@dutch-oven said:
Baker is a competent game manager at this point.
I still see nothing in his play that indicates he will ever progress to being a top-level starting QB.
But for now, he's plenty good enough to help the Browns progress from being a constant 10+ loss team to a competent, solid team.
But do I think he's a guy who will take the Browns from solid to legitimate playoff team/Super Bowl contender?
That's where I have some serious doubts.
Honestly, you could have had those kinds of doubts about 30-40% of the QBs that HAVE taken their teams to Super Bowls. If you go down the list of all QBs who have started in the Super Bowl, it is not like they are all HOF caliber.
Names: Lamonica, Morrall, Kapp, MOrton, Kilmer, Ferragamo, Jaworski, Anderson, Woodley, Theisman, Plunkett, Eason, McMahon, Simms, Williams, Esiason, Humphries, O'Donnell, McNair, Bledsoe, Dilfer, Johnson, Gannon, Delhomme, Hasselback, Grossman, McNabb.....All SB starters, all HOF eligible, none in. And then some actives: Flacco, Kaepernick, Foles, Goff, Garrapolo....not sure those are HOF caliber. I am not sure that Baker is any less capable than this whole list of names. You also have to have the rest of the team do its part.