, a Rivers etc. etc. etc.

    Or you could find guys like Jamarcus russel, Tim couch, ryan leaf, Alex smith, akili smith, etc etc etc

    First round QBs are a gamble

    You can hit or miss and set ur franchise up for success...or set ur franchise back another decade

    @cantonlegend said:

    Or you could find guys like Jamarcus russel, Tim couch, ryan leaf, Alex smith, akili smith, etc etc etc

    First round QBs are a gamble

    You can hit or miss and set ur franchise up for success...or set ur franchise back another decade

    Yes, but if you take the number of first round QBs against the number of 2d, 3rd, 4th etc. round QBs, you will probably hit more on the first round than in any other round.

  • Read this

    http://blogs.palmbeachpost.com/thedailydolphin/2011/04/17/by-the-numbers-first-round-quarterbacks-dominate-nfl-landscape/

    The draft is a gamble. Stick with the proven commodity in colt who is still growing and learning

    @cantonlegend said:

    Read this

    http://blogs.palmbeachpost.com/thedailydolphin/2011/04/17/by-the-numbers-first-round-quarterbacks-dominate-nfl-landscape/

    The draft is a gamble. Stick with the proven commodity in colt who is still growing and learning

    OK, but that is another question altogether.

  • Read this

    http://blogs.palmbeachpost.com/thedailydolphin/2011/04/17/by-the-numbers-first-round-quarterbacks-dominate-nfl-landscape/

    The draft is a gamble. Stick with the proven commodity in colt who is still growing and learning

    @cantonlegend said:

    Read this

    http://blogs.palmbeachpost.com/thedailydolphin/2011/04/17/by-the-numbers-first-round-quarterbacks-dominate-nfl-landscape/

    The draft is a gamble. Stick with the proven commodity in colt who is still growing and learning

    Since when has colt proven himself...

  • @cantonlegend said:

    Or you could find guys like Jamarcus russel, Tim couch, ryan leaf, Alex smith, akili smith, etc etc etc

    First round QBs are a gamble

    You can hit or miss and set ur franchise up for success...or set ur franchise back another decade

    Yes, but if you take the number of first round QBs against the number of 2d, 3rd, 4th etc. round QBs, you will probably hit more on the first round than in any other round.

    @the-gipper said:

    Yes, but if you take the number of first round QBs against the number of 2d, 3rd, 4th etc. round QBs, you will probably hit more on the first round than in any other round.

    More QBs get drafted in the first round than any other...that alone is going to skew numbers

    Not only that but if you pay a qb first round money you are likely to give him time to succeed before cutting ties. Problem with that logic is that the browns have 2 guys that have proven already to be better than several former first round picks but neither of them will be given the same time to progress in this offense that you'd give a first rounder

  • @cantonlegend said:

    Read this

    http://blogs.palmbeachpost.com/thedailydolphin/2011/04/17/by-the-numbers-first-round-quarterbacks-dominate-nfl-landscape/

    The draft is a gamble. Stick with the proven commodity in colt who is still growing and learning

    Since when has colt proven himself...

    @bills-n-browns-fan said:

    Since when has colt proven himself...

    In less than 2 full seasons of starting colt is already an above average qb in this league and that's without any help from his running game and WRs.

  • @bills-n-browns-fan said:

    Since when has colt proven himself...

    In less than 2 full seasons of starting colt is already an above average qb in this league and that's without any help from his running game and WRs.

    @cantonlegend said:

    In less than 2 full seasons of starting colt is already an above average qb in this league and that's without any help from his running game and WRs.

    I would love to see any statistic that shows that Colt is "above average" at anything in the NFL so far.

  • @cantonlegend said:

    In less than 2 full seasons of starting colt is already an above average qb in this league and that's without any help from his running game and WRs.

    I would love to see any statistic that shows that Colt is "above average" at anything in the NFL so far.

    @mark-o said:

    I would love to see any statistic that shows that Colt is "above average" at anything in the NFL so far.

    He certainly had an "above average" offense to work with right?

  • @bills-n-browns-fan said:

    Since when has colt proven himself...

    In less than 2 full seasons of starting colt is already an above average qb in this league and that's without any help from his running game and WRs.

    @cantonlegend said:

    In less than 2 full seasons of starting colt is already an above average qb in this league and that's without any help from his running game and WRs.

    With the PURE SHITSTORM that was the Browns offense this year, he had 16 tds to 13 ints. with no run game.

    But no RG3 scored 67 points against Washington! He's already better than Colt!

    People need to stfu about rg3

  • Great...16 TD's to 13 int's. How many TD's late in games against prevent defenses? How many wins did this "above average" QB lead us to?

    He's servicable and not terrible but he's no where near being above average at anything except that he can take a beating.

  • Great...16 TD's to 13 int's. How many TD's late in games against prevent defenses? How many wins did this "above average" QB lead us to?

    He's servicable and not terrible but he's no where near being above average at anything except that he can take a beating.

    @mark-o said:

    Great...16 TD's to 13 int's. How many TD's late in games against prevent defenses? How many wins did this "above average" QB lead us to?

    He's servicable and not terrible but he's no where near being above average at anything except that he can take a beating.

    But how in God's name do you expect anything better with the O of this year man? Actually, I bet you would've expected worse out of McCoy if you knew before the season what our offense would be diminished to.

    If live gives you lemons, make lemonade. McCoy was given lemon seeds and a pitcher. Thats it. It takes more to make lemonade than that. Especially good tasting lemonade.

    So can we give McCoy some sugar, water, a mixing spoon, a nice stand set up to sell it by the street, and an O-Coordinator? I think he's earned it.

  • @the-gipper said:

    You are clearly being the dumb one. Look at those players in the HOF. Look at who is named Pro Bowl, look at who is named All Pro. A greater percentage of the players designated as such come from the first round of the draft....and it goes down incrementally from there a you get to players in the lower rounds.

    Yes, you are going to find the exceptions. Yes you will find a Brady in the 6th round....but you will need a first rounder to find a Manning, a Rodgers, a BR, a Flacco, a Ryan, a Newton, a Freeman, a Palmer, a Rivers etc. etc. etc.

    Or you could find guys like Jamarcus russel, Tim couch, ryan leaf, Alex smith, akili smith, etc etc etc

    First round QBs are a gamble

    You can hit or miss and set ur franchise up for success...or set ur franchise back another decade

    @cantonlegend said:

    Or you could find guys like Jamarcus russel, Tim couch, ryan leaf, Alex smith, akili smith, etc etc etc

    First round QBs are a gamble

    You can hit or miss and set ur franchise up for success...or set ur franchise back another decade

    hahahaha and QB's aren't even more of a gamble in other rounds? duuuuuuuuuuude.

  • @cantonlegend said:

    Or you could find guys like Jamarcus russel, Tim couch, ryan leaf, Alex smith, akili smith, etc etc etc

    First round QBs are a gamble

    You can hit or miss and set ur franchise up for success...or set ur franchise back another decade

    hahahaha and QB's aren't even more of a gamble in other rounds? duuuuuuuuuuude.

    @pumpkin-eater said:

    hahahaha and QB's aren't even more of a gamble in other rounds? duuuuuuuuuuude.

    It's different with a busted 4th round as opposed to a bust in the 1st round dude. The Browns need all the help they can get in other places besides QB. Which is why I hate drafting a QB in the 1st. We obviously need a top WR, DE, LB, CB, RT, and HB more than a QB in the 1st.

  • We need to get all the pieces in place then look for a QB.

  • We need to get all the pieces in place then look for a QB.

    @mr.-t said:

    We need to get all the pieces in place then look for a QB.

    I'm not the only one on here that's not on the R2D2 bandwagon. Thank you. Picks in the 1st should be a WR and LB

  • @cantonlegend said:

    In less than 2 full seasons of starting colt is already an above average qb in this league and that's without any help from his running game and WRs.

    With the PURE SHITSTORM that was the Browns offense this year, he had 16 tds to 13 ints. with no run game.

    But no RG3 scored 67 points against Washington! He's already better than Colt!

    People need to stfu about rg3

    @typicalbrowns said:

    With the PURE SHITSTORM that was the Browns offense this year, he had 16 tds to 13 ints. with no run game.

    But no RG3 scored 67 points against Washington! He's already better than Colt!

    People need to stfu about rg3

    Nobody is saying hes already better than McCoy as far as im aware,i think they are saying he has a higher ceiling than McCoy...We pretty much know how good McCoy can be which is a good serviceable QB where if RG3 reaches his potential he has superstar capability..

  • Great...16 TD's to 13 int's. How many TD's late in games against prevent defenses? How many wins did this "above average" QB lead us to?

    He's servicable and not terrible but he's no where near being above average at anything except that he can take a beating.

    @mark-o said:

    Great...16 TD's to 13 int's. How many TD's late in games against prevent defenses? How many wins did this "above average" QB lead us to?

    He's servicable and not terrible but he's no where near being above average at anything except that he can take a beating.

    16 TDs to 13 INTs is not terrible. McCoy only had 3 touchdowns in garbage time situations so even if you take those away it is 13 TDs to 13 INTs. And players don't win games - teams do..

    I say use most of our early draft picks on building our offense (WR, RB) and draft a QB in the 4th round who can learn behind McCoy and Wallace. Then draft a QB higher in the 2013 draft if McCoy still can't cut it. But 13 TDs to 13 INTs with a crap offense tells me Colt might be able to go something like 20 TDs to 10 INTS with an improved offense. If not, it's not a big deal because we can still get better on offense without selecting a QB. The last thing I want to do is draft another QB that gets thrown in to start right away instead of being allowed time to develop as a backup. Rodgers, Brady, and Brees all had at least 1 year in the league before becoming a starter.. Rodgers had about 4.